Make us your home page

Rates are down, but refinancing not best for all

With mortgage interest rates dipping as low as 4.75 percent on Wednesday, Tampa Bay area homeowners should be clamoring to refinance with some of the cheapest home loans in generations.

Or should they?

Thanks to a 30 percent drop in home values since 2006, local bankers and mortgage brokers are preaching the virtues of home refinancing to a smaller choir of homeowners than they were just two years ago.

Borrowers with stellar credit and hefty home equity should find savings galore, but for the tens of thousands of homeowners who bought in the boom market of 2004-2007, refinancing could prove costly and pointless.

"I'd probably tell more people in this market not to refinance,'' said Kerri McDougald, broker-owner with Brandon's All Mortgage Group. "Most people right now are upside-down on their mortgages or the cost of refinancing is not effective for them."

To be sure, if you've owned your house at least five years, accumulated equity and won't move in the next year or two, you can save thousands of dollars a year.

On Tuesday, the Federal Reserve cut the rate it charges banks to between zero and a quarter percentage point, the greatest loosening of credit since the Great Depression.

Trimming your mortgage from 7 percent to 5 percent on a $200,000 loan would save you about $3,000 a year. Even accounting for fees and commissions associated with refinancing, you'd come out ahead in a year or two.

"For people in a decent equity position who have paid on time the rates are extraordinary,'' said Rim Karnavicious, mortgage specialist at First State Bank in St. Petersburg. "All the people who refinanced in the 6 to 7 percent range the last few years, should really look at refinancing again."

But the plunge in housing values has priced thousands out of the refinancing market, regardless of their credit score. Nearly half of Tampa Bay area homeowners who bought in the last five years owe more on their mortgages than their homes are worth, according to the real estate valuation company

It's even worse for people who bought in the peak price year of 2006. About 70 percent of them have negative equity in their homes. If they wanted to refinance, many of those homeowners would have to bring tens of thousands of dollars in cash to the closing table to compensate for the real estate depreciation. Without at least 20 percent in equity, bankers often require private mortgage insurance, which could add at least another $100 to the monthly payment.

"The house has to qualify as much as the borrower," said Don Ward, compliance manager at Clearwater's All State Mortgage and Loan Corp.

Even homeowners with solid equity but small loan balances might find it worth their while to skip refinancing. It could take years to work off the closing costs for such a small loan.

"I can drop some people two points on some loans, and it will save them only 30 bucks a month," said Rick Kelly, owner of Bay to Bay Lending in Tampa's Hyde Park.

To combat the recession, the Fed promised this week to keep rates "exceptionally" low for a while.

Whether that will be enough to help most Tampa area homeowners remains to be seen. Mortgage brokers said phone volume swells whenever banks cut rates. But as often as not, they have to turn down those potential borrowers. They simply don't qualify in an era when customers can no longer fudge incomes on loan applications.

"This rate cut is not going to address the biggest thing, which is lack of equity,'' McDougald said. "'Everybody's afraid to spend right now. They don't even know if they're going to have a job next month.''

When does it make sense to refinance?

Depends on how much you owe on your house, what rate you're paying and how long you plan to stay at that address. Here's three case studies of homeowners we'll assume have good credit and qualify for today's 5 percent rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage:

CASE STUDY A: You bought a house at the peak of the market in 2006 for $300,000 and still owe $270,000 at 6.5 percent interest. Answer: Doesn't make sense. A 5 percent loan would save you $3,084 a year. But a home worth $300,000 in 2006 is worth on average only $220,000 today. You'd have to cover out of pocket the $50,000 difference between your old loan amount and today's home value.

CASE STUDY B: You bought a house in early 1999 and owe $70,000 at 7.5 percent interest. You plan to move in one to three years. Answer: Might make sense. Your house has risen in value since 1999, and a 5 percent loan would save you $1,364 per year. But beware of closing costs. Fees and commissions on the refinance can easily cost $3,000. If you're moving in a year, you won't recoup the money. But if you won't move for three years, you'll probably save money.

CASE STUDY C: You bought a house for $200,000 in 2003. You still owe $195,000 on an adjustable rate mortgage that's resetting to 8 percent. Answer: Makes sense. The new 5 percent rate would save you $384 per month, or $4,600 per year. Even accounting for closing costs, you'll have saved more than $20,000 in five years. Since home values are still up modestly since 2003, chances are you won't need to bring any cash to the table.

Rates are down, but refinancing not best for all 12/17/08 [Last modified: Thursday, December 18, 2008 2:40pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Road to Nowhere' is back: Next phase of Suncoast Parkway coming


    Despite intense public opposition and dubious traffic projections, the Florida Department of Transportation has announced that construction of the toll road known as "Suncoast 2" is expected to start in early 2018.

    The Suncoast Parkway ends at U.S. 98 just south of Citrus County. For years residents have opposed extending the toll road, a project dubbed the "Suncoast 2" into Citrus County. But state officials recently announced that the Suncoast 2 should start construction in early 2018. [Stephen J. Coddington  |  TIMES]
  2. A sports rout on Wall Street


    NEW YORK — Sporting goods retailers can't shake their losing streak.

  3. Grocery chain Aldi hosting hiring event in Brandon Aug. 24


    BRANDON — German grocery chain Aldi is holding a hiring event for its Brandon store Aug. 24. It is looking to fill store associate, shift manager and manager trainee positions.

  4. Lightning owner Jeff Vinik backs film company pursuing global blockbusters


    TAMPA — Jeff Vinik's latest investment might be coming to a theater near you.

    Jeff Vinik, Tampa Bay Lightning owner, invested in a new movie company looking to appeal to a global audience. | [Times file photo]
  5. Trigaux: Look to new Inc. 5000 rankings for Tampa Bay's future heavyweights


    There's a whole lotta fast-growing private companies here in Tampa Bay. Odds are good you have not heard of most of them.


    Kyle Taylor, CEO and founder of The Penny Hoarder, fills a glass for his employees this past Wednesday as the young St. Petersburg personal advice business celebrates its landing at No. 25 on the 2017 Inc. 5000 list of the fastest growing private companies in the country. Taylor, still in his 20s, wins kudos from executive editor Alexis Grant for keeping the firm's culture innovative. The business ranked No. 32 last year. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]