Tuesday, June 19, 2018
Business

Target credit card breach breeds worry

TAMPA

Robert Spoden shops at Target a few times a month, usually spending $50 to $75 on food, clothes and sporting goods. But when Visa called last week to alert him about purchases totalling more than $2,700, he knew something was amiss.

"Initially, I was shocked that someone tried to do this with our credit card,'' he said. "But I wasn't surprised. It's a sign of the times and what's going on in our country.''

Spoden was aware of Target's data breach during the holiday shopping season. The retailer said cyber criminals stole data from 40 million credit and debit cards used between Nov. 27 and Dec. 15. The hackers also snatched personal information — including email addresses, phone numbers, names and home addresses — of another 70 million people.

On Monday, Chase Visa's fraud control department notified Spoden that his card had been used four times at a Target store in Tampa. Two of the transactions were for identical amounts: $640.93. The others were for $1,067.86 and $424. As a result, Visa was canceling his card and reissuing a new one.

As a courtesy to Target, he said, Spoden called the store along Gandy Boulevard, where he shops the most. Even though he knew he wasn't liable for the charges, he figured the store would want his information to help with the investigation.

They didn't. An employee instructed him to call Target's customer service line, sign up for a year of free credit monitoring and, most baffling to him, file a police report.

"Why should I be the one to call the police when they're incurring the loss?'' Spoden said. "What are the local police doing to do?''

• • •

Going after credit card fraud is a daunting task. Credit and debit card fraud losses worldwide reached more than $11 billion in 2012, up 15 percent over the previous year, according to the Nilson Report, a publication about the payment industry. Devoting resources to every case is impossible.

"We do investigations and are able to make arrests, but they are complicated cases and people should do what they can to protect themselves,'' said Tampa police spokesman Andrea Davis.

The Tampa Police Department has about three dozen detectives assigned to property-related crimes, a broad category that covers almost everything except murders and crimes involving sex, gangs and major drugs. Several other detectives work in the fraud unit but mostly investigate tax fraud and crimes against businesses.

In January, Tampa police received more than 100 reports of fraudulent credit card use — a small fraction of what actually occurs, Davis said.

Target has said it is working with law enforcement officials. On Wednesday, Attorney General Eric Holder said the Justice Department is committed to tracking down the thieves.

Spoden, 65, wonders what steps, if any, are being taken at the local level. Visa would not give him details, he said, but must know exactly where and when the illegal transactions took place. Did investigators look at surveillance video? Did they interview store employees?

Target isn't talking specifics about its investigation. A corporate spokeswoman said people suspecting suspicious activity should notify their credit card company.

The Minneapolis-based retailer hasn't said how many of its 110 million shoppers have been actual victims of the breach. So far among its REDcard Visa credit and debit card holders, Target has seen "low levels of incremental fraud'' beyond what normally occurs, said spokeswoman Molly Snyder.

Similarly, Visa, one of the major credit card companies picking up most of the tab for the heist, has not released an estimated amount. Spokeswoman Rosetta Jones said the company doesn't break out fraud data by retailer but, on average, fraud amounts to about 6 cents on every $100 transacted — 0.06 percent.

•••

While the banks that issued the credit cards will absorb the cost of fraudulent sales initially, Target is not off the hook. Once the banks can tally their losses, they are expected to file lawsuits against Target and issue fines to recoup some of the money, said Jake Kouns, chief information security officer for Risk Based Security.

"Some of the lawsuits, penalties and fines could get ugly,'' he said. "We know that this is going to cost the banks and Target a lot of money.''

Already, dozens of lawsuits nationwide have been filed against Target by private individuals, including one from a Target shopper in Tampa alleging the retailer failed to protect her personal and private financial information.

Target has $100 million of cyber insurance and $65 million of directors and officers liability coverage, according to press reports. While seemingly a lot of money, Target could go through it quickly, Kouns said. Illegal cards made from the stolen information will likely continue coming into the market for the next few years. Many of the stolen card numbers don't expire until 2016.

Risk Based Security, a Richmond, Va.-based company that tracks data breaches, counted 2,164 breaches in 2013 that exposed more than 822 million records. That's the most since the company started recording breaches in 2005, when the number of incidents was 158.

And the future doesn't look much better. Since the Target breach, Neiman Marcus and Michaels have announced similar incidents.

"It's not slowing down,'' Kouns said. "What we're doing right now is not working. Attackers are moving faster and are better equipped than the defenders.''

•••

In the end, the cost of security breaches will be passed on to consumers in the form of increased prices and credit cards fees, said Sajeev Varki, an associate marketing professor at the University of South Florida. Everyone will pay a few cents more as the cost of doing business on plastic.

But will Target's breach persuade shoppers to go elsewhere? Probably not, he said.

"If they think someone is targeting Target then consumers will be more likely to switch,'' Varki said. "But if they feel like it was a random attack, they will stay with the store and figure it will be someone else's turn.''

Spoden isn't blaming Target for his card getting hacked but has lost confidence in the retailer and fears similar breaches will just get more common.

He believes the most effective way to reduce checkout fraud would be to require shoppers to show identification when using a credit or debit card, a policy already in effect for some retailers. It could slow down the lines and offend some customers, but it might have stopped criminals from using his card.

In the meantime, he's no longer shopping at Target.

"We love Target but we're in a holding pattern," he said. "We're waiting for something to come back from Target that says, 'We've got this thing covered and you can have faith shopping in our stores.' ''

Susan Thurston can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 225-3110. Follow @susan_thurston on Twitter.

Comments
Tech Data sending a record 700 employees to march in Pride Parade

Tech Data sending a record 700 employees to march in Pride Parade

Among the marching bands and twirlers at Saturday’s St. Pete Pride Parade, one major sponsor, Tech Data, is sending by far a record number of employees — more than 700 at last count — to march in Florida’s largest gay pride parade.The parade, which d...
Updated: 16 minutes ago
St. Petersburg residents will see higher water, sanitation bills

St. Petersburg residents will see higher water, sanitation bills

ST. PETERSBURG — Residents can expect their water and sanitation bills to increase between $7 and $11 starting in October.That represents an average of a 7-percent increase. Customers who use an average of 4,000 gallons a month, including reclaimed w...
Published: 06/19/18
Spectrum’s new service will eventually increase the cost for TV

Spectrum’s new service will eventually increase the cost for TV

Spectrum’s new all-digital service is set to bring more high definition, faster internet speeds and expanded on-demand offerings — but it also comes with higher costs for some of its TV customers in Tampa Bay. Each TV that receives service from Spect...
Published: 06/19/18
Pasco Business Digest for June 22

Pasco Business Digest for June 22

Business digestBrieflyHOSPITALS RECEIVE AWARD: Regional Medical Center Bayonet Point and Medical Center of Trinity were recipients of Healthgrades 2018 Patient Safety Excellence Award, a designation that recognizes superior performance of hospitals t...
Updated: 3 hours ago

Hernando Business Digest for June 22

Business digestBrieflyHOSPITAL RECEIVES AWARD: Oak Hill Hospital in Spring Hill was the recipient of Healthgrades 2018 Patient Safety Excellence Award, a designation that recognizes superior performance of hospitals that have prevented the occurrence...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Private Florida firm buys Rent-A-Center in $1 billion deal

Private Florida firm buys Rent-A-Center in $1 billion deal

An Orlando private equity firm has purchased lease-to-own business Rent-A-Center in a deal valued at more than $1 billion.Vintage Capital Management put a bid in for the company on Friday: $15 per share, $1 per share above its previous offer. Rent-A-...
Published: 06/18/18
Report: 40 percent of Florida property will be ‘highly exposed’ to flooding

Report: 40 percent of Florida property will be ‘highly exposed’ to flooding

One of Florida’s biggest draws is also one if its biggest liabilities — its coastline. A new report projects that Florida is at the greatest risk of any state for tidal flooding caused by rising sea levels. And Tampa Bay faces some of the greatest ri...
Published: 06/18/18
Mazzaro’s gets ready to reopen

Mazzaro’s gets ready to reopen

day after an electrical fire broke out in its dry goods warehouse Friday night.Dominic Horwath, a grocery manager at Mazzaro’s on 22nd Ave. N, said staffers spent Monday and the weekend moving things into other warehouses.The damage from the fire at ...
Published: 06/18/18
Mazzaro’s market set to reopen Tuesday after blaze damaged one of its warehouses

Mazzaro’s market set to reopen Tuesday after blaze damaged one of its warehouses

ST. PETERSBURG — Mazzaro’s Italian Market is scheduled to reopen Tuesday after an electrical fire broke out its dry goods warehouse Friday night.Dominic Horwath, a grocery manager at Mazzaro’s on 22nd Avenue N said staff spent Monday and the weekend...
Published: 06/18/18
Developer Grady Pridgen buys St. Pete’s shuttered Edward White Hospital

Developer Grady Pridgen buys St. Pete’s shuttered Edward White Hospital

ST. PETERSBURG — Edward White Hospital, closed four years ago because of declining revenues, has been sold to developer Grady Pridgen for $2.7 million.Pridgen could not be reached Monday for comment. City officials said he has submitted plans for rem...
Published: 06/18/18