Saturday, May 26, 2018
Business

Old habits: State spending sprees that demand better oversight

True or false: Enterprise Florida economic development officials spent the following sums, largely taxpayer money, at these locations to woo businesses to the Sunshine State:

1. $22,000 on New York Yankees luxury suites and related purchases.

2. $13,000 at the San Diego Zoo.

3. $16,000 on Texas Rangers and Atlanta Braves baseball.

4. $7,800 at Truluck's Seafood Steak & Crab House (home of the $48 prime New York strip) in Austin, Texas, the 21 Club (home of the $75 fixed price dinner) in Manhattan, and 4 Rivers Smokehouse in Orlando.

Each example is "true." They are part of a much larger list recently made public that details some of the millions the state's public-private agency spends — on everything from entertainment and consulting firms to FedEx deliveries, parking fees and pest control. All of it, says Enterprise Florida, is done in the name of recruiting jobs and businesses to this state in the past two years.

The spending disclosures, first aired by CBS12 TV in West Palm Beach, are fresh fodder behind escalating criticism that Enterprise Florida officials are engaged in "lavish" spending, including some $30,000 a month on unspecified items, that appears excessive. Especially when it remains unclear what the state is getting for such spending when it comes to the number of actual jobs recruited to the state.

That very message is being relayed by watchdog groups to state representatives now that the annual legislative session is under way in Tallahassee.

"Enterprise Florida has a tough challenge to convince lawmakers that their spending of the public's money is generating a return on investment," states Dan Krassner. As head of the nonpartisan government watchdog group Integrity Florida, he remains a stubborn and vocal advocate for stronger accountability.

"Our expectation is that there will be increased focus from lawmakers on ensuring dollars go towards effective programs and move away from those that do not work," he says.

Escalating the feud was last fall's decision by the Enterprise Florida board to give agency CEO Gray Swoope a new contract that allows him to make up to $375,000 in salary and bonuses. That's a 25 percent increase over what he made then. And it comes on top of Swoope getting an annual $70,000 bonus in each of the past two years.

If this tale of high-end spending and big raises by a state government entity sounds familiar, it should.

Top officials at Citizens Property Insurance — Florida's state-run "insurer of last resort" — got their knuckles rapped last year after reports in the Tampa Bay Times revealed opulent spending on well-heeled meetings, fancy meals and elite hotel stays.

One 24-hour trip by Citizens CEO Barry Gilway from Jacksonville to Tampa cost more than $1,000 and included a dinner "meeting" for six at the posh Armani's restaurant in the Grand Hyatt that included "wine and spirits" along with veal shank, salmon and oysters.

Such examples at Citizens were not isolated. In the spring of 2012, Citizens spent nearly $28,000 for two days of meetings at a Tampa hotel. Before the fall of 2012, then-Citizens chief financial officer Sharon Binnun routinely stayed in New York City hotels costing $350 a night and up. That's in addition to a $35,000 tour Binnun took through four different countries, complete with stays in four-star hotels that included one in Bermuda costing more than $600 a night. (Binnun resigned last summer.)

Eerily like the big raise and bonuses delivered last fall to Enterprise Florida's chief, Citizens earlier had awarded big raises to senior executives.

Binnun received a $31,000 boost in pay, hiking her salary 14 percent to $255,000. Other top officials also got pay increases of more than $25,000 in late 2012, big bumps Citizens at the time justified due to "increased responsibility" and the need for pay "parity" with the private market.

Oh yeah, Citizens raised its insurance rates on policyholders at the same time these raises were doled out.

So far, the backlash against lush spending at Enterprise Florida and Citizens Property has proved very different.

Once quick to defend Citizens' spending ways, Gilway was publicly chastised by Florida Gov. Rick Scott, subjected to a state inspector general review and clearly embarrassed in public hearings. His past bravado is now muted.

In a recent visit with the Tampa Bay Times editorial board, Gilway said his agency has transformed dramatically over the past year. Once focused on fending off accusations of high executive expenses and loose oversight, Gilway said those concerns are all in the past.

And what of the spending follies of Enterprise Florida?

Unlike his earlier response to Citizens behavior, Scott continues to praise his job recruiting agency's track record and deflect calls for tighter spending controls. As governor, Scott happens to be the chairman of Enterprise Florida.

Recently, Enterprise Florida issued a three-page press release "setting the record straight" on its spending. Part of the release is dry regulatory history. And part of it defends itself against claims of lavish spending. Its tone hints that critics just don't "get" the high-stakes and expensive game of competing for the attention of site selection experts and corporate executives routinely wined, dined and entertained by dozens of states scrapping for the limited supply of new jobs and business expansions.

"To be successful in economic development, Enterprise Florida must build and maintain strong relationships with site selection professionals across the country," the release states.

Enterprise Florida is also feeling its oats because it is attracting more jobs and companies to the state in recent times than it did a few years ago. In 2013, the agency counted 152 recruitment/expansion projects and $2.1 billion in capital investment, up from 124 projects and $900 million in investment in 2010.

That translates to 21,742 new jobs "contracted" (committed to but not yet here) last year, a big gain over 11,398 new jobs contracted in 2010.

The message? Enterprise Florida is not Citizens Property. And unless or until Gov. Scott or state legislators fuss that pricey parties at venues like Yankee Stadium or Cowboys Stadium or the 21 Club are over the top … Get out of the way.

We're happy to step aside. But first fix one thing. Make sure Florida taxpayers know all that posh entertaining is worth it. Make sure it yields real — not just promised — jobs.

Many deals subsidized with taxpayer money commit to create jobs years into the future. Start to finish, Enterprise Florida must be crystal clear in telling us who did or did not deliver on their promises.

Information from Times staff writer Jeff Harrington and Times files was used in this column. Robert Trigaux can be reached at [email protected]

Comments
An American Airlines passenger was refused beer - so he screamed, fought and spit blood, FBI says

An American Airlines passenger was refused beer - so he screamed, fought and spit blood, FBI says

It began, as so many plane debacles seem to, with strange sounds in the bathroom.They were the noises of Jason Felix, one of the passengers on Wednesday’s American Airlines flight out of Saint Croix, according to a FBI affidavit recounting events lea...
Published: 05/26/18
Is the Lightning’s Jeff Vinik the best owner in professional sports?

Is the Lightning’s Jeff Vinik the best owner in professional sports?

Hope of another Stanley Cup has dissolved, and soon the ice will follow. Yet even if sorrow is the price of devotion, the true hockey fans will still buy in when the next season comes around.That concept may not be unique to Tampa Bay, but it does se...
Published: 05/26/18
Five members of 69ers motorcycle gang indicted on federal charges

Five members of 69ers motorcycle gang indicted on federal charges

Last year three members of the 69ers Motorcycle Club gang were implicated in the execution of a rival gang leader in the middle of rush hour traffic in Pasco County.Now those three and two other 69ers members have been indicted on federal charges tha...
Published: 05/25/18
With makeover, ZooTampa at Lowry Park takes a page from the theme parks

With makeover, ZooTampa at Lowry Park takes a page from the theme parks

TAMPA — Behind the construction walls near the carousel at ZooTampa at Lowry Park, hammers, saws and power drills made a racket in the blazing Friday heat. A raft full of 100-pound water jugs took test trips on the new Roaring Springs ride set ...
Published: 05/25/18
U.S. news outlets block European readers over new privacy rules

U.S. news outlets block European readers over new privacy rules

LONDON — U.S. news outlets including The Chicago Tribune, The Los Angeles Times, The Orlando Sentinel and The Arizona Daily Star abruptly blocked access to their websites from Europe on Friday, choosing to black out readers rather than comply with a ...
Published: 05/25/18
Tampa Electric appeals OSHA findings for October accident

Tampa Electric appeals OSHA findings for October accident

TAMPA — Tampa Electric Co. is appealing a recent citation by federal regulators. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration hit the utility with a $76,050 fine and a "serious" violation in April following its investigation into an accident in ...
Published: 05/25/18
Fiat Chrysler recalls 4.8 million cars, warning owners: Don’t use the cruise control

Fiat Chrysler recalls 4.8 million cars, warning owners: Don’t use the cruise control

Associated PressDETROIT — Fiat Chrysler is recalling 4.8 million vehicles in the U.S. because in rare but terrifying circumstances, drivers may not be able to turn off the cruise control. The company is warning owners not to use cruise control until...
Published: 05/25/18
Federal Reserve chairman warns his agency must be free from political pressure

Federal Reserve chairman warns his agency must be free from political pressure

Associated PressFederal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell warned Friday that the Fed’s independence from political pressure must be respected if it is to succeed in controlling inflation, maximizing employment and regulating the financial system. His re...
Published: 05/25/18
Restaurants like Ford’s Garage use the experience to get you in the door

Restaurants like Ford’s Garage use the experience to get you in the door

Tim Butler’s first car was a Ford Model A pick-up truck — a pearl fawn and cherry red pick-up he got his senior year in high school from his dad, who renovates antique cars. That’s why as Butler waited for a table at the Ford’...
Published: 05/25/18
St. Petersburg man fined $507,513 in penny stock scheme

St. Petersburg man fined $507,513 in penny stock scheme

TAMPA — A St. Petersburg man was fined $507,513 and permanently barred from participating in the offering of a penny stock in a case involving a scheme to manipulate the price of Aureus, a penny stock company incorporated in Nevada, officials said Fr...
Published: 05/25/18