Make us your home page

State Farm may stay for Florida homeowners

Ten months ago, State Farm was the scourge of Tallahassee when it announced plans to pull out of Florida's property insurance market.

Good riddance, Gov. Charlie Crist said at the time. "Floridians will be much better off without them.''

Insurance Commissioner Kevin McCarty insisted there was no cause for alarm, that some 700,000 homeowners policies shed by the biggest private insurer in the state would largely be absorbed by Florida startups.

Now regulators have changed their tune and say there's at least a chance that part of State Farm's homeowners business will stay.

McCarty and his deputies say they're "cautiously optimistic." They praise the value of having the good neighbor around.

"The commissioner has stated it would be beneficial for everyone if they did keep a presence here," McCarty spokesman Jack McDermott said Friday.

What's changed?

Not State Farm, which says, at least publicly, that it is still leaving and only negotiating with the state over terms of its withdrawal. Its hard-line stance is that its premiums are "woefully inadequate," making it impossible to stay.

The biggest difference between the Florida of 10 months ago and now: McCarty and his team of regulators are increasingly willing to approve premium hikes and give property insurers other incentives to keep them happily insuring.

State Farm's threat to pull out came after the state rejected its request for an average rate increase of 47 percent. Since then:

• Insurance regulators have approved numerous homeowners rate increases across the state. Universal Property and Casualty, the second-biggest private insurer behind State Farm, got the green light for an average 14.6 percent increase.

• Citizens Property Insurance, the state-run insurer for those who cannot find coverage in the open market, was approved for an average 5.4 percent rate hike for its base homeowners' policies and has a pending request for an average 7.7 percent increase for high-risk properties.

• Regulators said State Farm Florida could eliminate or reduce some discounts it offers its policyholders, effectively increasing premiums for homeowners as much as 28.4 percent. The decision will bring in $278 million in additional premiums for the company after all policies come up for renewals starting Dec. 1.

• There's a growing backlash against state-mandated mitigation credits that property insurers must give to those who take steps to shore up their homes against potential hurricane damage.

Insurers have criticized the program for depleting their premiums and say it is susceptible to fraud. Citizens Property recently approved a controversial $60 million "emergency plan" to inspect for cases of fraud among 400,000 policyholders who have received credits.

Arguably one of the most significant changes: Regulators have toned down their rhetoric against State Farm and other insurers. Despite another mild hurricane season, McCarty recently said he is sympathetic that property insurers deserve increases because they are receiving less in premiums and paying more for reinsurance.

State Farm spokesman Chris Neal said his company appreciates the attitude change.

"The tone has changed from last January when we filed our withdrawal," he said. "At least we're talking."

Still, Neal is adamant that "nothing has fundamentally changed.

"We do believe we're having very productive negotiations, but what we're negotiating is the withdrawal. … It's just that simple," he said.

"Our risk is still way too high, and our premiums are woefully inadequate. Until that changes, the only responsible thing that we can do is continue to seek to withdraw from this market."

The operative words being "until that changes."

Crist and McCarty are under a spotlight to keep as many insurance policies as possible in the hands of private insurers. A plan to grow Florida homeowners insurance companies has moved slowly, reflected by the fact Citizens still has more than 1 million policies. And that's before State Farm's mega-cancellation plan has even begun.

McDermott said each rate filing is considered on its own merits. Yet he leaves the door open for higher State Farm rates: "We've never stated we would not give them a rate increase," he said.

For now, both sides continue to talk as they've repeatedly postponed their case over the withdrawal plan terms now pending before the state Division of Administrative Hearings.

State Farm recently requested to postpone the hearing once more, pushing it to Jan. 25.

"If we didn't feel we were making progress, we wouldn't be doing that," Neal said.

In the end, State Farm may not get all of the 47 percent rate hike it originally demanded to stay. But its poker hand has gotten stronger.

Some have long argued the State Farm pullout has been a bluff from the start to angle for a huge rate hike.

If so, McCarty isn't calling their bluff. Rather, he's showing his hand at just how eagerly he wants State Farm to stay at the table.

Jeff Harrington can be reached at or (727) 893-8242. Follow him on Twitter at

State Farm may stay for Florida homeowners 11/15/09 [Last modified: Monday, November 16, 2009 10:38am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Trigaux: Halfway through 2017, a closer look at six drivers of the Tampa Bay economy


    We're nearly halfway through 2017 already, a perfect time to step back from the daily grind of business and ask: How's Tampa Bay's economy doing?

    Is there one theme or idea that captures the Tampa Bay brand? Not really but here's one possibility. The fun-loving annual Gasparilla "Invasion" of Tampa is captured in this photo of 
The Jose Gasparilla loaded with pirates of Ye Mystic Krewe of Gasparilla on its way this past January to the Tampa Convention Center. In the future a vibrant downtown Tampa or St. Petersburg may be the better theme. [CHRIS URSO   |   Times]
  2. Will new laws protect condo owners from apartment conversions and rogue associations?

    Real Estate

    Danny Di Nicolantonio has lived in St. Petersburg's Calais Village Condominums for 33 years. Annoyed at times by the actions, or inaction, of the condo board and property managers, he has complained to the state agency that is supposed to investigate.

    That has left him even more annoyed.

    A bill passed by the Florida Legislature would affect places like The Slade in Tampa's Channelside district, where cCondominium owners have battled a plan to convert homes into apartments.
[Times file photo]
  3. Walmart opens first Pinellas County in-house training academy


    Seminole — It had all the hallmarks of a typical graduation: robe-clad graduates marching in to Pomp and Circumstance, friends and family packed together under a sweltering tent and a lineup of speakers encouraging the graduates to take charge of their future.

    New Walmart Academy graduates are congratulated Thursday morning by associates during a graduation ceremony at the Walmart store, 10237 Bay Pines Boulevard, St. Petersburg. The Walmart location is one of the company's training academies where managers complete a one week retail course. David Shultz and Richard Sheehan, both from St. Petersburg, get high fives from the crowd.
[SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]

  4. Lawsuit: Florida contractor fakes death to dodge angry homeowners

    Human Interest

    SEMINOLE — For weeks, Glenn Holland, 67, crawled out of bed before the sun rose to look for a dead man.

    Last year Glenn and Judith Holland said they paid a contractor thousands of dollars to renovate their future retirement home in Seminole. But when they tried to move in on Dec. 14, they said the home was in shambles and uninhabitable. They sent a text message to contractor Marc Anthony Perez at 12:36 p.m. looking for answers. Fourteen minutes later, they got back this text: "This is Marc's daughter, dad passed away on the 7th of December in a car accident. Sorry." Turns out Perez was still alive. Now the Hollands are suing him in Pinellas-Pasco circuit court. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]
  5. Owners to level Port Richey flea market but may rebuild

    Public Safety

    PORT RICHEY — The owners of the recently shuttered USA Flea Market have agreed to demolish all structures on the property, leaving open the possibility of rebuilding the weekend shopping attraction, according to Pasco County officials.

    Pasco County officials shut down the USA Flea Market after it received hundreds of citations for health and code violations.