Make us your home page

Florida investigating charges that bank defrauded state's pension fund

Florida prosecutors are investigating charges that a major New York bank hired to safeguard retirees' savings cheated them by overcharging for currency-exchange trades.

Attorney General Pam Bondi plans to take over a whistleblowers' lawsuit alleging that the Bank of New York Mellon defrauded Florida's pension fund with the secret markup on billions of dollars, collecting a higher currency-conversion price than it actually got and pocketing the difference. The whistleblowers filed a similar lawsuit in Virginia.

"On behalf of the state of Florida, we will not tolerate these actions and they will be held accountable,'' Bondi said in a statement.

She declined further comment and did not say how much money allegedly had been siphoned by the bank, which has custody of $150 billion in Florida taxpayer assets belonging to more than 1 million current and future retirees and hundreds of cities, counties, state agencies and school districts. But experts familiar with custodian banks' currency-exchange practices said the losses could amount to tens of millions of dollars.

A BNY Mellon spokesman said that the allegations are without merit and that the bank will vigorously defend itself.

Bondi's decision to pursue a civil case was sparked by the whistleblowers who sued the bank in Tallahassee in November 2009. That lawsuit remains under seal, something required for false claim lawsuits brought by private citizens unless a judge orders otherwise.

Bondi filed a motion Thursday asking a judge to unseal this one. The motion also said the attorney general's office had completed a review of documents supplied by the whistleblowers and concluded the state should take over the case. The state will file its own complaint soon.

Last month, Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli joined a similar lawsuit filed by the same confidential whistleblowers, who have banded together in a Delaware shell company that they call FX Analytics. Zachary Kitts, a lawyer for the whistleblowers, declined to comment.

Virginia's complaint accuses BNY Mellon of regularly reporting false currency-exchange costs to hide the fact it was profiting from the trades. It seeks $150 million in damages.

The Wall Street Journal identified one of the whistleblowers as Harry Markopolos, a Boston investor who uncovered Bernie Madoff's Ponzi scheme 10 years before regulators went after him.

SBA and BNY Mellon

For years, the State Board of Administration, which manages public investments, has been plagued by lapses in oversight. Like a lot of pensions, Florida lost money during the market meltdown. The pension now has rebounded to assets totaling more than $125 billion. Despite recent gains, however, the pension fund is still in the red.

Bondi doubles as a trustee overseeing the SBA. This week, fellow trustee Gov. Rick Scott announced a pension overhaul that would require thousands of state and local employees to contribute 5 percent of their salaries toward their retirements.

A spokesman said Scott was aware of Bondi's actions on the whistleblowers' case and "fully supports holding the vendors accountable.''

In hiring BNY Mellon in 2005, then-executive director Coleman Stipanovich said the SBA had lowered its costs.

On Friday, the SBA said it has paid the bank more than $35 million in fees since 2005. That does not include currency-exchange revenue, which is a growing source of profits for the bank in Florida because the state's pension fund has been boosting its investments abroad.

In the past 22 months, records show, SBA executive director Ash Williams approved documents that helped Mellon conduct trading for the SBA in Bulgaria, the United Arab Emirates, Romania, Tunisia and Kuwait.

Earlier questions

Even before the whistleblowers' lawsuit, SBA managers questioned some of Mellon's practices and the agency's own controls.

In August 2009, an internal audit flagged troubles with Mellon's SBA contract and the way the bank checked and reconciled the values of billions of dollars in securities.

Overvalued assets can hide losses and allow fund managers to collect higher management fees. The SBA agreed to tighten its monitoring.

The whistleblowers in Florida and elsewhere are bringing their cases under state False Claims Acts, which allow citizens to recover funds lost because of fraud in government programs.

They are not just going after BNY Mellon, however,

In 2009, then-California Attorney General Jerry Brown joined whistleblowers in a pending currency-exchange lawsuit against State Street Corp., seeking $200 million in damages.

Brown — now governor — said the bank had committed "unconscionable fraud." "This is just the latest example of how clever financial traders violate laws and rip off the public trust,'' he said.

State Street denied wrongdoing, as does BNY Mellon.

'The Wild West'

Experts call the currency-exchange market "The Wild West,'' because it's lightly regulated and long has used questionable practices.

"You can lose your shirt and more,'' said James Economides, co-founder of Amaces, a London-based provider of custodian monitoring services. "I'm sure there are people shocked and surprised. But there are others who suspected this and said, 'I don't really want to turn over the stone because I don't want to find what lurks underneath.' ''

Edward Siedle, a former Securities and Exchange Commission lawyer who investigates pension abuses, said most pensions that give banks custody of their assets fail to properly manage the relationships or examine the compensation the banks get.

"They secretly profit in numerous ways that may be harmful to pension clients,'' Siedle said. Custodians have long offered artificially low custody fees, he said, "while they enjoy hidden profits from services like securities lending, money market fund cash 'sweeps' and currency exchange.''

Times researcher Natalie Watson and computer-assisted reporting specialist Connie Humburg contributed to this report.

Florida investigating charges that bank defrauded state's pension fund 02/04/11 [Last modified: Friday, February 4, 2011 10:49pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. The Iron Yard coding academy to close in St. Petersburg


    ST. PETERSBURG — The Iron Yard, a code-writing academy with a location in downtown St. Petersburg, will close for good this summer.

    Instructors (from left) Mark Dewey, Jason Perry, and Gavin Stark greet the audience at The Iron Yard, 260 1st Ave. S, in St. Petersburg during "Demo Day" Friday, Oct. 7, 2016, at The Iron Yard, which is an immersive code school that is part of a trend of trying to address the shortage of programmers.  The academy is closing this summer.  [LARA CERRI   |   Times]
  2. Florida's unemployment rate drops for fourth straight month


    How low can Florida's unemployment go? Pretty low, according to the state's latest unemployment numbers. The Sunshine State's unemployment rate dropped to 4.1 percent for June, down from 4.3 percent in May, state officials said Friday morning.

    Florida's unemployment level dropped to 4.1 percent in June from 4.3 percent in May. |  [Times file photo]
  3. Is sinkhole damage sinking Tampa Bay property values?

    Real Estate

    On a scale of desirability, the house for sale on Whittner Drive in Land O' Lakes would rank fairly low. It's a short sale; it sits on an unstabilized sinkhole and it's within a few miles of two houses that collapsed into a gargantuan hole July 16.

    A gated community in Hernando's Spring Hill area, Pristine Place has long been susceptible to sinkholes with nearly a third of its houses with documented sinkhole damage by 2012. Today, however, many houses with repaired sinkhole damage are selling for more than houses without any issues. [WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times file photo]
  4. The real estate pros in charge of Tampa's $3 billion makeover are younger than you think

    Working Life

    TAMPA — Brooke May, a 36-year-old senior construction project manager, knew she wanted to work for Strategic Property Partners the minute she met some team members involved with the group's massive downtown Tampa makeover.

    Matt Davis, Vice President of Development posed for a portrait in the Strategic Property Partners office in Channelside on July 12, 2017, in Tampa, Fla. [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]
  5. St. Pete Beach may loosen beach drinking rules for hotel guests

    Local Government

    ST. PETE BEACH — Drinking a beer, a cocktail or a glass of wine may soon be legal on this city's beaches, but only for hotel guests in and around their hotel's beachfront cabanas.

    Registered hotel guests would be able to drink alcoholic beverages at their cabanas on the beach under a new rule the St. Pete Beach City Commission is considering.