Make us your home page

Judge: Duke Energy is off the hook for $352 million for canceled Levy County nuke plant

A judge has ruled that Duke Energy doesn't have to pay $352 million to Westinghouse in connection with the shuttered Levy County nuclear plant. Cherie Diez | Times

A judge has ruled that Duke Energy doesn't have to pay $352 million to Westinghouse in connection with the shuttered Levy County nuclear plant. Cherie Diez | Times

This is one enormous bill that Duke Energy Florida customers won't have to cover.

A federal judge in North Carolina ruled last week that the Florida utility does not owe the Westinghouse Electric Co. $352 million for disputed costs associated with the 2013 cancellation of a Levy County nuclear power plant.

But federal Judge Max O. Cogburn Jr. said in a 29-page order that Duke is contractually obligated to pay Westinghouse a $30-million termination fee plus $4 million in interest.

The judge's Dec. 22 decision, after a bench trial, is a rare dose of good news for Duke over the controversial Levy project, which Duke inherited when it acquired Progress Energy in 2012. Duke's 1.7 million Florida ratepayers were forced to cover about $1.5 billion of Duke's costs in developing the project.

And the utility had been expected to seek approval from the Florida Public Service Commission to pass on the $352 million bill to its customers had Westinghouse prevailed. It remains unclear if consumers will be asked to cover the $34 million.

Duke in 2014 initially sued Westinghouse, the world's largest builder of nuclear plants, for the $54 million paid for Levy equipment that the utility said the contractor never produced. Westinghouse countersued Duke for $512 million for canceling the Levy contract. That sum was later reduced to $352 million.

Cogburn said in his ruling that Duke was not obligated to pay "full freight" for the development of an advanced reactor, noting the utility had the contractual right to opt out of a consortium of utilities partnered with Westinghouse.

The judge said Westinghouse, prior to the project cancellation, had never billed Duke for the hundreds of millions of dollars Westinghouse would later argue it had accrued.

Westinghouse "never notified Duke or its predecessors that expenses of enormous proportions were being amassed for performance of work necessary" for the project, Cogburn ruled.

J.R. Kelly, the public counsel whose office represents consumers before the Florida Public Service Commission, hailed the ruling.

"This is definitely a win win win for the whole state of Florida, Duke and ratepayers included," Kelly said.

Duke had canceled plans for two Westinghouse reactors, citing projected costs that had ballooned to $24.7 billion and delays obtaining the necessary federal licenses.

"While we are disappointed anytime we have to go to litigation with a vendor, we are pleased with the judge's decision not to award the termination cost claim," Duke spokeswoman Rita Sipe said in a written statement Thursday.

Duke Energy won't close the door entirely on building a nuclear facility in Florida years down the road, noting that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission issued a license for the Levy County site in October,

"We have not made a decision to build the plant, but the ability to add carbon-free, reliable nuclear generation is an important element of our long-term resource planning," Sipe said.

But Duke's nuclear ambitions in Florida have dimmed considerably in recent years.

Duke in February 2013 also announced the permanent closure of its Crystal River nuclear plant in Citrus County after a botched upgrade project led to repair bills that would have reached into the billions. Duke decided it would be more prudent to close the plant and build a natural gas facility.

That will cost customers $1.3 billion over the next 20 years.

Cogburn said in his ruling that the different "negotiating cultures" at Duke and Westinghouse may have needlessly escalated a dispute that otherwise might have ended amicably.

A Westinghouse official told the utility in an August 2013 meeting that the company would claim substantial termination costs should Duke cancel its Westinghouse contract. Duke took that as an affront and sign that Westinghouse was "cooking the bill," Cogburn said.

In fact, the judge said Westinghouse's statement "was more akin to posturing and bluster" common in negotiations, not something more nefarious.

"Rather than cooling off when hard positions were taken," Cogburn wrote, "these parties parted ways rather than stepping back and letting cooler heads prevail."

Contact William R. Levesque at or (813) 226-3432. Follow @Times_Levesque.

Judge: Duke Energy is off the hook for $352 million for canceled Levy County nuke plant 12/29/16 [Last modified: Thursday, December 29, 2016 5:23pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Construction starts on USF medical school, the first piece of Tampa's Water Street project


    TAMPA — Dozens of workers in hard hats and boots were busy at work at the corner of South Meridian Avenue and Channelside Drive Wednesday morning, signaling the start of construction on the University of South Florida's new Morsani College of Medicine and Heart Institute.

    A rendering shows what the USF Health Morsani College of Medicine and Heart Institute will look like when completed in 2019. Local officials gathered Wednesday to celebrate as construction begins on the facility, the first piece of the Water Street redevelopment area in downtown Tampa. [Rendering courtesy of the USF Health]
  2. Tampa Bay among top 25 metro areas with fastest growing economies

    Economic Development

    Tampa Bay had the 24th fastest growing economy among 382 metro areas in the country for 2016. According to an analysis by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Tampa Bay's gross domestic product, or GDP, increased 4.2 percent from 2015 to 2016 to hit $126.2 billion.

    Tampa Bay had the 24th fastest growing economy in the country for 2016. Rentals were one of the areas that contributed to Tampa Bay's GDP growth. Pictured is attorney David Eaton in front of his rental home. 
  3. Tampa Bay cools down to more moderate home price increases

    Real Estate

    The increase in home prices throughout much of the Tampa Bay area is definitely slowing from the torrid rate a year ago.

    This home close to Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa sold for $3.055 million in August, making it Hillsborough County's top sale of the month. [Courtesy of Bredt Cobitz]
  4. With successful jewelry line, Durant High alum Carley Ochs enjoys 'incredible ride'



    As a child Carley Ochs played dress up, draped in her grandmother's furs.

    Founder Carley Ochs poses for a portrait in her Ford Bronco at the Bourbon & Boweties warehouse in Brandon, Fla. on September 19, 2017. Ochs is a Durant High and Florida State University graduate.
  5. At Menorah Manor, planning paid off during Irma

    Nursing Homes

    ST. PETERSBURG — Doris Rosenblatt and her husband, Frank, have lived in Florida all of their lives, so they know about hurricanes.

    Raisa Collins, 9, far left, works on a craft project as Certified Nursing Assistant Shuntal Anthony holds Cassidy Merrill, 1, while pouring glue for Quanniyah Brownlee, 9, right, at Menorah Manor in St. Petersburg on Sept. 15. To help keep its patients safe during Hurricane Irma, Menorah Manor allowed employees to shelter their families and pets at the nursing home and also offered daycare through the week. The facility was able to accommodate and feed everyone who weathered the storm there. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]