Make us your home page

Judges blame banks for foreclosure slowdowns, but some see good in delay

Half a decade since the housing bust, many foreclosures are showing their age. A quarter of cases now in Hillsborough court are at least 3 years old.

So who's keeping Florida's more than 350,000 pending foreclosures in court? Judges largely blame the banks. State court data show banks regularly delay cases so long that judges drop them for lack of action.

That's right: The same industry facing billions of dollars in punishment for hastily whizzing foreclosures through court a few years ago now isn't moving fast enough, court leaders say.

"Foreclosures should be one of the simplest forms of civil litigation … but the lenders are sometimes their own worst enemies," said Thomas McGrady, chief judge of the Sixth Judicial Circuit over Pinellas and Pasco counties.

"For whatever reason — a business decision, moratorium issues or they're just overloaded — they don't seem willing to push the cases they've filed," he said.

Banks defend their foreclosure practices by blaming overloaded courts for the slog.

"We're trying to speed (cases) up after we get to the point where we can't work with the borrower anymore," but court overloads are a bottleneck, said Anthony DiMarco, the head state lobbyist for the Florida Bankers Association. "I don't think anyone was geared for the magnitude of what was coming."

Whoever is to blame, you won't find many lawyers or homeowners complaining. In fact, they argue slowdowns are exactly what most cases need.

They allow homeowners to work on short sales or loan modifications that save the banks money and keep people in their homes. And they keep repossessed homes from flooding the market, preserving local home prices and helping neighborhoods.

But with a "faster foreclosures" bill approved by lawmakers and now awaiting Gov. Rick Scott's response, lawyers worry the cases will be squeezed through court, hurting both homeowners and banks.

Hurried foreclosures would force banks "to throw people out of their houses when they don't want to," St. Petersburg foreclosure-defense lawyer Matt Weidner said. "What if the judge could wave a wand and all those foreclosures were instantly granted? Where would we be?"

• • •

State civil court standards in Florida say nonjury cases like foreclosures should take a year at most. The average Florida foreclosure, research firm RealtyTrac said, lasts about 900 days.

Pinellas and Pasco courts had nearly 29,000 pending foreclosures by April, more even than a year ago, showing judges were unable to clear old cases quicker than new ones piled on, state court data show. And half of Hillsborough courts' 24,000 pending foreclosures are more than 2 years old.

It's obvious why homeowners don't want to speed along their eviction. But what do banks, who drive the cases and have so much money on the line, stand to gain from slowing down?

It's not sloth, lawyers said, but shrewd calculation. The faster they take over a home, the quicker they assume full liability and the costs of upkeep, fees and resale. Negotiating a short sale or modifying a loan can often net them less hassle while preserving their bottom line.

"Even when the right to foreclosure is clear," judges wrote in a backlog reduction plan in April, "a lender may have a disincentive to proceed."

Because the banks want cash flow, not old homes, lawyers said they're agreeing more often to allow homeowners to sell their homes for less than they owe or pay back loans with terms they can afford.

As part of a nationwide "robo-signing" settlement, five of the biggest banks are also on the hook to avoid foreclosures using more than $8 billion in short sales, principal reductions and loan modifications in Florida alone.

But banks wait for short sales to close and trial modifications to succeed before they drop the foreclosures entirely, leaving many cases to grow old in court.

Slowed foreclosures also benefit the banks, lawyers add, because they appear more solvent than if all bad loans were foreclosed at once. As Georgetown law professor Adam Levitin wrote in November, "The game plan has always been to run the clock."

• • •

It's not just bank strategy that's slowing cases to a crawl. After years of lenders chopping up and reselling mortgages, questions abound over who owns the loans. Cases dawdle through homeowner bankruptcies and defense stall tactics. And slipshod paperwork, skipped hearings, switched attorneys and stalled negotiations from both sides slow cases even further.

Courts were largely caught off guard by recent years' tsunami of bad loans. Florida has seen 1.5 million foreclosures in the six years since the housing bust, state data show, and courts expect another 680,000 foreclosures within a few years.

Most courts, a state workgroup of judges said, lack systems to track case details as basic as how many times a foreclosure was delayed, making it tough to pinpoint problems. And the Florida Supreme Court said last month that lower-level officers with less experience than judges, called magistrates, should jump in to rule on cases.

But even when foreclosures are on the schedule, judges often opt to dismiss them due to a banks' "failure to prosecute." Judges dismissed 45 percent of the state's foreclosures last year, court data show, often because they thought banks were too slow to act. Banks often refile those cases, judges said, resetting the clock.

To ease the gridlock, some Florida judges have opted to set trials without either side's request. But lawyers said that can end up disrupting negotiations and delivering results neither the bank nor homeowner wants. Weidner called it "justice served at fast-food-restaurant speed."

And closing a foreclosure case doesn't always mean its over. Often, banks must reopen cases to cancel or reschedule the dates of a home's sale, as owners secure short sales or loan modifications that would save their homes from repossession. About 10,000 closed cases were reopened in Tampa Bay last year.

Judges said seeking to speed up even the slowest cases can lead to concerns over allowing for a proper defense. In Hillsborough courts, cases from 2009 or older are isolated and given extra attention from court staff, but judges said there's only so much they can do to whisk cases along.

"Lenders and borrowers," judges wrote in their backlog reduction plan, "must be ready, willing, and able to proceed."

• • •

Slowed foreclosures have given homeowners time to negotiate with banks, try out modified loans and, in some cases, get hired or pay off debt. Many homes have also risen in value, buoying some underwater homeowners.

But many cases remain problematic, including for the home- owners who don't know the bank's next move.

"If the lender isn't moving the case forward, what is (the home- owner's) responsibility?" lawyer Chae duPont said. "They're not allowed to make mortgage payments. They don't want to abandon it and let vandals take over, because they're still liable."

Still, she added, "It's not an enviable position to be in. It's scary. They don't know how long it's going to last, they're in limbo, their credit scores are depressed. And on top of all that, it's embarrassing."

Real estate agents said speeding all foreclosures to repossession would bring problems of its own. Selling swaths of distressed homes all at once could lead prices to plummet, enticing investors and bargain hunters but hurting neighborhood home values. Worries over a "shadow inventory" of foreclosures thudding onto the market have subsided largely because banks' case slowdown helped keep prices from plunging.

Courts have suggested speeding up foreclosures by punishing problem lawyers, fast-tracking uncontested cases and grouping foreclosures by attorney to allow for block trials. And the state's "faster foreclosures" bill, approved by the Senate during the legislative session's final hours, landed on Gov. Rick Scott's desk Tuesday, leaving him 15 days to sign, veto or become law without his support.

But some judges argue that legislated pushes to hurry along foreclosures can do more harm than good if the rules are too rigid. Hasty demands to close cases can undermine the ability for all sides in a case to reach agreeable results.

"Speeding it up is not better for everybody," said Herbert Baumann Jr., an administrative judge for Hillsborough's Thirteenth Judicial Circuit. "Court cases don't lend themselves to bright-line rules. There are goals, yes, and we're aware of the goals, but … if it takes long, it takes long. If it takes short, it takes short. It takes what it takes."

Contact Drew Harwell at (727) 893-8252 or

Judges blame banks for foreclosure slowdowns, but some see good in delay 06/01/13 [Last modified: Friday, May 31, 2013 5:23pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa International Airport morphing into a mini-city unto itself


    TAMPA — By the end of the 2026, Joe Lopano wants Tampa International Airport to function as its own little city.

    Artist rendering of phase two of the $1 billion construction expansion of Tampa International Airport. The airport is transforming 17 acres of airport property that will include at least one hotel, retail and office space and a gas station, among other things.
[Courtesy of Tampa International Airport]
  2. Lost Highway: As FHP struggles to recruit, speeding tickets plummet

    State Roundup

    TALLAHASSEE — The number of speeding tickets written by Florida state troopers has plunged three straight years as the agency grapples with a personnel shortage and high turnover.

    State data shows FHP troopers are not writing violations for speeding or other infractions like they did back in 2011, even though there's 1 million more licensed drivers in Florida.
  3. Kidpreneurs — and adults — capitalize on gooey, squishy Slime craze


    Aletheia Venator and Berlyn Perdomo demonstrate the stretchiness of their slime. - Berlyn Perdomo and her friend, Aletheia Venator, both 13, make and sell slime which can be seen on their instagram site @the.real.slimeshadyy [JIM DAMASKE   |   Times]
  4. The last farmer of Florida's prized Zellwood corn is thinking of packing it in


    MOUNT DORA — Hank Scott steps out of his pickup between the long rows and snaps off an ear that grows about bellybutton-high on the forehead-high stalks.

    Hank Scott, co-owner of Long and Scott Farms, shucks an ear of corn on the farm in Mount Dora, Fla., on Wednesday, May 10, 2017. The farm specializes in Scott's Zellwood Triple-Sweet Gourmet Corn. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times
  5. Law firm's Russia ties prove nothing about Trump


    The statement

    "Law firm @POTUS used to show he has no ties to Russia was named Russia Law Firm of the Year for their extensive ties to Russia. Unreal."

    Sen. Chris Murphy, D-Conn., stands during a media availability on Capitol Hill, Monday, June 20, 2016 in Washington. A divided Senate blocked rival election-year plans to curb guns on Monday, eight days after the horror of Orlando's mass shooting intensified pressure on lawmakers to act but knotted them in gridlock anyway — even over restricting firearms for terrorists. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)