Make us your home page
Instagram

Suit targets 44-year-old couple who own an age-restricted condo

The board of directors of the Royal Stewart Arms condo association say that rules forbid Natalie and William Trudelle from entering their condo without an approved of-age resident over 55. The Tampa couple has owned the condo for 15 years.

JIM DAMASKE | Times

The board of directors of the Royal Stewart Arms condo association say that rules forbid Natalie and William Trudelle from entering their condo without an approved of-age resident over 55. The Tampa couple has owned the condo for 15 years.

DUNEDIN — In a lawsuit that has stretched over two years, two courts and three judges, the condo association of a 55-and-over complex is trying to get rid of a Tampa couple, both of whom are 44.

The rules are clear, says the board of directors of the Royal Stewart Arms condo association. The age restriction is on the application. Section 14.8 of the Declaration of Condominium Ownership states their complex is an "adult community." No 44-year-olds, like Natalie and William Trudelle, allowed.

The lawsuit demands the Trudelles not enter the condo without an approved of-age resident over 55 and pay the association's legal fees. They wouldn't be forced to sell the condo as long as they continued to pay the association dues and insurance.

If the over-55 rule is not enforced, wrote attorney Joe Cianfrone in a 2007 court complaint, the complex would "sustain irreparable damage."

The Trudelles, who work in real estate, say the suit is a sham. Natalie Trudelle said she bought the condo 15 years ago for her mother and grandmother, both of whom died within two years and left her the unit.

The Trudelles lived there for less than a year, and in the decade since, they have rented to seasonal tenants older than 55. Other underage people have lived in the complex, they said, and it was never an issue. Then came the lawsuit.

"A third (of our neighbors) say it's ludicrous, a third don't give a rat's patootie and a third are on the board's side and say the rules must be followed," William Trudelle said. "Everyone out there says Honeymoon Island is paradise. We say they're trying to evict us from paradise."

The Fair Housing Act, passed in 1968 and amended two decades later, allows communities intended for those over 55 to discriminate against young potential renters and families with children. At least 80 percent of units must be occupied, it states, by a person older than 55.

So why can't their unit be in the other 20 percent, the Trudelles ask? They pay their taxes, their insurance, their $441 a month in association dues. Besides, they say, they're only ever there to decorate for potential renters.

The condo association won't budge.

"It is of no consequence that she claims to be there only to decorate," Cianfrone wrote in a 2007 letter to the association's board. "Any reason Ms. Trudelle provides for residing in the unit is irrelevant."

In the same letter, Cianfrone wrote the association could grant the Trudelles a "hardship exemption," allowing leniency because of Natalie Trudelle's former family connection. Department of Housing and Urban Development documents say the flexible protection is allowed but not required.

The board argues Trudelle never inherited the unit — it was hers all along. The sale application from 1994 shows Natalie as the applicant, with her mother and grandmother listed as additional occupants.

The Trudelles say they feel singled out by the association. They've compiled affidavits from former residents who would have been under 55. That includes board president John Hutchinson, who, they point to in records, was the sole owner of a unit there while underage.

Hutchinson disagrees, saying his unit was grandfathered in after the complex became age-restricted in 1988. He, like other board members, would not comment on the litigation. Four messages left for Cianfrone this week went unanswered.

Hutchinson did say any story on the 2-year-old legal complaint would be "premature," adding that "these kinds of cases happen all the time."

The case, moved from county to circuit court last month because county courts do not have jurisdiction over title disputes, continues, even as the Trudelles say they've given the board "every opportunity to drop the lawsuit."

They said they're sure they'll win. The board seems to disagree. The courts chug on.

"I would hope that you would try to get this matter mediated, or resolved somehow, instead of tilting (at) windmills like this," said Circuit Court Judge Radford Smith, according to a court transcript. "I mean, it just goes on and on and on."

Times researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report. Drew Harwell can be reached at dharwell@sptimes.com or (727) 445-4170.

Suit targets 44-year-old couple who own an age-restricted condo 08/28/09 [Last modified: Friday, August 28, 2009 8:33pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Dragon ride in Harry Potter section of Universal closing for new themed ride

    Florida

    Universal Orlando announced Monday that it will close Dragon Challenge for a new "highly themed" Harry Potter ride to open in 2019 — sending wizard fans into a guessing game with hopes for a Floo Powder Network or the maze from the Triwizard Tournament.

    Universal Orlando announced Monday that it will close Dragon Challenge on Sept. 5 for a new "highly themed" Harry Potter ride to open in 2019. The ride, originally the Dueling Dragons roller coaster, was renamed and incorporated into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter when the hugely popular area opened in 2010.
  2. Would you let your company implant a chip in you?

    Working Life

    Would you ask an employee to get a chip implanted in her hand? Sounds invasive and intrusive. But come Aug. 1, one company in Wisconsin will be giving it a try.

    Three Square Market - a developer of software used in vending machines - is offering all of its employees the option to get a microchip implanted between the thumb and forefinger. [Photo from video]
  3. Daniel Lipton resigns as artistic director of Opera Tampa

    Stage

    TAMPA — Daniel Lipton has resigned as artistic director of Opera Tampa, the David A. Straz Jr. Center for the Performing Arts announced.

    Daniel Lipton became the artistic director and conductor of Opera Tampa in 2012. Lipton replaced the opera's only previous director, Anton Coppola, who retired. [Times file (2012)]
  4. Throwback Tampa Bay station 102.9 goes from R&B jams to WFLA-AM's conservative talk

    Blogs

    Talk radio station WFLA-AM (970) began simulcasting on 102.9 FM in the Tampa area this morning. 

    Tampa's 102.9 is going from Throwback Tampa Bay to WFLA-AM's news radio.
  5. Bank of Tampa expanding into Sarasota

    Banking

    TAMPA — The Bank of Tampa is expanding to Sarasota County. It opened a loan office this month in downtown Sarasota at 1858 Ringling Blvd., which will be converted to a full-service branch within the year, the company said in a release Monday.

    The Bank of Tampa is expanding to Sarasota. Charles Murphy, pictured, will lead the Sarasota branch. | [Courtesy of The Bank of Tampa]