Wednesday, July 18, 2018
Business

3 strikes on mass transit: Did Tampa Bay just whiff as site for business expansion?

That's three strikes on mass transit. Did Tampa Bay just whiff on a top goal sought by the business community?

In 2010, the Moving Hillsborough Forward mass transit tax initiative was soundly defeated by voters in the midst of a recession. Strike one. In 2014, 62 percent of Pinellas County voters said no to the Greenlight Pinellas transit referendum, nixing a higher sales tax to expand bus service and build a 24-mile light rail system. Strike two.

On Wednesday night, Hillsborough County commissioners voted 4-3 against putting a half-cent-per-dollar sales tax for transportation before voters on the Nov. 8 ballot. Instead, the Go Hillsborough initiative was sent back to the drawing board. Strike three?

Three mass transit efforts. Three duds. It's beginning to feel like a deja vu plot from Groundhog Day.

Business leaders and corporate site selection experts contacted Thursday expressed frustration on three fronts. First, they lamented the inability, again, to move forward on meaningful mass transit. Second, they called for a major rethink on how to fund it. Three failed plans in six years seeking higher sales taxes clearly is not the way to win public opinion.

And third, they worried that yet another failed attempt to embrace mass transit could brand Tampa Bay as a business market that lacks the leadership to get things done.

"Ask any room of business leaders what is their most pressing issue," said Gary Sasso, CEO of Tampa's Carlton Fields law firm and one of the area business leaders most involved over the years in the push for better mass transit. "Almost always, they say transportation." But these days, voters are angry and distrustful of government, "making it hard to sell these programs."

Sasso anticipated Wednesday's outcome. Why didn't Hillsborough commissioners simply approve the project and let voters decide in the fall? Because, Sasso suggests, the commission figured residents would not approve it. And instead of suffering another failure at the polls, the commission opted to try and figure out something more palatable to voters at another time.

"You can see it around the country," Sasso said. "The lesson we just learned is: Mass transit efforts rarely work at a county level because urban voters may like it but rural voters don't see the benefit."

The Go Hillsborough initiative amounted to, in Sasso's critical assessment, "a lot of transportation projects and a tax. But not a plan."

One mass transit backer, the Greater Tampa Chamber of Commerce, on Thursday expressed disappointment in the County Commission vote not to proceed. "Our community must make a significant, long-term investment in transportation. Kicking the can down the road is not what we expect of our elected officials nor what our community deserves," the chamber stated.

Long before Wednesday's thumbs-down vote, the Tampa Bay market was singled out as the largest U.S. metro area without a mass transit system. Even Orlando, smaller in population and metro GDP, is operating a commuter train lines on existing CSX tracks.

Corporate site selectors — consultants who help companies pick the best places in the country for expansion — lately have praised the growth and livability of the Tampa Bay region. They also wish this area was making more tangible progress on mass transit beyond adding more roads.

Still, site selectors I contacted Thursday said one more mass transit stumble here is not necessarily a major deal killer for the area. Andrew Shapiro of Biggins Lacy Shapiro & Co., who recently toured this area, offered up this business relocation scenario.

"Would the lack of mass transit keep an otherwise attractive Tampa out of contention for a project?" No.

"Could that alone cause Tampa to be eliminated later in the selection process?" Potentially, Shapiro said. But not likely.

Site selector John Boyd of the Boyd Company, who also tracks the Tampa Bay metro area, said more mass transit is a nice goal but not yet a critical factor. But as Tampa Bay grows, it will become more significant, he acknowledged.

"Looking at it now, is that Hills­borough commissioner vote going to tip the scales against new business projects? My sense is it is not," Boyd said.

Whew. Looks like we'll be getting another turn at bat, after all.

Contact Robert Trigaux at [email protected] Follow @venturetampabay.

Comments
New board members at CareerSource Pinellas press for answers

New board members at CareerSource Pinellas press for answers

CLEARWATER— New board members at a troubled job placement center received a call for oversight Wednesday — something all but absent in recent years at the agency."Question, question, question," said CareerSource Pinellas board chair Jack Geller durin...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Kahwa’s next stop after 10 years in Tampa Bay? Publix

Kahwa’s next stop after 10 years in Tampa Bay? Publix

ST. PETERSBURG — It’s been Kahwa Coffee co-founders Raphael Perrier’s goal from the start.The chain of Tampa Bay coffee shops he opened with his wife has its roots in wholesale — so he dreamed of one day winning over a big distributor to get inside P...
Updated: 2 hours ago
PJs encouraged at Thursday’s Sunrise Sale in St. Pete. Prices go down when the sun comes up.

PJs encouraged at Thursday’s Sunrise Sale in St. Pete. Prices go down when the sun comes up.

The annual Sunrise Sale in St. Petersburg is almost as much of a bargain hunter’s holy grail as Black Friday. For 45 years, shoppers wearing pajamas have headed out at dawn to be in position at their favorite stores the moment the sun rises. That’s w...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Career Q&A:

Career Q&A:

Q: One of my co-workers is lying about a task she was supposed to complete. "Dawn" is responsible for renewing everyone’s membership in our industry’s professional association. However, last year she had a problem with my password, so I processed the...
Updated: 3 hours ago
New 35-story condo tower to rise in Tampa’s Channelside area

New 35-story condo tower to rise in Tampa’s Channelside area

TAMPA — A 35-story condo tower with just two units per floor is expected to start construction in the booming Channelside area early next year.Tampa-based Mercury Advisors announced Wednesday that it had obtained construction financing for the $74 mi...
Updated: 4 hours ago
St. Petersburg Downtown Partnership hires new CEO from Salt Lake City

St. Petersburg Downtown Partnership hires new CEO from Salt Lake City

ST. PETERSBURG — The nonprofit St. Petersburg Downtown Partnership on Wednesday said it has hired Jason Mathis as its new CEO.Mathis has more than 20 years of nonprofit experience, including serving as executive director of the Downtown Alliance in S...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Nitally’s set to reopen at a new, more intimate, South Pasadena location

Nitally’s set to reopen at a new, more intimate, South Pasadena location

Folks who have missed testing their taste buds with a St. Petersburg eatery’s famous inferno soup will get a chance to do so once again.Nitally’s ThaiMex Cuisine, which closed its downtown St. Petersburg location in May, will open soon in a smaller l...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Where to get a good hot dog in Tampa Bay for National Hot Dog Day

Where to get a good hot dog in Tampa Bay for National Hot Dog Day

Monday, July 23, is National Hot Dog Day. I don’t know precisely why, but I think some major lobbying from the sausage board was involved. It’s baseball season, it’s barbecue season, it’s I-don’t-feel-like-cooking season. Those are plenty of reasons....
Updated: 9 hours ago
Housing starts tumbled 12.3 percent in June

Housing starts tumbled 12.3 percent in June

Associated PressWASHINGTON — U.S. homebuilders sharply curtailed the pace of construction in June as housing starts plummeted 12.3 percent. The Commerce Department said Wednesday that housing starts fell to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.17 m...
Updated: 10 hours ago
EU fines Google a record $5 billion over mobile system

EU fines Google a record $5 billion over mobile system

BRUSSELS — The European Union fined Google a record $5 billion Wednesday for using the market dominance of its Android mobile operating system to force handset makers to install Google apps, reducing choice for consumers.EU Competition Commissioner M...
Updated: 11 hours ago