Monday, June 18, 2018
Business

Legislator asks Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam to study costs of nuclear vs. natural gas

A Tampa Bay area lawmaker on Monday urged Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam to conduct a study of the proposed Levy County nuclear plant to ensure consumers were getting a good deal.

In a two-page letter, Rep. Mike Fasano, R-New Port Richey, said a Tampa Bay Times report Sunday that compared the cost of the nuclear plant to a natural gas facility highlighted the need for the review.

Fasano said Putnam's office should conduct the review because "I do not believe that, if asked, the Florida Public Service Commission would conduct a fair and unbiased cost analysis."

The concern, Fasano said, is that Levy is projected to cost billions of dollars more than a natural gas facility.

"The potential savings to utility customers are incredible," Fasano wrote to Putnam, the state's point person on energy matters.

Putnam is one of several decisionmakers in Tallahassee who have argued that nuclear in the long term is a cheap source of electricity, particularly compared to the "volatile" costs of natural gas plants.

The Times set out to see if the premise that nuclear-saves-money is true by conducting an analysis of the cost of Levy and an equivalent natural gas plant — including construction, operating and maintenance costs and fuel — over 60 years.

The analysis showed that a natural gas facility would be billions of dollars cheaper than Levy, which would be the most expensive nuclear plant ever built in the United States. The Times analysis, conducted over three months, was based in large part on Duke Energy's 2012 filings with the state.

The Times' findings reflect the conclusions of other studies about nuclear's costs compared to natural gas, including Duke's own analysis. Duke found in 2012 that Levy would cost $3.9 billion more in today's dollars than an equivalent natural gas plant using middle-of-the-road estimates for fuel costs and without a carbon tax. Even an updated report that Duke filed May 1 concluded a natural gas facility would be $3 billion less expensive than the Levy plant.

In both of its reports, Duke assumed a fuel price that is higher than projections from the federal government. Using the government projections, the 60-year cost of a natural gas facility falls even further. Duke also has the start date for the gas facility as 2016, and the Levy start date as 2024. In accounting calculations, the difference in start dates can increase the price of the gas facility compared to the nuclear plant.

R. Alexander "Alex" Glenn, president of Duke Energy Florida, said in a letter to the Times that a natural gas plant could cost more than Levy, if the government ever considered imposing a carbon tax on emissions.

The Times' analysis included financial penalties for carbon emissions, even though there is little political will at this time in this country to tax carbon. Glenn said the newspaper's analysis assumed a lower carbon tax than Duke, making the natural gas plants less expensive than in the utility's report. He maintained that the Levy project remains a good deal for consumers.

"As a state and a country, we need to have a balanced portfolio in order to sustain and secure our energy future," Glenn wrote. "Florida's Levy nuclear project remains cost effective when compared to building comparable natural gas-fired power plants."

Glenn further stated that Florida is the "fifth most dependent state on natural gas, and we are poised to continue increasing our dependence. . . . This is like investing your retirement in one stock — and a very volatile one at that."

The cost and supply of natural gas is a critical issue in energy policy. State policy makers fear spikes in natural gas prices will send utility bills soaring, so they say Florida needs to diversify its energy mix. Utility's produce about 60 percent of the state's electricity from natural gas.

Part of the solution has been to push for new nuclear plants. But the ballooning price tag on construction costs of reactors have left many with sticker shock.

Fasano said another startling fact was the profit Duke would make off the Levy nuclear plant compared to a natural gas facility.

In today's dollars, Duke would earn $4 billion for Levy over a 60-year period, compared with $369 million for the natural gas facility, the Times analysis found.

"I never realized the profit that they make off a nuclear plant," Fasano later said in an interview.

Duke's written response on Monday did not address the issue of profit.

Duke proposes to build the Levy plant on a 5,000-acre tract 100 miles north of Tampa. The first of two reactors at the plant is projected to come online in 2024 with the second following a year later.

Levy was supposed to begin producing power in 2016 at a construction cost of $5 billion to $6 billion. But delays in approval of its federal operating license, the Great Recession and falling electricity demand pushed back the start date and in turn led to increases in cost.

"To date, nuclear power has been dominating the debate," Fasano wrote to Putnam. "Natural gas may be a more cost effective method to supply Florida's ever-increasing power demands."

Ivan Penn can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 892-2332.

Comments
St. Petersburg residents will see higher water, sanitation bills

St. Petersburg residents will see higher water, sanitation bills

ST. PETERSBURG — Residents can expect their water and sanitation bills to increase between $7 and $11 starting in October.That represents an average of a 7-percent increase. Customers who use an average of 4,000 gallons a month, including reclaimed w...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Private Florida firm buys Rent-A-Center in $1 billion deal

Private Florida firm buys Rent-A-Center in $1 billion deal

An Orlando private equity firm has purchased lease-to-own business Rent-A-Center in a deal valued at more than $1 billion.Vintage Capital Management put a bid in for the company on Friday: $15 per share, $1 per share above its previous offer. Rent-A-...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Report: 40 percent of Florida property will be ‘highly exposed’ to flooding

Report: 40 percent of Florida property will be ‘highly exposed’ to flooding

One of Florida’s biggest draws is also one if its biggest liabilities — its coastline. A new report projects that Florida is at the greatest risk of any state for tidal flooding caused by rising sea levels. And Tampa Bay faces some of the greatest ri...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Mazzaro’s gets ready to reopen

Mazzaro’s gets ready to reopen

day after an electrical fire broke out in its dry goods warehouse Friday night.Dominic Horwath, a grocery manager at Mazzaro’s on 22nd Ave. N, said staffers spent Monday and the weekend moving things into other warehouses.The damage from the fire at ...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Mazzaro’s market set to reopen Tuesday after blaze damaged one of its warehouses

Mazzaro’s market set to reopen Tuesday after blaze damaged one of its warehouses

ST. PETERSBURG — Mazzaro’s Italian Market is scheduled to reopen Tuesday after an electrical fire broke out its dry goods warehouse Friday night.Dominic Horwath, a grocery manager at Mazzaro’s on 22nd Avenue N said staff spent Monday and the weekend...
Published: 06/18/18
Developer Grady Pridgen buys St. Pete’s shuttered Edward White Hospital

Developer Grady Pridgen buys St. Pete’s shuttered Edward White Hospital

ST. PETERSBURG — Edward White Hospital, closed four years ago because of declining revenues, has been sold to developer Grady Pridgen for $2.7 million.Pridgen could not be reached Monday for comment. City officials said he has submitted plans for rem...
Published: 06/18/18

Hernando Business Digest for June 22

Business digestBrieflyHOSPITAL RECEIVES AWARD: Oak Hill Hospital in Spring Hill was the recipient of Healthgrades 2018 Patient Safety Excellence Award, a designation that recognizes superior performance of hospitals that have prevented the occurrence...
Published: 06/18/18
Pasco Business Digest for June 22

Pasco Business Digest for June 22

Business digestBrieflyHOSPITALS RECEIVE AWARD: Regional Medical Center Bayonet Point and Medical Center of Trinity were recipients of Healthgrades 2018 Patient Safety Excellence Award, a designation that recognizes superior performance of hospitals t...
Published: 06/18/18
Tampa Bay gas prices keep falling

Tampa Bay gas prices keep falling

The summer reprieve in gas prices is continuing.After flirting near the $3 mark, Tampa Bay gas prices fell another six cents a gallon over the past week to an average of $2.65 for unleaded, a wide gap with the national average of $2.91 a gallon, acco...
Published: 06/18/18
Your barista is a robot. Should it be friendly?

Your barista is a robot. Should it be friendly?

SAN FRANCISCO - The cold, steely arm of Fernando the Barista swirled the foam of my matcha latte, set it down gently, and waved goodbye from inside a glass case. San Francisco, 2018. Where you can get robot pizza and robot salad, and now, a robot mat...
Published: 06/16/18