Monday, November 19, 2018
Business

PolitiFact: Paul exaggerates degree of foreign aid theft

The statement

"We give (foreign aid) to developing countries, and 70 percent of it's stolen off the top."

Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., Jan. 11 in a Senate confirmation hearing

The ruling

There is no question that the aid bucket can leak. Sergio Gor, Paul's spokesman, told us Paul "was pointing out how often foreign aid is stolen."

But neither Paul's office nor any expert we reached could point to any study that found that 70 percent of what we give winds up stolen.

Gor sent us an article by noted aid researcher William Easterly at New York University that argued something altogether different.

Easterly wrote that as of 2008, 76 percent of all American aid went to countries judged by the private consulting group PRS to be most corrupt. Does that mean all that money was lost?

No. The corruption ranking is an indirect measure at best. It aims to help businesses figure out the risk of investing in a country and puts the most weight on patronage, nepotism and "suspiciously close ties between politics and business."

Easterly himself told us that his analysis is "suggestive" but in no way conclusive that 70 percent of aid money is stolen.

"It is inherently impossible to calculate the number 'x percent of aid is stolen' from the numbers that I use on how much aid goes to corrupt countries," Easterly said. "The actual stealing of aid happens mostly in secret, using many tricks intended to deceive any outside observers. So nobody knows how much is actually stolen."

Easterly wrote recently that in the name of fighting terrorism, the United States has "redirected aid money to some of the most autocratic, corrupt, and oppressive regimes in the world" such as Uzbekistan, Ethiopia and Uganda. He argued that this increased the risk of money going astray, but again, he said he couldn't quantify the diversion.

Morten Broberg, a law professor at Copenhagen University, focuses on corruption in development assistance and humanitarian aid.

"I do not recall coming across any detailed and convincing statistics," Broberg told us.

Broberg called the 70 percent figure incorrect.

Gor, Paul's spokesman, told us "there have been entire projects which have been fraudulently executed." He pointed to an op-ed about Nigeria that claimed, without any documentation, that hundreds of billions of dollars had been stolen from the government since 1960, an amount nearly equal to the foreign aid donors had sent.

He also cited an Economist article that said that a year after Western governments had given the African nation of Malawi $1.2 billion, "corrupt officials, businessmen and politicians pinched at least $30 million from the Malawian treasury."

If true, that would be a lot of money, but it would amount to about 2.5 percent of the total aid — not 70 percent.

Providing aid in war zones is particularly susceptible to fraud. Government auditors for the U.S. Agency for International Development investigated 25 cases of fraud and corruption within the humanitarian aid effort in Syria. In one case, a Turkish vendor had replaced lentils with salt in food ration kits for Syrians running from the fighting. Out of $835 million spent, they said their investigations "resulted in more than $11.5 million in savings."

While theft is real, and possibly extreme on individual projects, it is not on the scale Paul asserted.

We rate this claim False.

Edited for print. Read the full version at PolitiFact.com.

Comments
Brightline-Virgin rail service from Tampa to Orlando has estimated cost of $1.7 billion

Brightline-Virgin rail service from Tampa to Orlando has estimated cost of $1.7 billion

A financing plan filed last week with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission offers new details about the partnership between Miami-based Brightline and Sir Richard Branson's Virgin Group.
Updated: 6 hours ago
St. Petersburg, four other Florida cities, make top 20 list of hottest LGBTQ holiday destinations

St. Petersburg, four other Florida cities, make top 20 list of hottest LGBTQ holiday destinations

St. Petersburg, which has been trying to draw in more gay tourists, has been named No. 11 on a list of top 20 gay holiday destinations this year.
Updated: 10 hours ago
Thanksgiving gas prices headed for two-year low

Thanksgiving gas prices headed for two-year low

Gas prices in Florida are on track to be the lowest in two years, a boon for the 2.5 million travelers AAA, The Auto Club Group, expects to hit the roadways for the holiday this week.
Updated: 11 hours ago
IRS: Tarpon Springs couple used 'sham' companies to keep from paying $8.8 million in taxes

IRS: Tarpon Springs couple used 'sham' companies to keep from paying $8.8 million in taxes

The federal government accuses William and Regina Planes of Tarpon Springs of creating "alter egos'' and "sham trusts'' to keep the IRS from collecting more than $8.8 million in taxes they owed.
Published: 11/19/18
Who’s selling sports goods after midnight on Black Friday? Where do you go to get a tie at 3 a.m.?

Who’s selling sports goods after midnight on Black Friday? Where do you go to get a tie at 3 a.m.?

This holiday overview of area retail outlets guides you to the answers
Published: 11/19/18
Ernest Hooper: Initiative provides chance to make a better Tampa for pedestrians, cyclists

Ernest Hooper: Initiative provides chance to make a better Tampa for pedestrians, cyclists

Viable, safe alternatives to using a car in Hillsborough County remain as uncommon as snow.
Published: 11/19/18
Make-A-Wish builds Pinellas special needs teen a custom playhouse

Make-A-Wish builds Pinellas special needs teen a custom playhouse

Make-A-Wish Southern Florida surprised a Pinellas County teen with a custom backyard play set specifically designed for his needs.
Published: 11/19/18
Hernando Business Happenings

Hernando Business Happenings

News and notes on local businesses
Published: 11/19/18
Dear Penny: I need a car, but my credit is awful. Will I get ripped off?

Dear Penny: I need a car, but my credit is awful. Will I get ripped off?

Some advice on how to find an affordable used car at a price you can afford.
Published: 11/19/18
Tarpon Springs eases development rules on Sponge Docks

Tarpon Springs eases development rules on Sponge Docks

Development will become easier at both ends of the docks, though officials say the character won't change.
Published: 11/19/18