Make us your home page

Regional economic development is in the eye of the beholder

Beauty — and apparently a metro area's economic performance — is in the eye of the beholder.

When the Tampa Bay Partnership recently issued its twice-a-year economic report card comparing Tampa Bay to five other Southern metro areas, we improved dramatically. Charlotte, too dependent on the struggling banking industry, fell like a rock to last place.

Now comes Charlotte's new benchmark report, out this week, that ranks Charlotte No. 3 out of nine Southern metro areas. And Tampa? It's in the basement at No. 8, just ahead of last-place Jacksonville.

Okay, class: Put on your rose-colored glasses. Now we all can see what we want to see, if the right statistics and comparative methodologies are employed.

Benchmarking studies that compare competing metro areas can be big business in economic development circles. When companies with potential expansion or relocation plans come calling, metro areas want to be able to show their economic standings, like a promising Major League Baseball team. See, we're only three games out of first!

To get a better perspective, I talked to Larry Henson, the Tampa Bay Partnership's business intelligence officer. He's put together the last six comparative scorecards. He said his scorecard and Charlotte's differ in the time periods chosen for assessing performance. The Tampa Bay report always uses the most current numbers, most recently comparing data from the first quarter of 2009 vs. the same period of 2008.

The goal is an unvarnished look at all six metro areas, which explains why Tampa Bay was, until this latest report, ranked sixth and last place for two scorecards in a row.

I also asked the author of Benchmark Charlotte 2009, University of North Carolina-Charlotte associate professor of geography Harry Campbell, for his thoughts. The Charlotte report takes a long-term view, he said. Tampa takes a short-term view.

Charlotte's benchmarking uses multiple-year data. That makes it more historically accurate but does less of a job capturing the "right now" 2009 state of the economy in each of the metro areas.

"There are pros and cons to both approaches," Campbell said. "In many ways, the Tampa report does a better job of illustrating how each of the areas is faring during this recession."

Henson, to his credit, was blunt in saying economic development groups enjoy plenty of "artistic license" when assembling reports meant to market cities in the best possible light. But that was never the goal of the Tampa Bay scorecard. It's supposed to help economic development officials make better decisions about how to strengthen the Tampa Bay area.

I learned plenty from both benchmarking reports. But the extreme disparity in metro rankings left me wondering, to paraphrase Mark Twain:

There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics. And sometimes economic benchmarking studies.

Robert Trigaux can be reached at

Where they ranked

How Tampa Bay and Charlotte rank

in two new benchmark studies:

Charlotte Chamber of Commerce

1. Raleigh-Durham

2. Austin

3. Charlotte

4. Atlanta

5. Dallas

6. Richmond

7. Nashville

8. Tampa

9. Jacksonville

Tampa Bay


1. Raleigh-Durham

2. Dallas.

3. Atlanta (tie)

3. Tampa Bay (tie)

5. Jacksonville

6. Charlotte

Regional economic development is in the eye of the beholder 06/17/09 [Last modified: Wednesday, June 17, 2009 7:13pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Water Street Tampa unveils video showing downtown's transformation


    TAMPA — Water Street Tampa, the sweeping, 50-plus acre redevelopment project in Tampa's urban core, has unveiled new images and video of what the downtown district will look like upon completion.

    Strategic Property Partners released a conceptual image of what the Tampa skyline will look like once its redevelopment of 50-plus acres of downtown will look like. [Photo courtesy of  of SPP]
  2. Florida ranks high for workplace equality between men and women

    Working Life

    When it comes to the workplace, Florida ranks fifth in terms of gender equality, a WalletHub study released Tuesday found.

    Florida ranks high in terms of equality between men and women in the workplace. Pictured is Sandra Murman, county commissioner in 2015, talking about the differences in pay between men and women. | [Times file photo]
  3. Treasury secretary's wife boasts of travel on government plane, touts high fashion


    U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin's wife, Louise Linton, boasted of flying on a government plane with her husband to Kentucky on Monday and then named the numerous fashion brands she wore on the trip in an unusual social media post that only became more bizarre minutes later.

    Steven Mnuchin and his then- financee Louise Linton watch as President Donald Trump speaks during Mnuchin's swearing-in ceremony as  treasury secretary in the Oval Office of the White House on Feb. 13. [Mandel Ngan | AFP via Getty Images]
  4. Ford, Chinese partner look at possible electric car venture


    BEIJING — Ford Motor Co. and a Chinese automaker said Tuesday they are looking into setting up a joint venture to develop and manufacture electric cars in China.

    In this April 23, 2016 photo, attendees take smartphone photos at a promotional event for Ford Motor Company ahead of the Auto China car show in Beijing. Ford Motor Co. announced an agreement Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2017 with a Chinese partner to look into forming a joint venture to develop and manufacture electric cars in China. [AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein]
  5. Judge throws out $458,000 condo sale, says Clearwater attorney tricked bidders

    Real Estate

    CLEARWATER — Pinellas County Circuit Judge Jack St. Arnold on Monday threw out the $458,100 sale of a gulf-front condo because of what he called an "unscrupulous" and "conniving" scheme to trick bidders at a foreclosure auction.

    John Houde, left, whose Orlando copany was the high  bidder June 8 at the foreclosure auction of a Redington Beach condo, looks in the direction of Clearwater lawyer and real estate investor Roy C. Skelton, foreground,  during a hearing Monday before Pinellas County Circuit Judge Jack St. Arnold.  [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD   |   Times ]