Tuesday, October 16, 2018
Business

Repair costs rise at Crystal River nuclear plant

The cost to fix the broken Crystal River nuclear plant appears to be on the rise.

The previous top estimate of $1.3 billion is likely too low, Duke Energy CEO Jim Rogers confirmed in an interview Thursday.

The utility has not decided whether to repair or permanently shut down the plant. An independent technical evaluation commissioned on the facility by Duke's board is expected to be complete in about a month, Rogers said.

"The cost estimate is trending higher," Rogers said. "The repair plan appears to be technically feasible but issues remain."

Florida sits at the top of Rogers' priority list now that the merger between Duke and Progress Energy is complete. The broken Crystal River plant and a proposed plant in Levy County are multi-billion dollar issues for Rogers. Both are complex, and Rogers said in a telephone interview with the Tampa Bay Times that he's giving them careful consideration.

Crystal River is first.

The nuclear plant in Citrus County went off line in September 2009 for maintenance and upgrades. During the project, the plant's 42-inch thick concrete containment building cracked. A half-billion dollar repair resulted in more cracks.

Repairing the new cracks was estimated to cost another $900 million to $1.3 billion, plus more than $1 billion for replacement power. Both the repair and replacement power costs continue to rise.

Lynn Good, Duke executive vice president and chief financial officer, said the initial repair costs for Crystal River were developed in 2011, before engineers completed any significant analysis. She said no new costs estimates were available yet.

Crystal River's insurer, the Nuclear Electric Insurance Limited, has only made a partial payment on the initial crack. NEIL opened its own investigation of the damage last year and is no longer voluntarily paying any claims on the plant. Rogers said during Thursday's interview that the utility is set to meet with NEIL during the fourth quarter of this year in "non-binding mediation" over payment for damages to the plant.

Mark Cooper, senior fellow at the Institute for Energy and the Environment at Vermont Law School, said the growing tab on the Crystal River repair signals more cost for customers and the likelihood the plant will not return to service.

"Every day you don't reach a resolution is money out of the consumer's pocket," Cooper said. "Given slack demand, given the incredible cost of fixing it, the sooner you pull the plug, the better." But shutting down Crystal River isn't an easy calculation.

Duke's subsidiary, Progress Energy Florida, relies on natural gas plants to produce electricity. Crystal River is the utility's only nuclear plant in Florida.

"We definitely do not have the diversity we enjoy in other parts of the country," Rogers said.

Rogers could look toward the proposed Levy County nuclear project as an alternative. But that, too, isn't an easy decision.

Estimates project Levy to cost as much as $24 billion to build the two-reactor plant, which would make it the most expensive in history. Duke also has two other proposed nuclear projects in the Carolinas.

Whether to move forward with Levy will depend on such factors as customer demand, cost and energy diversity, Rogers said.

"I think the issue with Levy is really an issue of timing going forward," Rogers said. "Growth in sales have been anemic. There are a lot of key factors that we need to consider."

Whether to build any of the three new nuclear projects, Rogers said, will depend on the needs of the communities where they would produce power.

"All are in play," Rogers said. "We have greater diversity in the Carolinas, so that's not as much of a driving force. The future price of gas plays a role here as well."

Rogers said he sees any of Duke's new nuclear plants coming online in the 2020s, about a decade before existing plants shut down. For Florida, that could mean a period with no nuclear plants.

But Cooper and others who favor alternatives to nuclear say there are options to fill the void that would be left if the utility had no reactors in Florida.

"You diversify with efficiency and renewables," Cooper said. "You don't diversify with the nuclear stuff, which makes problems. That's a serious thing to think about."

Rogers will appear before the Florida Public Service Commission Aug. 13, where he is expected to talk about how the Progress and Duke merger will affect Florida consumers.

Comments
Clearwater tweaks downtown incentive program

Clearwater tweaks downtown incentive program

CLEARWATER — On the heels of intensive meetings with downtown property owners and potential business tenants, the city’s Community Redevelopment Agency has tweaked its incentive programs designed to attract businesses that would operate...
Published: 10/16/18
Tampa’s last Sears survived bankruptcy closings, but Westshore Plaza is dropping Sears anyway

Tampa’s last Sears survived bankruptcy closings, but Westshore Plaza is dropping Sears anyway

Sears’ long-foreshadowed bankruptcy filing Monday came with the blow that more than 140 of its remaining 700 locations would be closed in a bid to save the once robust and venerable chain of department stores. But some locations not even on th...
Updated: 11 minutes ago
Early Hurricane Michael claims: 38,000, $5.7M in damages

Early Hurricane Michael claims: 38,000, $5.7M in damages

As Panhandle residents began making their way back home over the weekend, clearer damage estimates began to arise: According to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, about 38,000 claims have been submitted for Hurricane Michael damage and $5.7 ...
Updated: 12 hours ago
Fish Tales Seafood House in St. Peterburg closes after nearly 20 years in business

Fish Tales Seafood House in St. Peterburg closes after nearly 20 years in business

Fish Tales Seafood House in St. Petersburg has closed its doors after nearly 20 years in business, the restaurant announced on its Facebook page Monday."It is with a heavy heart that I have to write this, but write it I must," the Facebook post state...
Published: 10/15/18
Tampa International Airport tops 20 million passengers in a year; St. Pete-Clearwater has biggest September ever

Tampa International Airport tops 20 million passengers in a year; St. Pete-Clearwater has biggest September ever

Tampa International Airport has surpassed the 20 million-passenger mark for the first time ever, closing out its budget year with more than 21 million passengers over a 12-month period.The airport exceeded its own expectations on Sept. 30 when it end...
Published: 10/15/18
Florida citrus expected to see 76 percent yield jump this season

Florida citrus expected to see 76 percent yield jump this season

This time last year, Florida was facing projections of its lowest orange yield in 75 years after the state’s citrus industry was ravaged by Hurricane Irma. But the most recent projections aren’t nearly as sour.The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s fir...
Published: 10/15/18
Drugmakers to disclose prices for medicines advertised on TV

Drugmakers to disclose prices for medicines advertised on TV

TRENTON, N.J. — Dozens of drugmakers will start disclosing the prices for U.S. prescription drugs advertised on TV. The prices won’t actually be shown in the TV commercials but the advertisement will include a website where the list price will be pos...
Published: 10/15/18
Hurricane Michael reminds us it’s past time to get smarter about where we build

Hurricane Michael reminds us it’s past time to get smarter about where we build

Avoidance is a great way to mitigate risk. As in, get out of trouble’s way, or don’t be there to begin with. When it comes to hurricanes, that good advice is getting harder to heed. In Florida, we continue to build along our coasts, ofte...
Published: 10/15/18
Sears files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy amid plunging sales, massive debt

Sears files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy amid plunging sales, massive debt

NEW YORK — Sears has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, buckling under its massive debt load and staggering losses. Sears once dominated the American retail landscape. But the big question is whether the shrunken version of itself can be via...
Published: 10/15/18
Candidates for Pinellas commission race pause to help with natural disasters

Candidates for Pinellas commission race pause to help with natural disasters

As Election Day nears, the candidates for Pinellas County Commission have shifted from campaigning to helping residents deal with the aftermath of natural disasters.Democrat Amy Kedron held a town hall meeting and helped draft policies for businesses...
Published: 10/15/18