Make us your home page

Judge rejects State Farm rate hike

A Tallahassee judge has rejected State Farm's bid for a 47 percent hike in property insurance rates, raising the specter that Florida's biggest private insurer could drop a significant number of policies statewide.

State Farm's original request was turned down by Florida Insurance Commissioner Kevin McCarty. In an appeal, the insurer said it could have justified a 67 percent increase because costs have spiked.

State Farm said it is collecting less in premiums because of big discounts given to customers who strengthen their homes against hurricanes.

Administrative Law Judge Daniel Manry rejected those arguments, writing that State Farm Florida did not prove that its rate filing "is not excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory.''

State Farm officials have repeatedly warned of potentially dire consequences if they were turned down — that they may have to shed a large number of policies or even pull out of Florida.

With about 1-million property insurance policies in Florida, State Farm of Bloomington, Ill., is by far the state's biggest private insurer, second only to state-run insurer of last resort Citizens Property Insurance.

Citizens' policy count has fluctuated dramatically: It swelled to 1.4-million in 2007 as private insurers fled because of the risk of hurricanes and their inability to persuade regulators to back double-digit rate hikes. But over the past year, small private insurers and start-up companies have selectively taken several hundred thousand policies out of Citizens.

The flood to Citizens left State Farm as the sole major private insurer, bigger than the next eight carriers combined. It has about 100,000 policyholders in the Tampa Bay area, almost one out of every six homeowners.

State Farm spokesman Chris Neal would not address whether State Farm would drop policies. But in a statement, Neal said the facts presented to Manry "should have led to a different recommendation.''

"We need to be able to pay our customers' claims, particularly those due to catastrophic events such as hurricanes. Our rate request is justified and necessary to stabilize State Farm Florida's rapidly deteriorating financial condition and to serve those customer needs,'' Neal said.

"We acknowledge that this rate increase poses a difficult situation for our customers, especially in light of these tough economic times; however, it is the only responsible choice.''

In rejecting State Farm initially, the state Office of Insurance Regulation said the company didn't follow state law and properly pass on to their customers savings from buying the state's cheap back-stop insurance.

McCarty's office has 30 days to issue a final order endorsing the judge's recommendations. Ed Domansky, a spokesman for McCarty, said there would be no further comment because the insurance commissioner acts as the final hearing officer.

Although McCarty is expected to echo Manry's recommendation, State Farm Florida urged him to take into account its "rapidly deteriorating financial condition.'' Earlier, State Farm Florida told employees it lost $200-million the first nine months of the year despite the lack of a major storm and continues to lose $20-million to $25-million a month.

After McCarty acts, State Farm could appeal to the 1st District Court of Appeal, but that route can be expensive and hasn't been common.

Earlier this year, administrative law judges ruled against Florida Farm Bureau and Hartford Insurance, which were some of the first companies to appeal the state's rejection of their rate hikes after lawmakers made it tougher for insurers to raise rates in 2007. Neither of those two companies subsequently filed an appeal.

Jeff Harrington can be reached at or (727) 893-8242.

Judge rejects State Farm rate hike 12/12/08 [Last modified: Tuesday, December 16, 2008 2:14pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Have your say Tampa Bay on the region's future transit options

    Mass Transit

    TAMPA — It's time, yet again, for Tampa Bay residents to tell officials what kind of transit options they want for their region.

    The Cross-Bay Ferry docks at the Tampa Convention Center on its maiden voyage on Nov. 1, 2016. A regional premium transit study will determine whether a ferry, or other options such as express buses or light rail, would be a good addition to Tampa Bay. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Times]
  2. SOCom seeks civilian drone pilots to develop new technology through ThunderDrone


    TAMPA — For the last three years, Nicole Abbett has been using drones as part of her photography business, with clients like the city of Tampa and construction companies.

    Josh Newby, 31, Palm Harbor, of Tampa Drones fly's a drone in England Brothers park, Pinellas Park, 8/25/16. As drone popularity increases as a hobby and business, local governments are navigating a legal grey area- where, when, and how should drone flights be allowed?
  3. New apartment complex delivers unique floor plans


    RIVERVIEW — A new luxury apartment community has opened in the Progress Village area touting itself as a distinct living option just 10 miles from downtown Tampa.

    Alta at Magnolia Park dubs its new apartment community, that opened earlier this year in Riverview, a modern and distinct option for living just 10 miles from downtown Tampa.
  4. 'Road to Nowhere' is back: Next phase of Suncoast Parkway coming


    Despite intense public opposition and dubious traffic projections, the Florida Department of Transportation has announced that construction of the toll road known as "Suncoast 2" is expected to start in early 2018.

    The Suncoast Parkway ends at U.S. 98 just south of Citrus County. For years residents have opposed extending the toll road, a project dubbed the "Suncoast 2" into Citrus County. But state officials recently announced that the Suncoast 2 should start construction in early 2018. [Stephen J. Coddington  |  TIMES]
  5. A sports rout on Wall Street


    NEW YORK — Sporting goods retailers can't shake their losing streak.