Wednesday, May 23, 2018
Business

New flood insurance rules have consequences for Florida's economy

By any reasonable measure, paradise is worth the wait.

So when Colin and Joyce Elston discovered the Pinellas beaches while on vacation from Connecticut in the 1970s, they agreed they would bide their time.

There were three children to raise. And a job opportunity for an industrial scientist of Colin's expertise in Washington. Even a seven-year stopover in the mountains of Mexico where land was cheap and money could be saved.

Yet the Elstons never forgot about the place where the sun was bright and the water stretched beyond the horizon.

So in June, nearly 40 years after they first vacationed in Tampa Bay, the retirees bought a house in Treasure Island and settled in for what they assumed was forever.

Three months later, paradise was interrupted.

The Elstons had never heard of the Biggert-Waters Act passed by Congress in 2012. They had no idea it revamped the National Flood Insurance Program and was about to cause premiums to skyrocket in high-risk areas.

Two weeks ago they discovered the flood insurance they purchased for $1,750 will likely increase 500 to 600 percent in the blink of an eye.

They are waiting for a survey to determine their home's elevation level, but have been told to expect their premium to cost between $10,000 and $12,000.

"Coming here had always been our dream, and everything seemed to work out perfectly for this house,'' Colin said. "It was going to be a stretch for us, but we … knew this could work.

"Now, we don't know what we're going to do. The best we can hope for is bad news. If it turns out to be the worst, it will be impossible for us to live with.''

• • •

The aim behind the Biggert-Waters Act is laudable.

The execution is most certainly not.

Seeking ways to help the Federal Emergency Management Agency climb out from under an enormous deficit built up from storms like Hurricane Katrina, both houses of Congress agreed the federal government would no longer subsidize flood insurance. In other words, homes in high-risk areas would pay the full freight on their premiums.

In theory, this might make sense. In reality, this problem requires a far more nuanced approach.

Come Oct. 1, any business in a high-risk area will immediately lose its flood insurance subsidy. Any home sold after Oct. 1 will also lose its subsidy. And — to the horror of the Elstons — any home sold after Biggert-Waters passed last summer will lose its subsidy.

For everyone else in high-risk areas, it's more like a slow water torture. Their premiums will increase 20 percent every year until their policies are no longer subsidized.

Admittedly, there is a certain appeal to someone paying the true cost of their home's risk, as opposed to being bailed out by other taxpayers.

But that simplistic approach ignores some important truths.

No. 1, Congress has essentially changed the rules in the middle of a game. You can't provide subsidized insurance for decades, then pull the rug out from under people in a matter of months. That's sort of like telling a politician that campaign donations are simply bribes by another name, and so they will have to fund their own election bids starting in 2014. Not too realistic, huh?

No. 2, even if you are devoid of empathy, the ramifications of this law will impact Florida and other coastal states far beyond insurance premiums. The real estate market will take an enormous hit if high-risk homes become unsellable due to insurance rates. Property values will begin to drop, which will affect tax revenues.

It's easy to say that rich people on the beach should have seen this day coming, but what about families in modest inland homes that are in high flood zones? What about homes that have just been redrawn into flood zones by FEMA?

"There's a much bigger picture here,'' said Anita Ford, a St. Petersburg insurance agent. "It's not just, 'Gee you have a nice waterfront house, why don't you step up to the plate and pay what you owe?'

"We were told St. Pete has more parcels in high-risk zones than the top two beach communities combined. It's ludicrous to think this is just impacting a few rich people.''

• • •

So is there a solution?

Maybe not a perfect one, but there has to be something better than Biggert-Waters.

Getting rid of the retroactive home sales clause would be a start. And increasing the maximum deductible for high-risk homes so flood insurance essentially becomes catastrophic insurance is another idea.

Lawmakers in Louisiana have been screaming about the law for months now, and there is talk of delaying its implementation as well as introducing new legislation. Unfortunately, most politicians in Florida have been shamefully low-key on the topic.

The bottom line is real estate agents are worried. Local officials are worried. Homeowners are downright frightened.

It would be nice if our congressional representatives had the guts to stand up and defend homeowners, or else look them in the eye and explain why they don't see this as a problem.

Comments
Birchwood owner will open a three-story restaurant and bar at St. Petersburg pier

Birchwood owner will open a three-story restaurant and bar at St. Petersburg pier

ST. PETERSBURG — Chuck Prather, owner of the Birchwood in St. Petersburg, returned from his daughter’s Maine wedding this week with an exciting announcement of his own. On June 7 the St. Petersburg City Council is expected to sign off on him being on...
Updated: 9 hours ago
St. Petersburg’s Jabil expands in Israel with new innovation center

St. Petersburg’s Jabil expands in Israel with new innovation center

St. Petersburg-based contract electronics company Jabil announced Wednesday it has expanded in Israel by opening an Optics Technology Innovation Center.The 6,560-square-foot complex is in Haifa, Israel’s third-largest city. "Our Optics Innovation Cen...
Updated: 11 hours ago
New restaurants on the horizon: Metro Diner and Zoes Kitchen in Tampa, Trophy Fish and Oak & Stone in St. Pete

New restaurants on the horizon: Metro Diner and Zoes Kitchen in Tampa, Trophy Fish and Oak & Stone in St. Pete

OPEN NOW: BAHAMA BUCK’SFeel a shiver? Just in time for Florida’s sultry summer, Bahama Buck’s opened this week in Trinity with an avalanche of sno. The 2,346-square-foot island-inspired shop opened at 8815 Mitchell Blvd. with more than 91 flavors of ...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Lee Roy Selmon's original Tampa restaurant is closing, marking the end of an era

Lee Roy Selmon's original Tampa restaurant is closing, marking the end of an era

Lee Roy Selmon’s, the restaurant that paid homage to the community icon who rose to fame as a Tampa Bay Buccaneer and grew to become a popular civic leader, will shutter the doors of its original location on Tampa’s Boy Scout Boulevard in...
Updated: 12 hours ago
At Bay 3, developers of Tampa’s Armature Works transform old industrial space into new co-work offices

At Bay 3, developers of Tampa’s Armature Works transform old industrial space into new co-work offices

TAMPA — The name of the new Bay 3 co-working space at the Armature Works goes back to World War I, when the red-brick warehouse overlooking the Hillsborough River was the maintenance barn for Tampa Electric’s streetcar system.As the name suggests, it...
Published: 05/23/18
Comcast may outbid Disney for Twenty-First Century Fox

Comcast may outbid Disney for Twenty-First Century Fox

Associated PressPHILADELPHIA — Comcast may make an offer for Twenty-First Century Fox, potentially putting it in a head-to-head bidding war with Disney. Comcast Corp. on Wednesday did not provide specific details on a bid, other than to say that it w...
Published: 05/23/18
Brunch-based alcohol will be available at First Watch’s new Orlando location

Brunch-based alcohol will be available at First Watch’s new Orlando location

ORLANDO — The popular breakfast and brunch chain First Watch will be opening a new restaurant in Orlando that will add cocktails, beer and wine to the menu. The new concept restaurant, set to open on Memorial Day at 1448 N Alafaya Trail, will be 1,00...
Published: 05/23/18
Humana hiring 100 for phone sales, Medicare enrollment assistance

Humana hiring 100 for phone sales, Medicare enrollment assistance

Kentucky-based health care provider Humana is hiring 100 phone sales employees in Tampa Bay. The new hires will field sales calls and offer enrollment assistance for Humana’s Medicare plans and other products.The positions, which are being added to h...
Published: 05/22/18
Updated: 05/23/18
Downtown St. Pete Ford’s Garage and Yeoman’s to open Wednesday

Downtown St. Pete Ford’s Garage and Yeoman’s to open Wednesday

ST. PETERSBURG — Ford’s Garage, a car junkie’s haven, has proven to be popular eatery across the state.Now it has a chance to drive customers to its seats in St. Petersburg. The restaurant opens its ninth location downtown Wednesday at 200 First Ave....
Published: 05/23/18
Target: New Tampa, Clearwater stores part of company-wide makeovers

Target: New Tampa, Clearwater stores part of company-wide makeovers

Target is renovating more than 1,000 stores by the end of 2020, including two SuperTarget locations in New Tampa and Clearwater.The Clearwater store’s makeover — which the corporation calls ‘‘reimagining" — just wrapped up, according to Target spoke...
Published: 05/23/18