Make us your home page

Big-money donors slow to fully embrace recovery

In the world of big-bucks philanthropy, Florida's never been much of a player.

The wealthy, big givers who live in Florida tend to arrive in the Sunshine State later in life and tend to send their millions back to alma maters or hometown charities in distant states. The rest of the wealthy in the United States rarely seem motivated to toss $10 million, much less $50 million or more, to a Florida cause.

There are exceptions to the rule. Several Florida educational organizations hit the jackpot in 2009. More on those gifts in a moment).

The two Big Kahunas that rank major U.S. giving — the Chronicle of Philanthropy's Philanthropy 50 and the Slate 60 both list America's most generous people — acknowledge that 2009 was an unusually rough year. Thanks to the recession and last March's sharp blow to the stock market, the richest people naturally grew more cautious with their remaining wealth.

Total giving by the top 50 givers pancaked to $4.1 billion last year from $15.5 billion in 2008, almost a 75 percent decline. The median gift fell to $41.4 million from $69.3 million in 2008.

"In purely financial terms, last year was a dismal year for mega-gifts," the Chronicle stated. To qualify for the Philanthropy 50, the 50 most giving people in the country, a donor needed to part with just $16.2 million in 2009. In 2008, that number was $30.5 million, and in 2007 it was $39 million.

Even now, the unstable global economy has left many wary. The Dow has rebounded from last March's low of 6,500 to more than 10,000, but it remains far below its peak above 14,000 in 2007.

That volatility continues to unnerve the philanthropy world, just as it makes companies uneasy to hire. Donors and fundraisers both warn that big giving won't rebound to where it was for at least a few more years, if not longer.

The biggest philanthropic gift of 2009 came from Pittsburgh's Stanley Druckenmiller, who heads Duquesne Capital Management, and wife Fiona. The couple committed $705 million to their own foundation to support the Harlem Children's Zone and medical causes. Not too far behind was mutual fund pioneer John Templeton, whose $573 million went to his own foundation focused on the ties between spirituality and health.

Florida giving among the nation's top givers was nowhere near such Olympian heights. But a few recipients in the state did pretty well. Top of the list was the University of Florida, whose Florida Museum of Natural History in Gainesville received $41 million from a Minnesota couple. A separate gift of $21 million was pledged to UF's Shands Cancer Center in Gainesville. And $16 million was pledged to UF's business school.

Combined, that's $78 million from just three donors.

In Sarasota, the name Virginia Bernthal Toulmin is known as a benefactor of the local symphony, theater and arts communities. But last year, she gave a much more substantive $20 million to support nonprofits in Ohio, where she used to live.

And recent Florida resident Tom Golisano, at No. 50 on the Philanthropy 50 rankings, committed more than $16 million last year. Most of that went to his foundation in New York state. Of that sum, $4 million was pledged to Ave Maria University near Naples.

What's missing in this Florida list? A whopper: the $100 million to be funded over several years as a teacher effectiveness grant to the Hillsborough County school system from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. It was unveiled late last year.

If the sheer size of philanthropic gifts is shrinking, the giving has grown smarter, philanthropy experts say. The wealthy increasingly donate through their own foundations. That may help at tax time, but it also empowers givers to focus their money. Donors are more involved in their philanthropy.

In that spirit, fewer givers are waiting until their deaths to donate major sums. As for the lean and hungry recipients in this time of diminished philanthropy, they're happy for whatever they get.

Robert Trigaux can be reached at


In Florida: Philanthropists who gave in 2009

William and Nadine McGuire, Wayzata, Minn., gave a donation valued at approximately $41 million to the Florida Museum of Natural History, affiliated with the University of Florida in Gainesville. The donation includes a cash gift and a collection of more than 2 million butterfly and moth specimens, about 2,000 of which are now extinct. McGuire is a former CEO of UnitedHealth Group who resigned in 2006 amid regulatory investigations and legal complaints over alleged backdating of stock options.

Jerry and Judith Davis of Jacksonville pledged $21 million to the University of Florida's Shands Cancer Center in Gainesville. Both of the Davises are cancer survivors. Jerry is former chairman of Computer Management Sciences in Jacksonville.

Alfred C. Warrington IV's name already adorns UF's Warrington College of Business Administration, but he still pledged $16 million to establish an endowment to support faculty salaries and benefits. He graduated from the university with a business degree in 1958.

Virginia Bernthal Toulmin has lived for many years in Sarasota and is a patron of the local arts. But she chose to give a hefty $20 million to the Dayton Foundation in Ohio to support local nonprofits there. She says she and husband Harry, now deceased, had a happy and successful life there, and she wants to pay something back to Dayton.

Tom Golisano is founder of the Paychex payroll business in Rochester, N.Y., and an owner of the Buffalo Sabers pro hockey team. He has pledged $16 million, most of it back to his New York foundation, but took $4 million of it to help Florida's fledgling Ave Maria University build an indoor athletic facility. Before relocating to Naples, Golisano penned a newspaper opinion piece, Why I'm Leaving New York, criticizing the state for its high costs. Moving to Florida, Golisano wrote, will personally save him $13,800 every single day. "That," he said "is a pretty strong incentive."

Big-money donors slow to fully embrace recovery 02/13/10 [Last modified: Friday, February 12, 2010 7:13pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Where are Orlando's beaches? Pinellas tourism pitch urges visitors to head west


    For years, Florida's Space Coast has been known as Orlando's beaches.

    Pinellas tourism officials hope to lure Orlando visitors to Clearwater Beach and other West coast beaches in a new summertime campaign.

  2. ReliaQuest's benevolent hackers try to make companies more secure


    TAMPA — Their goal is to get in. Past a security desk, through a firewall, into a system they shouldn't have access to. Sometimes they'll look like a regular person in the lobby who innocently forgot their access badge. Most times they won't be seen at all, remotely and quietly prodding a company's systems from a …

    Angelo Castellano of Tampa works at his desk at ReliaQuest | | [CHARLIE KAIJO, Times]
  3. Despite soaring home prices, Tampa Bay still an affordable market

    Real Estate

    Times Staff Writer

    Finally, some good news for Tampa Bay home buyers. Despite rising prices, the bay area remains relatively affordable compared to many other parts of the country.

    Despite rising prices, the bay area remains relatively affordable compared to many other parts of the country. [Associated Press file photo]
  4. National economy off to a luckluster start this year


    WASHINGTON — The U.S. economy got off to a lackluster start during the first three months of 2017, though it enjoyed more momentum than earlier estimates indicated.

    he U.S. economy got off to a lackluster start during the first three months of 2017, though it enjoyed more momentum than earlier estimates indicated.
[Associated Press file photo]
  5. Last steel beam marks construction milestone for Tom and Mary James' museum


    ST. PETERSBURG — Tom and Mary James on Wednesday signed their names to the last steel beam framing the 105-ton stone mesa that will be built at the entrance of the museum that bears their name: the James Museum of Western and Wildlife Art.

    The topping-out ceremony of the James Museum of Western & Wildlife Art was held Wednesday morning in downtown St. Petersburg. Mary James (from left), husband Tom and Mayor Rick Kriseman signed the final beam before it was put into place. When finished, the $55 million museum at 100 Central Ave. will hold up to 500 pieces of the couple's 3,000-piece art collection. [Courtesy of James Museum of Western & Wildlife Art]