Make us your home page

Scott's rejection of high-speed rail will be costly for Florida's future

Florida Gov. Rick Scott last week unilaterally derailed the Tampa-to-Orlando high-speed rail line, saying the potential financial costs to the state were just too high.

But the price to Florida of doing nothing may prove no less stratospheric.

Amid a struggling state economy, doing nothing means lost jobs now and lost jobs in the future by pulling the plug not only on the 84-mile Tampa-to-Orlando line, but the entire statewide high-speed rail network that was expected to follow.

Doing nothing delivers a blow to Florida's deepest desire to convey a can-do, 21st century image to the rest of the world. Doing nothing takes away Central Florida's once-in-a-lifetime chance to be the first and (for a while) only true high-speed rail project in the United States. Doing nothing sacrifices $2.4 billion in federal funds once committed to high-speed rail here but soon likely destined for similar projects in more-welcoming states.

And doing nothing threatens the already-thin ties between Scott and a business community still eager to work with him but confounded by his premature thumbs-down on high-speed rail. Scott said no thanks before eight worldwide private rail consortia could propose ways to run a brand new railroad and protect state taxpayers from bailouts.

Longtime rail proponent and now St. Petersburg Area Chamber of Commerce CEO Chris Steinocher warns that Florida runs a big global risk by pulling the rug out from under major foreign rail corporations that had spent considerable time on their bids.

"We led everyone to believe there was this process," he said. Then Scott pulled the plug. "That is not how you stimulate the economy."

All may not be lost just yet, even as a deadline looms for billions in federal dollars to be reallocated to other states. Florida's elected officials and business groups are performing a near-desperate form of triage to save the project. They hope to create a regional consortium of metropolitan planning organizations that could legally receive the fed's $2.4 billion. Then they hope to restructure the Tampa-Orlando line to exclude the state from any financial obligations.

"It feels like a long shot," acknowledged Tampa Mayor Pam Iorio, who has been hyperfocused for many years on selling rail to the area. A regional rail plan was defeated by Hillsborough County voters last fall.

"This has tremendous costs," said the exasperated mayor, who has a little over a month left in office. In an interview, she detailed those costs.

• Florida, long a donor of its federal gas tax revenues to other states, finally got $2.4 billion in federal funds back in its favor for high-speed rail. Not anymore.

• The first true high-speed rail line in America would have put Tampa Bay on the map. "It's a project we would show off and people would come to see."

• Without adding high-speed rail to the transportation mix, Iorio says, how do we move people around Florida in the 21st century? Just adding more roads and bigger airports come with very high price tags, too.

• She worries we are creating an image to the world of Florida as a state that does not want progress. "What is our message? 'Don't bother.' "

Transportation experts point out the loss of high-speed rail will start to cost Florida dearly as its growing population ages and more people clamor for quality mass transportation, not just more driving.

"Having that transportation alternative in Florida would be a benefit," says Stephen Reich, interim director in Tampa of the University of South Florida's Center for Urban Transportation Research. "We have been woefully underfunding transportation in this country for a couple of decades."

At the Brookings Institution in Washington, senior research analyst and high-speed rail observer Adie Tomer warns that as gas prices rise and the costs of owning a car increase, "more and more folks will need to rely on other modes to get around."

Let's be clear. This column does not suggest high-speed rail should be built at all costs. Many Floridians have long argued the price tag of the high-speed rail line between Tampa and Orlando is too much. Ridership will never justify its costs and the time saved over driving from one city to the other on Interstate 4 is insignificant, they say. Besides, without regional rail systems at either end of the high speed rail line, how do passengers get around Tampa or Orlando easily?

All good points. But consider: The Tampa-Orlando line is just the first short leg of what would be a statewide network of high-speed rail, including a second leg of 220 miles connecting Orlando and Miami. Eventually, Jacksonville would be connected, then Atlanta as the rail connections went interstate.

If it ever happens. While the Obama administration wants to invest $53 billion nationwide in high-speed rail in the coming years, intense federal and state budget battles make that increasingly less likely.

It's easy to say the project is too expensive, so we're dropping it and handing back $2.4 billion in federal funds. But there are expenses — some major — that Florida must absorb in not pursuing high-speed rail, too.

Those costs were compounded by the premature scuttling of the deal. Florida is sending the wrong message to businesses looking to put down roots or bid on future game-changing projects: We won't even bother listening to your ideas.

"We are hoping to be seen as the leader of this new type of transportation in the United States, but we risk being seen as less progressive," said Steinocher at the St. Pete Chamber. "Our rail line is flat and does not go over mountains or under the San Francisco Bay. We thought companies could invest here first."

For communities like Tampa Bay and Orlando, Steinocher wonders: How rarely do we get to position ourselves as leaders of a brand new initiative in the United States?

So rare that it may have disappeared all too soon before our eyes. That will cost us.

Robert Trigaux can be reached at [email protected]

Scott's rejection of high-speed rail will be costly for Florida's future 02/19/11 [Last modified: Sunday, February 20, 2011 2:59pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. How a group of Florida tomato growers could help derail NAFTA


    Tony DiMare, a third-generation Florida tomato grower, has spent two decades contending with cheap Mexican imports, watching his neighbors abandon crops in their fields and sell off their farms when they couldn't match the price of incoming produce.

    Workers fill a trailer with tomatoes as they harvest them in the fields of DiMare Farms in Florida City. [Joe Raedle | Getty Images(2013)]
  2. Pinellas deputies go door-to-door at dawn to arrest unlicensed contractors


    Pinellas deputies began pounding on doors at 5 a.m. Tuesday, part of a widespread roundup of contractors accused of working without licences and workers compensation.

    Pinellas Sheriff deputies J. Short, left, and T. Festa, right, arrest suspect Randy Ronchi, center, in Largo early Tuesday, as part of a joint roundup of unlicensed contractors. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]
  3. HQ2 watch: As deadline looms for Amazon headquarters pitch, one metro bows out


    If there's one national business saga to keep up on these days, it's the frenzy by metropolitan areas — including Tampa Bay — to make their best pitches to Amazon in the hope of being chosen as the new location for the giant online retailer's second massive headquarters. HQ2, as it is called, would create …

    Cities across the country are trying to land Amazon's second headquarters, known as HQ2. In Birmingham, Ala., giant Amazon boxes were constructed and placed around the city as part of its "Bring A to B" campaign. [Ali Clark/Bring A to B Campaign]
  4. Shares in Tampa's Health Insurance Innovations rebound from stronger earnings report


    TAMPA — After a sharp drop in its stock price in August and September, Health Insurance Innovations on Monday announced strong revenue and net income gains in preliminary numbers for its third quarter of the year. The company also announced a $50 million stock buyback over the next two years meant to bolster its …

    After losing more than half its market value between August and September, shares in Tampa's Health Insurance Innovations are rebounding."The new share repurchase program underscores our confidence in our business strategy, financial performance, and the long-term prospects of our company while also allowing us the financial flexibility to continue to invest in our business," company CEO Gavin Southwell announced Monday. [Courtesy of LinkedIn]
  5. Trigaux: Campaign aims to leverage tourism ads to recruit millennials, businesses

    Economic Development

    TAMPA — Tampa Bay's unleashing one of its best weapons — a cadre of successful entrepreneurs and young business leaders — in a marketing campaign already under way but officially …

    Erin Meagher, founder of Tampa coconut oil products company Beneficial Blends, is part of a group of business savvy millennial entrepreneurs and managers who are helping to pitch the work-live-play merits of the Tampa Bay market in a new marketing campaign called Make It Tampa Bay. The campaign is backed by Visit Tampa Bay and the Tampa Hillsborough Economic Development Corp. and aimed at recruiting more millennial talent to relocate and stay in the Tampa Bay area. [Courtesy Tampa Hillsborough EDC, Visit Tampa Bay]