Make us your home page

Robo-signing controversy could derail nation's entire foreclosure process

What began as scattered accusations of shoddy paperwork and fudged documents is mushrooming into a full-blown crisis threatening to derail the foreclosure process across the country.

Bank of America on Friday became the first big bank to temporarily halt foreclosures in all 50 states while it reviews hundreds of thousands of cases for potential paperwork errors.

For Florida, which has been slower than many states in attacking its foreclosure backlog, any delay threatens to not only clog courts further but also makes it harder for the overall market to reach any sort of price stability. Wary buyers will remain on the sidelines until they know the value of what they intend to purchase won't collapse.

The Bank of America announcement also created further jitters among title insurance companies, several of which are already scared away from offering "clear title" guarantees on foreclosed homes. Without those guarantees, most would-be buyers simply won't, or can't, go ahead with the purchase.

All of this comes as home sales are already slumping this summer, despite the lowest mortgage rates in decades.

"It's impossible at this point to state the magnitude of this, but the consequences are profound," said St. Petersburg lawyer Matt Weiden, a vocal critic of Florida's foreclosure system. "I believe there will be a shutdown of the entire mortgage foreclosure industry as this continues to spiral out of control."

Bank of America said Friday that only pending judgments and sales are affected. In other words, Bank of America customers won't be booted from their homes during the moratorium, but more could be served with the initial foreclosure paperwork.

Of the 14 million loans Bank of America services, more than 14 percent are past due or already in foreclosure. The bank wouldn't give details about its volume of Florida cases.

"Foreclosure sales will be held up until the ongoing assessment of documents is completed, which we anticipate will be within a few weeks," said bank spokesman Rick Simon.

Paperwork problems

Lenders and their law firms have been under fire for months, accused not only of shoddy work but using "robo-signers" to either sign affidavits that haven't been researched or forge documents outright.

The affidavits are used to verify whether loan documents and other records are correct. Judges rely on them to make sure lenders are on firm ground in kicking someone out of their home.

On Sept. 20, Ally Financial, previously known as GMAC, was the first lender to pause foreclosures in Florida and 22 other states where evictions need court approval. Bank of America followed with a temporary halt in the 23 states last week. JPMorgan Chase halted proceedings for about 56,000 homeowners. PNC Financial announced Friday that it, too, would postpone at least some foreclosures.

St. Petersburg lawyer Barry Wilkinson would not address Bank of America specifically but said he has seen many instances of paperwork errors and missing documents during the foreclosure process. Among them: affidavits that have the wrong name or wrong address and one certifying that a delinquent homeowner was served a court notice at a non-existent address.

Nick Bogos, a tax lawyer who is handling a foreclosure suit filed on his late brother's house in Tampa, was not surprised to hear of Bank of America's pullback.

During his involvement in the foreclosure process, he said, there was not only miscommunication on whether a deed in lieu of foreclosure could proceed but also conflicting paperwork about who even had title to the house: Bank of America or Fannie Mae.

Backlog could worsen

The impact of even a partial foreclosure hiatus has already hit the courts.

One senior judge in St. Petersburg found 50 percent of the foreclosure cases on the docket canceled on Tuesday, according to Pinellas-Pasco Chief Circuit Judge J. Thomas McGrady. And on Friday, another 18 cases were canceled.

Most of them were final hearing cases in which the judge would typically grant the foreclosure.

As of July 1, the Pinellas/Pasco district had 33,000 open mortgage cases. And every month, another 1,000 new cases are filed.

With federal stimulus money paying for more judges and case managers, McGrady said the circuit is trying to address 800 cases a week in four different courthouses. A foreclosure suspension will make it difficult to meet a goal of reducing the foreclosure case load by 62 percent by July.

McGrady said that since July, judges have sent back about 300 cases because of problems with the paperwork necessary to complete the foreclosure. Either they didn't attach the original note or they didn't complete the proper form of final judgment.

"It would appear from what we're seeing that some of them are trying to take some shortcuts," McGrady said.

As accusations of errors and fraud grow, some attorneys anticipate that banks may be forced to reopen past cases, creating havoc for lenders and title companies.

The issue goes far beyond sloppy affidavits to the core issue of improperly conveyed title to property, said Weiden, the foreclosure lawyer.

"Even a small percentage of title claims will be crippling not just to the title agency but the entire real estate industry," he said. "What these (foreclosure moratoriums) are, I believe, are the lenders taking a deep breath."

More uncertainty

As cases of canceled foreclosures continue to swell, Realtors are worrying about the ripple affects.

Fred Bullard III, broker and owner of Bullard Realty, said he expects to receive lots of calls from homeowners on the brink of a short sale who may be wondering if they should hold off.

"A lot of them will be dissuaded and will say, 'let's see what happens' rather than going ahead and getting started," he said.

Bullard worries that Congress might force a moratorium on all foreclosures. Sen. Christopher Dodd, D-Conn., the chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, announced Friday that he will hold a hearing to investigate allegations of improper mortgage servicing and foreclosure processing on Nov. 16, the day after the Senate returns from recess.

"That would be bad for the market," Bullard said. "Any time the natural forces of the market are interfered with, this creates instability."

Jon B. Coats, a real estate lawyer in Pinellas Park, said a foreclosure moratorium could stabilize or even slightly increase real estate prices initially since banks would stop flooding the market with low-priced homes. But once foreclosures began in earnest again, the reverse would happen.

"You would see thousands of homes flood the market, and you would see another decline in housing prices," he said.

Times staff writer Greg Hamilton contributed to this report, which also used information from Times wires.

What's the fallout from the foreclosure moratoriums?




What's the fallout from the foreclosure moratoriums?

Housing market – Creates more uncertainty, particularly for short sales and foreclosure sales already in process.

Courts – Legal experts predict that some foreclosure cases will have to start all over again, further clogging up Florida's already backlogged system.

Delinquent homeowners – A temporary reprieve from being kicked out of their homes, but it likely will only delay that day of reckoning.

Robo-signing controversy could derail nation's entire foreclosure process 10/08/10 [Last modified: Friday, October 8, 2010 10:37pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Starbucks to close all Teavana locations, including five in Tampa Bay


    Local Teavana locations include Tyrone Square in St. Petersburg, International Plaza and Westfield Citrus Park in Tampa, Brandon and Clearwater.

    Starbucks announced Thursday plans to shut down all 379 Teavana stores, citing "underperformance." Starbucks acquired the mall-based tea chain for $620 million in 2012. [ CANDICE CHOI | AP file photo]
  2. Trigaux: Closing Iron Yard coding school hits area tech hard but leaders talk of options


    The coming shutdown this fall of the Iron Yard software coding school in downtown St. Petersburg — announced this month as part of a national closing of all 15 Iron Yard locations — remains a shocking event to a Tampa Bay technology community that dreams big of becoming a major player in the Southeast if not …

    In better days last fall, friends and family of graduates at The Iron Yard, based in the Station House in downtown St. Petersburg, applaud during "Demo Day" when grads of the coding school show off their skills. Despite the local success and strong job placement by the coding school, The Iron Yard is closing all of its 15 locations across the country this summer. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]
  3. U.S. economy gathers steam in second quarter


    WASHINGTON — The U.S. economy revved up this spring after a weak start to the year, fueled by strong consumer spending. But the growth spurt still fell short of the optimistic goals President Donald Trump hopes to achieve through tax cuts and regulatory relief.

    A government report released Friday showed economic output picked up in the second quarter. 
[Associated Press file photo]
  4. Founder of Tampa home sharing platform questions Airbnb, NAACP partnership


    TAMPA — A Tampa rival to Airbnb, which was launched because of discrimination complaints on the dominant home sharing platform, has concerns about the new partnership between Airbnb and NAACP announced this week.

    Rohan Gilkes poses for a portrait at his home and business headquarters in Tampa. 

Innclusive, a Tampa-based start-up, is a home-sharing platform that focuses on providing a positive traveling experience for minorities. [CHARLIE KAIJO | Times]
  5. Appointments at Port Tampa Bay and Tampa General Medical Group highlight this week's Tampa Bay business Movers & Shakers



    Port Tampa Bay announced that Jamal Sowell has been named director of special projects. Sowell, a former member of the U.S.Marine Corps, will support internal, external and special projects, assist the executive team with management oversight and serve as a liaison on a variety of port …

    Port Tampa Bay announced this week that Jamal Sowell has been named director of special projects. [Handout photo]