Make us your home page

Medical debts may depress credit scores of mortgage applicants

Medical debts may torpedo credit scores

WASHINGTON — Are medical bill collection accounts buried away inside millions of consumers credit files — even bills that were fully paid or settled years ago — functioning as a drag on the housing market?

That might sound far-fetched, yet some credit and mortgage industry experts say negative medical collection records are playing a little-recognized but significant role in depressing otherwise creditworthy loan applicants' scores. Lower scores, in turn, are disqualifying borrowers from getting mortgages or forcing them to pay higher interest rates, fees and down payments.

According to a 2008 study by the nonprofit Commonwealth Fund, an estimated 28 million Americans were contacted by collection agencies on medical debt issues during a two-year period, and 72 million reported difficulties in paying outstanding medical bills.

Now a bipartisan group in Congress is sponsoring legislation that would limit the credit score impacts of paid-off and settled collection accounts that sometimes are the product of disputes and botched record-keeping by insurance companies, hospitals and doctors.

Titled the Medical Debt Responsibility Act, the bill would require the three national credit bureaus — Equifax, Experian and Trans- Union — to expunge medical collection records of $2,500 or less from files within 45 days of their being paid or settled. Currently, paid-off collections can remain in files for as long as seven years. The bill is co-sponsored by Reps. Heath Shuler, D-N.C., Don Manzullo, R-Ill., and Ralph Hall, R-Texas.

Craig Watts, director of public affairs for Fair Isaac, developer of the FICO score that is widely used by lenders, confirmed that "the mere presence of a collection account on the credit report" has an impact on a person's score. Critics note, however, that medical bills are different from other types of credit accounts since often the consumer is impacted by uncontrollable events such as illness or accidents.

Terry Clemans, executive vice president of the National Credit Reporting Association, whose members prepare a large percentage of the reports used by mortgage lenders, says the negative effects of collection accounts on a borrower's scores vary, but in extreme cases can be "in the high double digits or even more than a hundred" points.

"We see this all the time," Clemans said. "It's a serious problem" because many of these collections stem from run-of-the-mill disagreements over co-pay amounts with insurers or billing issues with doctors that ultimately were paid in full or settled. But because hospitals and doctors tend to quickly hand over unpaid or disputed bills to collection agencies, who then report their actions to the national credit bureaus, what should have been a routine matter turns into a long-term scar on a consumer's credit file.

Rodney Anderson, executive director of Supreme Lending, a national mortgage banking and brokerage firm in Dallas, says he and his staff regularly encounter borrowers who are unaware of medical collection accounts on their credit files that depress their FICO scores and increase total loan costs by thousands of dollars. In one case, a borrower had a $150 unpaid medical collection item that cost him $1,500 extra on upfront points on a Fannie Mae conventional mortgage. Anderson's firm conducted a survey covering 1,700 mortgage applicants and found 776 "had at least one medical collection" depressing their scores.

The idea of Congress intervening and requiring deletion of medical bill records from national credit files does not sit well with everyone, however. Though the credit bureaus had no immediate comment on the legislation, their trade group, the Consumer Data Industry Association, opposed a similar bill that passed the House 336-82 in September. The association said it is still studying the current bill.

Don't be surprised if the House passes it. But if the big banks weigh in against it, look for it to have a much tougher time getting through the Senate.

Kenneth R. Harney can be reached at

Medical debts may depress credit scores of mortgage applicants 06/18/11 [Last modified: Friday, June 17, 2011 4:50pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Special to the Times.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Another Pinellas foreclosure auction fools bidders, raises questions

    Real Estate

    For the second time in six weeks, a company connected to lawyer Roy C. Skelton stood poised to profit from a Pinellas County foreclosure auction that confused even experienced real estate investors.

    A Palm Harbor company bid  $112,300 for  this Largo townhome at a foreclosure auction July 21 not realizing the auction involved a second mortgage, connected to lawyer and  real estate investor Roy Skelton -- and that the bank could still foreclose on the  first mortgage.
  2. Clearwater-based USAmeriBank acquired by New Jersey bank in $816 million deal


    CLEARWATER — USAmeriBancorp, Inc., based in Clearwater, is being acquired by New Jersey's Valley National Bancorp in an $816 million deal, it was announced today.

    Joe Chillura, CEO of USAmeribank, shown inside a branch in Ybor City in this file photo.
  3. Outback Steakhouse sees growth in U.S. and Brazil markets in second quarter


    TAMPA — Restaurant sales were up at Outback Steakhouse and Carrabba's Italian Grill during the second quarter of 2017, but Bonefish Grill continues to lag at Tampa-based Bloomin' Brands.

    The Outback Steakhouse, on 4088 Park St. N, is showin on July 26, 2017. Restaurant sales were up at Outback Steakhouse  and Carrabba's Italian Grill during the second quarter of 2017, but Bonefish Grill continues to lag at Tampa-based Bloomin' Brands. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]
  4. Controversial landfill site could be rechristened as industrial recruiting land in Pasco

    Economic Development

    The east Pasco property of Angelo's Aggregate Materials, which failed to obtain a state environmental permit to be developed as a garbage landfill, is being studied as a potential 1,000-acre mega site for industrial recruitment.

  5. Marriott opening new hotel on Clearwater Beach


    CLEARWATER BEACH — A dual-branded Marriott hotel with a tongue-twister name is opening on Clearwater Beach in August. The Residence Inn Tampa Clearwater Beach and SpringHill Suites Tampa Clearwater Beach will have 255 suites total, connected by a lobby.

    A dual-branded Marriott hotel called the Residence Inn Tampa Clearwater Beach and SpringHill Suites Tampa Clearwater Beach will open in August in Clearwater Beach. Pictured is a rendering.
[Courtesy of Hayworth PR]