Tuesday, January 16, 2018
Business

After botched merger, Duke Energy has more to repair than broken nuclear plant in Florida

A perennially passive Florida regulator squares off Monday against the nation's largest electricity producer and owner of the aging Crystal River 3 nuclear power plant north of Tampa Bay. The issue? The fate of CR3, broken since late 2009.

At the heart of the Florida Public Service Commission's hearing: Can CR3 be safely fixed at reasonable cost and start generating electricity again? Or is its concrete containment vessel so damaged and now so brittle that we all may be best served by Duke Energy closing CR3 for good?

There are some key, hard-hitting questions the timid PSC should be asking Duke about a broken nuke plant that may cost billions to fix. I'm skeptical that the commission will even pose many of those questions. And those that are posed will be deflected by Duke — a giant utility more combative than Progress Energy.

First, let's set the bigger scene.

In normal times, Monday's status update would pass largely ignored. PSC regulators are often wimps, bullied by state legislative overseers who are slaves to campaign contributions from rich utilities.

Florida PSC leaders may claim they follow the letter of regulatory rules, but they've lost much of the spirit to act in the public interest of clearly beleaguered Floridians. Especially those Floridians already paying Duke a premium for electricity.

But these times are far from normal. In what is perhaps the most manipulative merger in recent U.S. corporate history, Duke Energy last month finalized its purchase of North Carolina peer Progress Energy. The takeover makes CR3 Duke's problem now.

There's a good reason Friday's Wall Street Journal ran this headline: Lingering Mistrust Will Haunt Duke Merger. "Nearly everyone involved in this Southern Gothic drama — directors, executives, regulators, and Wall Street — no longer trusts each other." And that, the Journal states, "will haunt the utility."

From the start of the proposed super-merger, Duke promised Progress Energy that its CEO, Bill Johnson, would become chief executive of the resulting power company.

Bizarrely, Johnson instead was tossed out on the same day the merger was completed last month, mere hours after formally becoming CEO of the new Duke Energy.

Replacing Johnson as CEO of the new Duke Energy is Jim Rogers, longtime CEO of the old Duke.

The underhanded style and Machiavellian tone of the corporate coup produced an instant backlash. Rogers had to explain Duke's actions at length under oath before upset North Carolina regulators.

North Carolina's attorney general started an investigation. Several lawsuits accuse Duke of sucker punching Progress Energy and misleading investors in the deal.

There's even some talk that Duke will have to sacrifice Rogers as part of the ultimate price of fixing this fiasco. But Rogers is politically powerful, having played a key role in bringing the Democratic National Convention and President Obama to Charlotte just weeks from now.

In addition to Johnson's ousting, several top Progress Energy executives have resigned either in protest of the handling of the merger or because they feel Duke will not treat them fairly in the future.

The management turmoil continued last week. Progress Energy Florida announced Wednesday that president Vinny Dolan, 57, would resign this year even though he's held the position for only three years.

Which brings us to Monday's long-scheduled hearing by the Florida PSC. The agency had no influence in the messy merger to date. But where it should have some clout is in its alleged oversight of what is now Duke's job of handling CR3.

After all, both Rogers and Duke's top directors blame Johnson's poor handling of the botched repairs to CR3 as a big reason for the loss of confidence in Johnson becoming their new CEO.

On Monday, Rogers will appear for the first time before the Florida PSC. He will comment in a separate meeting before the scheduled review of CR3's future. Rogers is supposed to discuss how Duke's purchase of Progress Energy will affect 1.6 million Florida customers, especially on the matter of future electricity rates.

Once Rogers is done, another PSC hearing begins with a team from Duke on whether to repair or retire CR3. Nobody's expecting a final answer yet.

Duke has chosen (but not identified) an outside engineering firm to repair the plant, but more information is still being gathered.

Also likely to be discussed is NEIL, short for Nuclear Electric Insurance Limited, which provides insurance to nuclear plants.

As the owner of damaged CR3, Duke wants NEIL to honor the plant's insurance policy and cover some of the $1 billion-plus price tag for repairs. NEIL has not yet indicated whether it will honor that policy because Progress Energy's own botched repairs aggravated the damages to CR3 and might have been avoided.

Bottom line? CR3's troubles are hardly the only repairs Duke must undertake. Rebuilding trust may take longer than the company thinks.

Robert Trigaux can be reached at [email protected]

Comments
Pinellas is at the center of a rise in Florida flu outbreaks

Pinellas is at the center of a rise in Florida flu outbreaks

Feeling a little sniffly or scratchy or stuffed up? It may be the flu, and you don’t want to wait around to see a doctor this year. This is not the time to write off flu-like symptoms, Tampa Bay area health officials and doctors warn. The influenza v...
Updated: 9 minutes ago
Italian Butterfingers? Nestle selling candy business for $2.9B

Italian Butterfingers? Nestle selling candy business for $2.9B

Associated PressNEW YORK — Swiss food and drink giant Nestle is selling its U.S. candy business to Italy’s Ferrero for about $2.9 billion in cash. Ferrero will take over iconic chocolate brands Butterfinger and Crunch bars, as well as the sugary Nerd...
Updated: 16 minutes ago
23 seek vacant PSC post

23 seek vacant PSC post

There is another Mariano seeking a job in Tallahassee.Pasco County Commissioner Jack Mariano, the father of state Rep. Amber Mariano, R-Hudson, is seeking an appointment to the Florida Public Service Commission, the powerful board regulating Florida ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
St. Petersburg’s apartment boom is spreading west

St. Petersburg’s apartment boom is spreading west

ST. PETERSBURG — Still more apartments are coming to St. Petersburg, this time to the Edge and Grand Central Districts just west of downtown. The new projects, all by out-of-state developers and more moderately priced than those downtown, will...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Florida raises insurance regulation grade from C to B

Florida raises insurance regulation grade from C to B

When it comes to regulating insurance, Florida is slowly improving. The Sunshine State raised its grade from a C in 2016 to a B in 2017 on the "R Street 2017 Insurance Regulation Report Card." It ranked No. 15 among all states.The annual report, writ...
Updated: 2 hours ago

US travel industry launches plan to reverse tourism decline

Associated PressNEW YORK — Travel industry representatives sounded an alarm Tuesday over declines in international tourism to the U.S. and announced plans to reverse the trend. Organizers of the new Visit U.S. Coalition portrayed the decline as long-...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Raymond James advice for small to mid-sized companies about activist shareholders? Prepare and listen

Raymond James advice for small to mid-sized companies about activist shareholders? Prepare and listen

Shareholder fights between activist investors and publicly traded companies are getting nastier, especially in some industries, and a lot of them don’t involve corporate giants like General Motors and Procter & Gamble.In 2015, according to Raymond Ja...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Dow bursts through 26,000 in record seven trading days

Dow bursts through 26,000 in record seven trading days

The Dow Jones industrial average blew past 26,000 Tuesday for the first time ever, coming only a week after hitting 25,000 and showing further evidence that the long-running bull market is alive and well."There are several reasons for markets to melt...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Arizona-based AFI Mortgage opens St. Petersburg branch

Arizona-based AFI Mortgage opens St. Petersburg branch

Times StaffAFI Mortgage, a subsidiary of an Arizona-based bank, is opening its first Florida locations in St. Petersburg and Lakeland. Its parent company, AmeriFirst Financial Inc., specializes in mortgages. "This Florida team is innovative, knowledg...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Some fear Spa Beach billowing net sculpture could catch birds and storms

Some fear Spa Beach billowing net sculpture could catch birds and storms

By WAVENEY ANN MOORETimes Staff WriterST. PETERSBURG — International artist Janet Echelman may have fulfilled her $75,000 feasibility contract with the city and previewed her billowing, parasol-inspired sculpture for Spa Beach, but for some, key ques...
Updated: 10 hours ago