Make us your home page

Lawyers for WellCare defendants ask if 60 Minutes influenced verdict

TAMPA — Jurors in the WellCare fraud trial deliberated for more than three weeks before issuing mixed verdicts against four former executives in June.

Now the defendants want a federal judge to summon those jurors and ask them an unusual question: Did they catch that 60 Minutes episode on health care fraud?

On June 9, CBS ran an old 60 Minutes episode about fraud allegations at hospital chain Health Management Associates. It wasn't exactly a memorable night in television history. But in newly filed documents in federal court, attorneys for the four executives say the report "may have influenced some or all of the jurors' consideration of the evidence and tainted the verdict ultimately rendered."

The segment, called "The Cost of Admissions," was about allegations from HMA doctors that the chain had pressured them to admit patients regardless of their medical needs. It made no mention of WellCare, the Tampa managed-care company that handles services for a large number of Medicaid patients.

Defense lawyers note in their July 31 filings that the episode included an interview with HMA senior vice president Alan Levine, whose name may have been known to jurors because of his former position as head of the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration during the period WellCare was accused of ripping off the Medicaid program. Levine's name was mentioned during the trial, though he never testified.

The 60 Minutes report focused on "the economic costs of health care fraud and the impact of inflated and mischaracterized billing submissions to the government," the lawyers wrote.

On June 10, the jury found former chief executive officer Todd S. Farha, former chief financial officer Paul L. Behrens and former vice president William Kale guilty of two counts of health care fraud for submitting false expenditure reports to the state Medicaid program. The jury also found Behrens guilty of two other charges of making false statements related to health care matters.

A fourth defendant, former vice president Peter E. Clay, was found guilty of making false statements to federal agents.

On May 23, the jury had sent a note to the judge saying they were deadlocked on all counts, but they were told to keep trying. "The sudden progress and announcement of a verdict less than 18 hours after the episode aired compels (the defendants) to ask the court to interview the jurors to determine whether any of them viewed the episode or was made aware of its content," the defense team wrote.

Contact Jodie Tillman at or (813) 226-3374.

Lawyers for WellCare defendants ask if 60 Minutes influenced verdict 08/06/13 [Last modified: Tuesday, August 6, 2013 8:14pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Austin software company acquires second Tampa business


    Austin, Tex.-based Asure Software acquired Tampa's Compass HRM Inc. late last week for $6 million. Compass focuses on HR and payroll.

    [Company photo]
  2. Hackers hide cyberattacks in social media posts


    SAN FRANCISCO — It took only one attempt for Russian hackers to make their way into the computer of a Pentagon official. But the attack didn't come through an email or a file buried within a seemingly innocuous document.

    Jay Kaplan and Mark Kuhr, former NSA employees and co-founders of Synack, a cybersecurity company, in their office in Palo Alto, Calif., in 2013. While last year's hacking of senior Democratic Party officials raised awareness of the damage caused if just a handful of employees click on the wrong emails, few people realize that a message on Twitter or Facebook could give an attacker similar access to their system. 
[New York Times file photo]
  3. Big rents and changing tastes drive dives off St. Pete's 600 block

    Music & Concerts

    ST. PETERSBURG — Kendra Marolf was behind the lobby bar of the State Theatre, pouring vodka sodas for a weeknight crowd packed tight for Bishop Briggs, the latest alternative artist to sell out her club.

    Sam Picciano, 25, left, of Tampa and Molly Cord 24, Palm Harbor shop for record albums for a friend at Daddy Kool Records located on the 600 block of Central Avenue in St. Petersburg, Florida on Saturday, May 20, 2017. OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times
  4. How Hollywood is giving its biggest stars digital facelifts


    LOS ANGELES — Johnny Depp is 53 years old but he doesn't look a day over 26 in the new "Pirates of the Caribbean" movie — at least for a few moments. There was no plastic surgeon involved, heavy makeup or archival footage used to take the actor back to his boyish "Cry Baby" face, however. It's all …

    This combination of photos released by Disney, shows the character Jack Sparrow at two stages of his life in "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales."  Johnny Depp, who portrays the character, is the latest mega-star to get the drastic de-aging treatment on screen
[Disney via Associated Press]
  5. Precinct Pizza to cover new neighborhood


    NEW TAMPA — In 2006, husband and wife, Rick and Jessica Drury opened up Precinct Pizza in Channelside.

    Precinct Pizza looks to gain greater popularity in New Tampa with its Bambino Bleu Cheese piazza. Photo courtesy of Precinct Pizza.