Saturday, May 26, 2018
Business

Even with Shore Acres, St. Petersburg paid 8 times more into flood insurance than claimed

If there's an argument that Florida residents already pay too much for flood insurance, Shore Acres is it.

The low-lying neighborhood of 2,300 homes in northeast St. Petersburg is one of the most flood-prone areas in Tampa Bay.

Since 1978, so many Shore Acres houses have flooded two, three, even five times that they have helped make St. Petersburg one of the top 30 places in the country for claims filed with the beleaguered National Flood Insurance Program.

Even so, the flooding that has hit Shore Acres is not why the flood program is $24 billion in debt.

St. Petersburg homeowners ­— through their flood insurance premiums — have more than paid for the cost of repairing homes in Shore Acres and every other property that has flooded in the city over the past 35 years.

In fact, St. Petersburg property owners have paid eight times more money into the flood program than they have gotten back to cover losses — $480 million paid in versus $55 million received, records show.

Statewide, Floridians have paid $4 into the program for every $1 returned.

"We have done more than our fair share to make the (flood program) financially sound,'' Gov. Rick Scott said in a recent letter to Florida's two U.S. senators.

Yet thousands of homeowners in Shore Acres and the rest of coastal Florida face huge premium increases because of the Biggert-Waters act, which phases out insurance subsidies for homes built before the federal government began requiring tougher construction standards in flood zones. Most homeowners will see premiums jump as much as 20 percent a year over the next five years, while subsidies will end immediately when homes are sold or policies lapse.

A bipartisan group in the U.S. House and Senate has agreed on a measure to delay the increases for four years. If Congress fails to act, flood insurance premiums could soar to $10,000 a year or more.

Eliminating the subsidies has been cast as an effort to make homeowners pay their fair share.

The reality on the ground in St. Petersburg raises questions about that argument.

Since 1991, the city has spent $9.2 million on flood prevention in Shore Acres alone, raising several streets by 6 inches and building vaults that keep water from backing up in drainage pipes during high tides.

"It's not going to help when the tide is higher than seawalls," said Thomas Gibson, St. Petersburg's capital improvements director. "But the vaults do prevent routine tidal flooding of streets, which helps protect everybody's cars and other infrastructure affected by saltwater."

The results can be seen in declining flood claims, according to a Tampa Bay Times analysis of the 354 St. Petersburg single-family residences that have had at least two claims since 1978.

Even houses that flooded in Hurricane Frances in 2004 have remained dry since.

"I've never seen a drop of water come anywhere near my property since they did that work,'' said lawyer William Walker, whose home on Denver Street in Shore Acres flooded three times before the city made improvements.

If the proposed rate increases go forward, options are limited for Walker and other homeowners.

Dropping flood insurance is possible only for those who don't have mortgages. Tearing down an old house and building bigger and higher generally makes sense only in prime waterfront locations.

A few owners have raised existing houses.

Retired police Officer Billy Atkins and his wife, Bonnie, bought their 1,200-square-foot Shore Acres home in 1977. In June 1982, a no-name storm sent 10 inches of water seeping into the house.

Three years later, water rose 18 inches inside while Hurricane Elena stalled off the coast for days.

Sick of dealing with ruined furniture and flooring, the Atkins spent $20,000 to raise the house 3 feet. That was enough to keep them dry in 1996 when Tropical Storm Josephine swamped more than 900 Shore Acres homes, and in 2004, when Hurricane Frances flooded a few hundred.

But the Atkins' home is still a few feet lower than required by coastal construction standards, meaning they still pay $1,800 a year for flood insurance and will be hit with big increases every year unless they drop coverage.

"We could have gone a little higher," Bonnie Atkins said, "and I wish we had.''

Today, though, the cost of elevating a house can be prohibitive.

Mark Roesch, owner of a Largo house-moving company, quotes rates of about $45 a square foot to raise a home 3 to 5 feet, and $100 a square foot to raise one 10 feet.

That works out to $120,000 for a modest 1,200-square-foot house. And that doesn't include thousands of dollars to add stairs and redo the driveway and landscaping.

After news of impending rate hikes, Roesch said he had about 30 calls from people interested in elevating their homes. He recently won a bid to raise a 947-square-foot cottage on Bayou Grande Boulevard NE, the most flood-prone street in St. Petersburg.

In the past four decades, 52 houses on Bayou Grande have flooded at least twice, the Times analysis found.

The owner of the small bayfront home has applied for a grant from the Federal Emergency Management Agency that would pay 75 percent of the elevation cost. The grant program is so little publicized and the application process so tedious that she was the only St. Petersburg resident to apply this year.

Statewide, 76 Florida home­owners applied for FEMA grants this year and are awaiting approval, which could take several months.

Even though his company stands to profit from the flood insurance crisis, Roesch is appalled by the potentially sky-high rates.

"What they're trying to do,'' he said, "is absurd.''

Susan Taylor Martin can be contacted at [email protected]

     
Comments
An American Airlines passenger was refused beer - so he screamed, fought and spit blood, FBI says

An American Airlines passenger was refused beer - so he screamed, fought and spit blood, FBI says

It began, as so many plane debacles seem to, with strange sounds in the bathroom.They were the noises of Jason Felix, one of the passengers on Wednesday’s American Airlines flight out of Saint Croix, according to a FBI affidavit recounting events lea...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Is the Lightning’s Jeff Vinik the best owner in professional sports?

Is the Lightning’s Jeff Vinik the best owner in professional sports?

Hope of another Stanley Cup has dissolved, and soon the ice will follow. Yet even if sorrow is the price of devotion, the true hockey fans will still buy in when the next season comes around.That concept may not be unique to Tampa Bay, but it does se...
Published: 05/26/18
Five members of 69ers motorcycle gang indicted on federal charges

Five members of 69ers motorcycle gang indicted on federal charges

Last year three members of the 69ers Motorcycle Club gang were implicated in the execution of a rival gang leader in the middle of rush hour traffic in Pasco County.Now those three and two other 69ers members have been indicted on federal charges tha...
Published: 05/25/18
With makeover, ZooTampa at Lowry Park takes a page from the theme parks

With makeover, ZooTampa at Lowry Park takes a page from the theme parks

TAMPA — Behind the construction walls near the carousel at ZooTampa at Lowry Park, hammers, saws and power drills made a racket in the blazing Friday heat. A raft full of 100-pound water jugs took test trips on the new Roaring Springs ride set ...
Published: 05/25/18
U.S. news outlets block European readers over new privacy rules

U.S. news outlets block European readers over new privacy rules

LONDON — U.S. news outlets including The Chicago Tribune, The Los Angeles Times, The Orlando Sentinel and The Arizona Daily Star abruptly blocked access to their websites from Europe on Friday, choosing to black out readers rather than comply with a ...
Published: 05/25/18
Tampa Electric appeals OSHA findings for October accident

Tampa Electric appeals OSHA findings for October accident

TAMPA — Tampa Electric Co. is appealing a recent citation by federal regulators. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration hit the utility with a $76,050 fine and a "serious" violation in April following its investigation into an accident in ...
Published: 05/25/18
Fiat Chrysler recalls 4.8 million cars, warning owners: Don’t use the cruise control

Fiat Chrysler recalls 4.8 million cars, warning owners: Don’t use the cruise control

Associated PressDETROIT — Fiat Chrysler is recalling 4.8 million vehicles in the U.S. because in rare but terrifying circumstances, drivers may not be able to turn off the cruise control. The company is warning owners not to use cruise control until...
Published: 05/25/18
Federal Reserve chairman warns his agency must be free from political pressure

Federal Reserve chairman warns his agency must be free from political pressure

Associated PressFederal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell warned Friday that the Fed’s independence from political pressure must be respected if it is to succeed in controlling inflation, maximizing employment and regulating the financial system. His re...
Published: 05/25/18
Restaurants like Ford’s Garage use the experience to get you in the door

Restaurants like Ford’s Garage use the experience to get you in the door

Tim Butler’s first car was a Ford Model A pick-up truck — a pearl fawn and cherry red pick-up he got his senior year in high school from his dad, who renovates antique cars. That’s why as Butler waited for a table at the Ford’...
Published: 05/25/18
St. Petersburg man fined $507,513 in penny stock scheme

St. Petersburg man fined $507,513 in penny stock scheme

TAMPA — A St. Petersburg man was fined $507,513 and permanently barred from participating in the offering of a penny stock in a case involving a scheme to manipulate the price of Aureus, a penny stock company incorporated in Nevada, officials said Fr...
Published: 05/25/18