Make us your home page

Florida senators, after emotional debate, defeat key provision of immigration bill

TALLAHASSEE — In an emotional debate where senators choked up and recalled the struggles of their immigrant forebears, the Florida Senate on Tuesday unexpectedly defeated one of Gov. Rick Scott's pledges to crack down on illegal immigration.

The 23-16 vote to defeat the amendment to institute E-Verify, the federal government's system to check a worker's immigration status, could ultimately doom any immigration crackdown.

The annual legislative session ends Friday, and members of the House say they won't take a watered-down immigration bill without a stronger E-Verify component.

"The process does not really allow for a piece of legislation like this to come in the waning hours," said Rep. William Snyder, R-Stuart, a mild-mannered former Miami-Dade police officer and the bill's House sponsor.

He called the possibility of the House taking up the Senate's immigration bill "improbable." The Senate might wait on the House to take up the measure. The House might wait for the Senate. So the bill itself could be dead because the E-Verify amendment was killed.

If Tuesday's vote on E-Verify is any indication, the bill's passage isn't certain in the Senate.

"I couldn't vote for this in a million years," said Sen. Gwen Margolis, a Miami Democrat who fought back tears as she told of growing up with her grandparents who didn't speak English.

Just before his E-Verify amendment was defeated, Sen. John Thrasher, R-St. Augustine, said it was needed to prevent terrorism. Had E-Verify been used, he claimed, some of the 9/11 hijackers who lived in Florida might have been caught. (PolitiFact Florida rated his assertion Pants on Fire.)

Thrasher's amendment would have required all state agencies to use E-Verify — and imposed a fine on any employer found to have hired an undocumented immigrant.

The bill would limit the use of E-Verify to state workforce agencies recommending candidates for employment and to applications for any government benefits. Law enforcement would also have to check the immigration status of a person who has been arrested. The House has a stricter immigration proposal, HB 7089.

In the Senate, proponents of the E-Verify plan included Sen. Don Gaetz, a Niceville Republican who recounted how his maternal grandparents settled in the Red River Valley in North Dakota, where Gaetz's mother was born in a sod house.

"I understand a little bit about immigrant roots," Gaetz said.

The vote against E-Verify could pose political troubles for Haridopolos, the Republican Senate president from Merritt Island who is running for the U.S. Senate. Haridopolos did not vow to impose the federal system on private employers, but tea party conservatives wanted an Arizona-style law with E-Verify.

Haridopolos was on the losing side of a vote that he said was "not really" surprising, though he thought it would be closer.

"I've proven on many different times I'm not a dictator," he said, noting members vote their will.

To grass roots Republicans, he said he would point out that his chamber is fiscally conservative, having cut spending and taxes.

The linchpin behind the defeat of the E-Verify amendment was one of the most respected Republican members of the chamber, Sen. J.D. Alexander.

A Central Florida farmer from Lake Wales, Alexander was handed the bill after Haridopolos yanked it from Sen. Anitere Flores, a Miami Republican who was not willing to accept a more hard-line immigration stance. On Tuesday, the legislative Hispanic caucus officially opposed the Senate and House bills.

Operating on just four hours of sleep after marathon budget talks, Alexander gave an impassioned speech about the difficulties of farming and the families of migrant laborers who struggle to make their children a part of the American dream.

"I resent that I have to be asked to choose between hardworking people and somebody's uninformed knowledge," said Alexander, giving his captivated colleagues a firsthand account of housing guest workers from Mexico who picked his crops two years ago. "You can't get anybody to come do this stuff, folks. And it's the same thing, whether it's construction, or whether it's hotels. Americans don't want to do it."

After session was over Tuesday, Alexander acknowledged the bill could run out of time.

"I'd rather get it right than move it quickly," he said. "It's getting awfully late in the process."

The vote was a big defeat for Scott, who made E-Verify a top priority during his Republican primary race, saying that all businesses in the state should use the program.

Scott had also promised an Arizona-style immigration law that essentially required local police to double as immigration agents. Amid fears of racial profiling, the Senate refused to take up that provision.

Told on Tuesday the Senate bill did not include E-Verify, Scott declined comment, saying he wanted to read the bill. Instead, he repeated his insistence for a law that lets local law enforcement check people's immigration status.

"If they're doing something wrong, they ought to be asked if they're legal or not," he said. "It's got to be fair and there can't be any racial profiling."

Times/Herald staff writers Michael C. Bender and Mary Ellen Klas contributed to this report. Patricia Mazzei can be reached at

Fast facts

Florida Senate's immigration bill

Key components of the latest version of SB 2040:

• Requires state workforce agencies to use E-Verify for anyone who applies for a job in person.

• Requires an immigration status check for anyone applying for government benefits.

•Requires law enforcement to check the immigration status of people who are arrested and booked.

.fast facts

Florida Senate's immigration bill

Key components of the latest version of SB 2040:

• Requires state workforce agencies to use E-Verify for anyone who applies for a job in person.

• Requires an immigration status check for anyone applying for government benefits.

•Requires law enforcement to check the immigration status of people who are arrested and booked.

Florida senators, after emotional debate, defeat key provision of immigration bill 05/03/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, May 3, 2011 11:41pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Where to pig out for National Bacon Lovers Day

    Food & Dining

    That's right: Sunday is the national day devoted to all things bacon, National Bacon Lovers Day. Which, really, isn't too different from the other 364 days of the year. But here's a little roundup of some special places to celebrate everyone's favorite meat snack (seriously, even vegans have a grudging respect …

    A creme-filled doughnut topped with maple frosting and bacon at Dough on MacDill Avenue in Tampa.
  2. The Penny Hoarder tops 79 fastest growing Tampa Bay companies on Inc. 5000


    ST. PETERSBURG — The Penny Hoarder today further cemented its reputation as one of the country's fastest growing companies. The personal finance web site business ranks 25th nationwide and tops in the Tampa Bay market for growth on the just released 2017 Inc. 5000 list of fastest growing businesses.

    One of the fastest growing startups in the country is St. Petersburg's The Penny Hoarder, a financial advice web site aimed at helping readers save money. Playing a game in the office is (right to left) founder and CEO Kyle Taylor, vice president of business operations Vishal Mahtani and executive editor Alexis Grant. [Courtesy of The Penny Hoarder]
  3. Here's what it's like inside a writhing, growling Howl-O-Scream audition


    TAMPA — At Busch Gardens, a Howl-O-Scream manager is hunting zombies.

    Auditioner Natalie Rychel, 20, of Tampa, Fla., high fives director of atmosphere Morgan Malice after being selected for a job for Bush Gardens' Howl-O-Scream during an audition at the theme park on Friday, August 11, 2017, in Tampa, Fla. (From left) Auditioners Jared Shipley, 20, of Lakeland, Fla., and Lincoln Scott, 41, of Riverview, Fla., look over. This year, Howl-O-Scream will take place from September 22 to October 29 at Bush Gardens. ALESSANDRA DA PRA  |   Times
  4. Tampa Bay homeowners sue JPMorgan Chase for billing on already-paid mortgages


    ST. PETERSBURG — Two Tampa Bay homeowners are suing JPMorgan Chase Bank for attempting to continue to collect on what they say were already-paid-off mortgages.

    JPMorgan Chase is the subject of a lawsuit by two Tampa Bay homeowners who say the bank attempted to collect on mortgages they already paid off. | [Getty Images]
  5. Housing starts fall in July

    Real Estate

    WASHINGTON — The Commerce Department said Wednesday that housing starts fell 4.8 percent in July to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.16 million. Groundbreakings for multi-family buildings such as apartments slumped 17.1 percent, while single-family house construction slipped 0.5 percent.

    On Wednesday, the Commerce Department reported on U.S. home construction in July. 
[AP file photo]