Make us your home page

Saving money is harder now than when your parents did it

New York Times

Savers just can't catch a break. • Because of persistent low interest rates, anyone looking for decent returns that are also safe has had a tough time this year. Most of the best savings accounts, for instance, don't even top a 1.5 percent annual yield. • Sure, some people have made out nicely in this environment. If you have a hefty mortgage, are able to make your payments and have enough equity, you can refinance into a 30-year loan with an interest rate that begins with the number four. • That still seems like a miracle. But many of the people who qualify for refinancing are already comfortable and the low rates are just a bonus.

It's older people with not much of a mortgage left who are really getting hurt here. The low interest rates keep payouts for newly purchased annuities low, for instance. Insurance companies have been citing the low rates when trying to raise prices on long-term care policies.

And if you're living on a fixed income, you may be spooked by the stock market collapse a couple of years ago and have little appetite left for risk and no slack for further declines.

That's understandable, but the earnings on your savings may not be keeping up with real-life inflation, the kind that includes rapidly increasing health care and other expenses that older people bear the most. And even if you aren't paying higher prices, it's still disappointing to earn so little on money you want to be there when you need it.

If this sounds like you and you're increasingly frustrated, all of this poses a basic question: Isn't there some institution, somewhere, that can pay just a little bit more? What is stopping that from happening?

Here are some things getting in the way.

LOWER PROFITS: Here's the way things are supposed to work and normally do: Banks take in deposits and then lend that money out.

And here's what's happening more frequently now: People are doing a better job of spending less than they earn, but any leftover money is going toward paying down debt, not taking on new debt.

So to the extent that banks have deposits, they can't lend them out in the quantity they used to. Instead, they buy Treasury bills, according to Bill Hampel, the chief economist for the Credit Union National Association. And those don't pay as they once did because of the interest rate environment.

The resulting lower profits make it harder to raise the rates that savers earn.

THE REALITY OF THE FED: If money is so cheap, why can't financial institutions give us a bit more? After all, banks can just get money from the Federal Reserve and pay close to nothing for the privilege.

Well, at least in theory they can, but only so much and only for so long.

"You don't really want to borrow money like that if you're a bank," said Dan O'Malley, who runs PerkStreet, which sets up customers in a checking account with a debit card that can pay back 2 percent in rebates. "It looks bad to regulators, like you didn't have enough deposits to plan your business well."

While PerkStreet has been extremely aggressive with its debit card rewards, it does not plan to top the interest rate tables when it introduces a savings account next year.

CREDIT UNION LAGGARDS: It's a bit surprising that credit unions, which exist to serve members rather than shareholders, don't pay more. Surprising, that is, until you consider what it really means to serve.

Credit union members putting money into certificates of deposit would love to earn more, and they often do get a bit more than they would from a nearby megabank. But members who are borrowers want to pay less for their loans, and they often do.

THE PROBLEM WITH WINNING: But why not just pay us a bit more, even a quarter of a percentage point? Surely there must be an institution strong enough to do that or willing to do it to build good will.

Even in this environment, however, companies may not need all of the potential deposits. Sallie Mae started its savings account and CD offering this year to raise money that it could then lend out for student loans. It is offering one of the best rates in the country, a 1.3 percent annual percentage yield, but it's not alone atop the rankings.

"We don't need more than the amount that is coming in," said Joe DePaulo, Sallie Mae's chief marketing officer.

LAZY CUSTOMERS: Many big banks continue to pay well below 1 percent. Why? Because you let them. Sure, it's a bit inconvenient to open a separate, higher-yielding account and link it to your bank account when you're not getting all that much more for the privilege. But because many people don't bother doing that, many megabanks continue on their merry way, paying absolutely pathetic savings account rates.

Saving money is harder now than when your parents did it 12/11/10 [Last modified: Saturday, December 11, 2010 3:31am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Florida turns over voter-roll data to Trump election commission

    State Roundup

    Florida provided voter-roll data to President Donald Trump's election fraud commission Friday despite a lawsuit by the ACLU of Florida attempting to prevent the state from providing the information.

    Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, left, and Vice President Mike Pence, right, lead the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity, which is seeking voter data from every state.
  2. Wells Fargo charged 800,000 for unnecessary auto insurance, internal report says


    Wells Fargo incorrectly charged 800,000 of its auto loan customers for unnecessary auto insurance, according to an internal report obtained by The New York Times. According to the report, about 274,000 of those customers were forced into delinquency on their loans, which resulted in 25,000 repossessions. …

    An internal Wells Fargo report obtained by The New York Times said the bank charged more than 800,000 people for auto insurance they did not need.  | [Los Angeles Times]
  3. Trigaux: Do we all need PhDs to fight scams, frauds and rip-offs?


    There are days when it feels like our school priorities are all wrong. Literature? Math? Computers? Nah. What everyone really needs to survive in the 21st century is a PhD in fighting the rise of increasingly creative consumer scams, frauds and rip-offs.

    As solar panels become cheaper and more popular, consumer agencies are starting to see a rise in consumer complaints about misleading and deceptive solar offerings. Solar scams are noted in a national report on major consumer complaints issued this week by the Consumer Federation of America and the North American Consumer Protection Investigators. [William Levesque, Times]
  4. Starbucks to close all Teavana locations, including five in Tampa Bay


    Local Teavana locations include Tyrone Square in St. Petersburg, International Plaza and Westfield Citrus Park in Tampa, Brandon and Clearwater.

    Starbucks announced Thursday plans to shut down all 379 Teavana stores, citing "underperformance." Starbucks acquired the mall-based tea chain for $620 million in 2012. [ CANDICE CHOI | AP file photo]
  5. Trigaux: Closing Iron Yard coding school hits area tech hard but leaders talk of options


    The coming shutdown this fall of the Iron Yard software coding school in downtown St. Petersburg — announced this month as part of a national closing of all 15 Iron Yard locations — remains a shocking event to a Tampa Bay technology community that dreams big of becoming a major player in the Southeast if not …

    In better days last fall, friends and family of graduates at The Iron Yard, based in the Station House in downtown St. Petersburg, applaud during "Demo Day" when grads of the coding school show off their skills. Despite the local success and strong job placement by the coding school, The Iron Yard is closing all of its 15 locations across the country this summer. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]