Make us your home page

Investigation sought into Crystal River nuclear plant deal

Duke Energy announced on Feb. 5 that it will permanently close the crippled Crystal River nuclear plant that has been shut down since late 2009. The damaged containment building of the nuclear plant is seen at the center of the photo.


Duke Energy announced on Feb. 5 that it will permanently close the crippled Crystal River nuclear plant that has been shut down since late 2009. The damaged containment building of the nuclear plant is seen at the center of the photo.

Consumer advocates want Duke Energy to refund its Florida customers hundreds of millions of dollars for "woefully inadequate" handling of the now shuttered Crystal River nuclear plant.

The state Public Counsel's Office, which represents consumers before the Public Service Commission, filed a petition Monday, asking the regulatory body to open an investigation into Duke's decisions about the 36-year-old nuclear plant.

The petition, backed by the 8,000-member Florida Retail Federation, is the first challenge to Duke's move earlier this month to permanently shut down the utility's sole nuclear plant in the state.

"The Public Counsel and FRF request the Commission take all necessary and appropriate actions to protect the customers … and to insure that they bear no more of the costs of the financial and economic disaster visited upon them by the CR3 outage," Public Counsel J.R. Kelly wrote in the petition.

State regulators and consumer advocates wanted Duke to repair the Crystal River nuclear plant because it provided cheap, clean electricity.

Cindy Muir, a spokeswoman for the commission, said regulators are reviewing the petition and will considered it in upcoming hearings. Sterling Ivey, a Duke spokesman, also said the utility received the petition and is reviewing it.

During an upgrade project in 2009, which included replacement of old steam generators and increasing the nuclear plant's power, the reactor's 42-inch thick concrete containment building cracked. An attempt to repair the crack and bring the plant back online led to more cracks.

The damage left Duke with a repair bill that could have reached $3.4 billion. In addition, the utility continued to amass replacement power costs of as much as $300 million a year while the reactor remained idle.

Instead, Duke decided to shut down the plant.

Duke, which took over the plant when it became the parent company of Progress Energy Florida in July, already is refunding customers $388 million for replacement power related to the outage. The utility pressed its insurance company to cover the costs of the damage. But in the end, the insurer, the Nuclear Electric Insurance Limited or NEIL, settled with the utility for a fraction of what it would take to repair the plant.

Even so, the full payment by NEIL of $835 million was the largest payout by the insurance company in its more than 30-year history.

In its petition, the public counsel and the retail federation asked state regulators to order Progress and its parent company Duke to renegotiate with its insurance company and collect a larger amount for customers or require the utility's shareholders to make up the difference.

The consumer advocates want at least $500 million more to make up for what they consider a low settlement amount with the insurance company.

In addition, the petition seeks to block Duke from recovering $111 million from customers for money it spent to upgrade the Crystal River plant — improvements that did not produce a single kilowatt of power for customers.

Duke, the petition states, "has an obligation to its captive customers to exert full efforts to provide service at the lowest reasonable costs — which, in this instance, means doing everything necessary to maximize its recovery under the NEIL policies in order to minimize costs to its customers."

Ivan Penn can be reached at or (727) 892-2332.

Investigation sought into Crystal River nuclear plant deal 02/25/13 [Last modified: Monday, February 25, 2013 10:19pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Amid U.S. real estate buying binge by foreign investors, Florida remains first choice

    Real Estate

    Foreign investment in U.S. residential real estate recently skyrocketed to a new high with nearly half of all foreign sales happening in Florida, California and Texas.

    A National Association of Realtors annual survey found record volume and activity by foreign buyers of U.S. real estate. Florida had the highest foreign investment activity, followed by California and Texas. [National Association of Realtors]
  2. Trigaux: Tampa Bay health care leaders wary of getting too far ahead in disruptive times


    Are attempts to repeal Obamacare dead for the foreseeable future? Might the Affordable Care Act (ACA), now in dire limbo, be revived? Will Medicaid coverage for the most in need be gutted? Can Republicans now in charge of the White House, Senate and House ever agree to deliver a substitute health care plan that people …

    Natalia Ricabal of Lutz, 12 years old, joined other pediatric cancer patients in Washington in July to urge Congress to protect Medicaid coverage that helped patients like Ricabal fight cancer. She was diagnosed with Ewing's sarcoma in 2013 and has undergone extensive treatments at BayCare's St. Joseph's Children's Hospital in Tampa. [Courtesy of BayCare]
  3. The Iron Yard coding academy to close in St. Petersburg


    ST. PETERSBURG — The Iron Yard, a code-writing academy with a location in downtown St. Petersburg, will close for good this summer.

    Instructors (from left) Mark Dewey, Jason Perry, and Gavin Stark greet the audience at The Iron Yard, 260 1st Ave. S, in St. Petersburg during "Demo Day" Friday, Oct. 7, 2016, at The Iron Yard, which is an immersive code school that is part of a trend of trying to address the shortage of programmers.  The academy is closing this summer.  [LARA CERRI   |   Times]
  4. Florida's unemployment rate drops for fourth straight month


    Unemployment in Florida hit a 10-year low in June, clocking in at 4.1 percent, down from 4.3 percent in May. The state added 19,400 jobs over the month, and saw growth in most industries. But there's one glaring missing piece to the economic recovery puzzle: wage growth.

    Florida's unemployment level dropped to 4.1 percent in June from 4.3 percent in May. |  [Times file photo]
  5. Is sinkhole damage sinking Tampa Bay property values?

    Real Estate

    On a scale of desirability, the house for sale on Whittner Drive in Land O' Lakes would rank fairly low. It's a short sale; it sits on an unstabilized sinkhole and it's within a few miles of two houses that collapsed into a gargantuan hole July 14.

    A gated community in Hernando's Spring Hill area, Pristine Place has long been susceptible to sinkholes with nearly a third of its houses with documented sinkhole damage by 2012. Today, however, many houses with repaired sinkhole damage are selling for more than houses without any issues. [WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times file photo]