Saturday, November 25, 2017
Business

PunditFact: George Will's comparison of tax preparers, firefighters based on outdated data

RECOMMENDED READING


The statement

"America has more people employed as tax preparers (1.2 million) than as police and firefighters."

George Will, July 12 in a column

The ruling

Newspaper columnist and TV pundit George Will says the current U.S. tax code takes more manpower to maneuver than firefighting and law enforcement combined.

"The complexity of the code, which is about 4 million words, is why America has more people employed as tax preparers (1.2 million) than as police and firefighters," Will wrote in a July 12 column on tax reform.

According to the National Taxpayer Advocate's annual report to Congress this year, the 2016 tax code indeed came to roughly 4 million words. And even they agreed it's convoluted.

The tax code "rewards taxpayers who can afford expensive tax advice and discriminates against taxpayers who cannot," the report said.

But are there more Americans employed as tax preparers than police and firefighters?

We found it's not the case.

Will did not respond to our request for comment. The number in the story linked to a U.S. News & World Report article from 2012, which we eventually traced back to an Internal Revenue Service report citing a 2007 statistic.

The number given was that between 900,000 and 1.2 million people were "preparing tax returns for a fee."

We asked the IRS for a more recent estimate.

About 713,448 people had current preparer tax identification numbers, or PTINs, in 2017, the closest estimate to the number of people employed as tax preparers this year.

This is an annually renewed credential that the IRS requires of every tax preparer, a prerequisite that wasn't in place when the original estimate Will cited was created.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics found in May 2016 that 657,690 people are employed as police and sheriff's patrol officers.

In turn, the BLS counted 315,910 firefighters.

When we added the number of these civil officers together, they exceeded tax preparers by 260,152 people.

The BLS had a much lower figure for people employed as tax preparers — 70,030.

But these don't include individuals who were self-employed or identified as attorneys, accountants or auditors, as the survey allows people to identify only one occupation.

Will isn't the only person to make this mistake. A May 13 Economist article also included the outdated information.

We rate this statement False.

Edited for print. Read the full version at PunditFact.com.

Comments
Black Friday still a brick-and-mortar experience for some

Black Friday still a brick-and-mortar experience for some

TAMPA ó Standing in a frantic line at Best Buy on Thanksgiving, one young woman beat the system when she showed off the receipt for her new TV, which she had just purchased on her phone. She was waiting to pick it up."I didnít know you could do that,...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Woman, 51, robbed in Tyrone Square Mall parking lot, police say

ST. PETERSBURG ó A woman was robbed after a man followed her to her car in a mall parking lot Thursday night and shot once at her, police said. The 51-year-old woman, whose identity St. Petersburg police are withholding, was not injured. She was walk...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Take steps against holiday fraud with private WiFi, fraud alerts

Take steps against holiday fraud with private WiFi, fraud alerts

The holiday shopping season bring hosts of discounts and deals, but it also brings something less cheery ó fraud. According to a forecast by ACI Worldwide, a payment processing company, retailers are expected to see a 30 percent jump in fraud this ye...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Fourth Streetís mom and pop motels are a dying breed

Fourth Streetís mom and pop motels are a dying breed

ST. PETERSBURG ó Billboards as far north as Tennessee beckoned tourists by the thousands to St. Petersburgís Fourth Street calling it "the longest motel street in the world" in the 1940s and í50s. There were 95 motels between the Gandy Bridge and Cen...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Suburban-bound millennials and other 2018 housing trends to watch

Suburban-bound millennials and other 2018 housing trends to watch

Whatís ahead for real estate in 2018? Zillow economists put their heads together and offered up a laundry list of forecasts and predictions. The chief one to remember? Inventory shortages of homes for sale which challenged the market in 2017 will pe...
Published: 11/24/17
Across country, small retailers aim for emotional ties big chains may lack

Across country, small retailers aim for emotional ties big chains may lack

Associated PressSome smaller retailers will tug at shoppersí heartstrings during the holidays, trying to create an emotional experience or connection that a big national chain might not provide.Store owners are going well beyond the usual holiday dec...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Inkwood Books among retailers banking on ‘Small Business Saturday’

Inkwood Books among retailers banking on ‘Small Business Saturday’

TAMPA — By Tuesday evening, at least 50 cardboard boxes were still stacked against the shop’s wall, each labeled clearly with a black sharpie. "Biographies" "Pets" "Fiction" "Music" While the front of the store and new children’...
Updated: 11 hours ago
As Tampa Bay economy matures, more key people bear watching. Letís get started.

As Tampa Bay economy matures, more key people bear watching. Letís get started.

Whatís coming down the economic pike for Tampa Bay? Whoís driving this metro economy into 2018 and beyond? Change ó people, issues, business focus ó can be a good thing. It keeps places like geographically challenged Tampa Bay nimble with fresh blood...
Published: 11/22/17
Updated: 11/24/17
Six years and counting: Allegiant Air reaches agreement with flight attendants

Six years and counting: Allegiant Air reaches agreement with flight attendants

ST. PETERSBURG ó After six years of negotiations, Las Vegas-based Allegiant Air and its flight attendants union reached a tentative contract to improve worker pay and benefits and solidify airline policies."We feel like itís an agreement that is cert...
Published: 11/22/17
Workers at luxury St. Pete condo tower say they are owed thousands

Workers at luxury St. Pete condo tower say they are owed thousands

ST. PETERSBURG ó Nearly three dozen workers at ONE St. Petersburg, a luxury condo tower under construction in the heart of downtown, havenít been paid in weeks and are owed thousands of dollars.With the holidays nearing, some of the men say they are ...
Published: 11/22/17