Make us your home page

Hollywood futures market just another invitation to trading corruption

Investors learned last week of Wall Street's latest attraction — a "futures" market where anyone from casual moviegoers to Hollywood moguls could wager on the success of upcoming movies.

In many ways, the Hollywood Stock Exchange is simply the logical extension of the recent trend in financial markets, which have long since outgrown their original purpose — to raise capital for real businesses — and have now turned themselves into high-tech casinos offering endless opportunity for speculation.

The rationale for this market in movie futures is roughly the same as the one offered for stock and commodities futures, or credit default swaps or even the market in "synthetic" CDOs, those securities designed to mimic the performance of the real-life packages of mortgages and other debt instruments. Apologists talk about how much "liquidity" they bring to these markets, magically lowering costs and moderating price swings while allowing all manner of businesses to hedge their risks. And because these markets can accomplish these things with absolutely no unpleasant side effects, it is folly to even consider regulating them and stifling this wealth-producing innovation.

To understand what hogwash this all is, take a closer look at the Hollywood Stock Exchange, which the New York Times reported will launch soon.

As with all futures markets, the defense of this one starts with the argument that it's perfectly benign to allow betting on a movie's box office performance because it won't have any impact on actual ticket sales — just as betting in the stands won't affect the outcome of the match on the field. But, of course, that argument breaks down when it turns out that the bettors in the stands are the players in the field, which is exactly what the Hollywood Stock Exchange envisions.

If nothing else, the movie exchange is an obvious invitation to trading with insider information, allowing those producing a movie to bet on its outcome against outsiders who have never read the script, reviewed the dailies or seen the marketing budget. And surely it won't be long before theater owners and moviegoers begin checking prices on the exchange before deciding which films to show and attend, thereby altering the outcomes the exchange is meant to forecast.

Because there is no limit on the amount you can bet on any movie, it is possible that a film that cost only $100 million to produce could cause financial losses many times that amount, creating a contagion effect that could dry up funding for the entire industry. Such concerns are analogous to what happened in recent years as a result of abusive and unregulated trading on futures and derivatives markets.

Does anyone really believe that Goldman Sachs or JPMorgan Chase would not have been more careful with those crappy mortgage securities if they didn't know they could hedge their exposure with credit-default swaps?

Have we already forgotten that, thanks to synthetic CDOs, defaults of several hundred billion dollars in subprime mortgages could generate a trillion dollars in losses to the financial system?

And if it is illegal to short a stock you neither own nor control, why allow "naked" short-selling of bonds, credit-default swaps or an ounce of copper?

The truth is that no great economic or social purpose is served by allowing people to profit from assets they do not control or hedge risks they do not have.

The Hollywood Stock Exchange is another misguided financial innovation that serves no purpose other than to enrich a handful of clever speculators and the vast industry that serves them.

Hollywood futures market just another invitation to trading corruption 03/14/10 [Last modified: Sunday, March 14, 2010 5:42pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa Bay small businesses give Tampa B+ for regulatory climate


    In a recent survey about small business sentiments toward state and local government policies that affect them, Tampa Bay ranked at No. 25 out of 80 — a B+ overall.

    Tampa Bay ranked No. 25 out of 80 in a recent survey about how small business owners feel about state and local government policies that affect them. | [Times file photo]
  2. Seminole Heights restaurants face struggles amid killings, post-Irma

    Food & Dining

    TAMPA — The neighborhood's hip circle of popular, well-regarded restaurants is feeling the squeeze in the wake of a recent killing spree. And the timing is rough.

    Ella’s Americana Folk Art Cafe has been taking precautions in light of the Seminole Heights killings: keeping the lights on all night and having employees walk to their cars in groups.
  3. St. Pete-Clearwater holding food, supply drive for hurricane refugees


    CLEARWATER — St. Pete-Clearwater International Airport and Allegiant Air are holding a food and supply drive for the Hispanic Outreach Center in Pinellas County. The event, which will benefit refugees displaced by Hurricane Maria, will be held Tuesday from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. at the airport at 14700 Terminal Blvd.

    St. Pete-Clearwater International Airport and Allegiant Air are hosting a food and supplies drive Tuesday for refugees displaced by Hurricane Maria. | [Times file photo]
  4. Tallest building in Pinellas County in search of a new name

    Real Estate

    ST. PETERSBURG — The name "Priatek" is gone from Pinellas County's tallest building, perhaps to be replaced by that of a much better-known company new to the Tampa Bay area.

    The Priatek name is off of downtown St. Petersburg's tallest building.
 [LARA CERRI  |   Times.  2015]
  5. Estuary wins pier design contest for the Lee Roy Selmon Expressway extension

    Real Estate

    TAMPA — And the winner is… Estuary.

    Voters overwhelmingly supported a pier design called Estuary for the $200-million extension of the Lee Roy Selmon Expressway in Tampa.
[Courtesy of AECOM]