Make us your home page

Many warnings along the path to a broken Crystal River nuclear plant

Progress Energy can't say it wasn't warned. The company was told that its strategies were flawed at nearly every step in its effort to replace old steam generators at the Crystal River nuclear plant. Progress insists that no one could have predicted or prevented the problems — mainly the cracking of the containment building that houses the nuclear reactor and the steam generators. The St. Petersburg Times' ongoing investigation, based largely on documents from Progress, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and state agencies, has detailed multiple warnings prior to the utility's critical decisions. Ivan Penn, Times Staff Writer

The first warning

Progress' own internal study said that the company needed to hire an experienced general contractor to manage the project.

After accepting bids from the two firms that had managed all of the other steam generator replacement projects in the country, Progress decided to manage the project itself, hoping to save as much as $27.9 million.

A subsequent Progress analysis listed 25 threats and weaknesses, which the company later decided it could overcome.

The second warning

In March 2009, six months before Progress started the upgrade, contractors who had worked on similar projects warned the utility that its procedure for cutting into the containment building to gain access to the steam generators was different from all similar projects nationwide.

For instance, on March 9, 2009, Charles Hovey, an experienced construction foreman who had worked on similar projects at other nuclear plants, wrote an email that said: "I have never heard of it being done like this before and I just want to express my concerns to you one last time."

Progress did not change its procedure and the concrete nuclear reactor containment building cracked.

The third warning

In December 2009, two months after workers found the crack in the reactor building, Thomas Saporito of Jupiter filed a petition with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission opposing Progress' repair plan. Saporito is a nuclear plant instrument control technician and safety whistle-blower who has worked at Crystal River.

In a January 2010 NRC public meeting, Saporito said the utility's plan to "patch" the wall with the crack would lead to more cracks. He suggested that Progress remove concrete all around the building to ensure there were no other cracks and to prevent future ones.

Progress stuck with its own approach. The building cracked a second time in March of this year and a third time in July.

The fourth warning:

Progress's current plan calls for replacing and strengthening all of the six concrete panels that make up the walls of the building (one already was replaced during the first repair).

Nuclear plant experts, including nuclear engineer Arnie Gundersen and Dave Lochbaum, a nuclear engineer with the Union of Concerned Scientists, say Progress needs to tear down the building and build a new one. Otherwise, Progress "will chase cracks for years."

Progress says it believes its plan is the best course of action.

Many warnings along the path to a broken Crystal River nuclear plant 12/09/11 [Last modified: Saturday, December 10, 2011 7:10pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. At Menorah Manor, planning paid off during Irma

    Nursing Homes

    ST. PETERSBURG — Doris Rosenblatt and her husband, Frank, have lived in Florida all of their lives, so they know about hurricanes.

    Raisa Collins, 9, far left, works on a craft project as Certified Nursing Assistant Shuntal Anthony holds Cassidy Merrill, 1, while pouring glue for Quanniyah Brownlee, 9, right, at Menorah Manor in St. Petersburg on Sept. 15. To help keep its patients safe during Hurricane Irma, Menorah Manor allowed employees to shelter their families and pets at the nursing home and also offered daycare through the week. The facility was able to accommodate and feed everyone who weathered the storm there. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]
  2. After Irma, nursing homes scramble to meet a hard deadline

    State Roundup

    TALLAHASSEE — Florida's nursing homes and assisted-living facilities find themselves in an unfamiliar place this week — pushing back against Gov. Rick Scott's administration over new rules that require them to purchase generator capacity by Nov. 15 to keep their residents safe and comfortable in a power …

    In this Sept. 13 photo, a woman is transported from The Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills as patients are evacuated after a loss of air conditioning due to Hurricane Irma in Hollywood. Nine have died and patients had to be moved out of the facility, many of them on stretchers or in wheelchairs. Authorities have launched a criminal investigation to figure out what went wrong and who, if anyone, was to blame. [Amy Beth Bennett | South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP]
  3. Trigaux: How Moffitt Cancer's M2Gen startup won $75 million from Hearst


    TAMPA — A Moffitt Cancer Center spin-off that's building a massive genetic data base of individual patient cancer information just caught the attention of a deep-pocketed health care investor.

    Richard P. Malloch is the president of Hearst Business Media, which is announcing a $75 million investment in M2Gen, the for-profit cancer informatics unit spun off by Tampa's Moffitt Cancer Center. Malloch's job is to find innovative investments for the Hearst family fortune. A substantial amount has been invested in health care, financial and the transportation and logistics industries.
  4. Three-hour police standoff ends, thanks to a cigarette


    TAMPA — A man threatening to harm himself was arrested by Tampa police on Tuesday after a three-hour standoff.

  5. Another Hollywood nursing home resident dies. It's the 9th in post-Irma tragedy.

    State Roundup

    The Broward County Medical Examiner's office is investigating another death of a resident of the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills — the ninth blamed on the failure of a cooling system that became a stifling deathtrap three days after Irma hit.

    Carlos Canal, pictured at 47 years old, came to Miami from Cuba in 1960. Above is his citizenship photo. [Courtesy of Lily Schwartz]