Make us your home page

Similarities exist between the economic downturns of the 1970s and today

Is Florida ready to go retro?

Back to the '70s, not in terms of fashion but in terms of finances.

Comparisons to the Great Depression aside, the country's burgeoning economic slump is drawing sharp parallels to the early 1970s — the last time the stock markets behaved in such a consistently lurching manner indicating utter lack of investor faith; the last, long-running "secular" bear market.

Raymond James chairman Tom James gets nostalgic, but not in a good way. "I'm still amazed at how tough this is, because I haven't seen anything like this since '73, '74," said the head of the St. Petersburg financial services company. "And nobody really remembers what it was like, because we're far enough away."

The circumstances aren't exactly the same. The 1973 turndown was fueled by a crippling oil embargo and extended by surging inflation. This one had its roots in a housing bust and the ripple of bad mortgage loans. It was pushed into overdrive by fearful financial institutions that cut off the flow of credit.

The Florida of 2008 also looks a lot different from 35 years ago. It's much larger, more globally connected and far less reliant on tourism. But if you could go back again, it offers a scenario of how Florida's shifting fortunes may play out.

A. Gerald "Jerry" Divers, the septuagenarian president of Bank of Tampa, was making loans and working in the trust department at the former Exchange Bank (now part of Bank of America) in the early 1970s.

He rattles off several eerie similarities between then and now. Like most Florida recessions, a housing downturn came first. In the '70s, the core problem was speculative landowners saddled with lots they couldn't develop; this time, it was home builders and owners saddled with houses they can't sell.

Then came the broader downturn that's being replicated, with everyone from lawyers to car dealers to lawn service companies seeing fewer customers.

One telltale sign Divers notices is that, just like 35 years ago, there's a big chill on changing jobs. Bank of Tampa used to have 10 to 12 open positions at any time. Now there are none, as even entry-level bank tellers are unlikely to change jobs in this climate.

"And when an opening does come up, you'd find 20 to 30 people to fill it," he said. "That frankly is what we're feeling now."

So what would a prolonged recession look like in Florida?

• More breathing room at schools and day care centers. Nearly ever major recession has been accompanied by a drop in the birth rate as hard-pressed couples stall starting a family or have fewer kids. Between 1973 and 1976, the U.S. fertility rate fell every year, only climbing again post-recession.

• More elderly workers as retirement dreams are postponed.

• Cheap prices. Short-term, it may cost less to buy a car, clothes or a house as fewer shoppers usually triggers deflation. Long-term, the Federal Reserve's pumping of money into the system could fuel inflation, as it did in the late 1970s.

• More burglaries and robberies. There are conflicting opinions here. But Bruce Weinberg, an associate professor of economics at Ohio State University, said his research, stretching back 30 years, shows a pattern of crime rates increasing in tandem with a weak labor market.

"That's particularly true with property crime or crimes with financial motives like robbery," he said.

• Tighter credit. As we're seeing already, many consumers are finding it harder to qualify for a credit card and carry large balances. Late fees will rise.

It'll be a rude awakening, predicted Ben Bishop, who bought the Allen C. Ewing & Co. investment banking firm in Jacksonville back in 1973, a period when credit wasn't so easy. Look for more bank failures, consumer defaults and bankruptcies as the "deleveraging" process unfolds, Bishop said.

Who'll do well this time? Hospitals, consumer good companies (think Procter & Gamble) and purveyors of inexpensive entertainment. During the Great Depression, the motion picture industry did well as people sought to satisfy a need for affordable diversions.

Who won't do well? A longer list: the service industry, for starters. Americans can't live beyond their means with neither easy credit nor much home equity.

Joe Consumer will eat out less, cut back on shopping sprees, and take fewer flights and vacations. Businesses have cut back on advertising and perks. Retailers are bracing for a brutal holiday season.

As housing prices fell and construction dried up, Florida's job losses have mostly been in home building, construction-related manufacturing, financial services, wholesale trade, and retailing.

The next stage, Wachovia economist Mark Vitner forecasts, is job losses across a broader spectrum.

"Tourism has also held up relatively well so far," Vitner said. "That is not expected to continue. The tourist and convention trade tends to respond to swings in the national and global economies, which slowed in the first half of the year and are now in recession."

Raymond James economist Scott Brown predicts U.S. unemployment will rise to 7.5 percent by the middle of 2009, likely higher in Florida. "And there's a danger things could get a lot worse."

Brown and fellow economist David Denslow at the University of Florida have pushed back statewide recovery forecasts to 2010 or 2011. And recovery of devastated stock markets could be years later.

After the Great Depression began, it wasn't until 1958, 29 years later, that the market reached its pre-Depression peak, adjusted for inflation. By a similar measure, the bear market that included the 1970s recession was nearly as long, extending 24 years until 1992.

Divers, for one, believes Florida's boom-and-bust cycle won't bounce back again as quickly or strongly as it has after past recessions. Retirees elsewhere in the country can't afford to sell their homes and make the trek southward. And those that can sell are often lured by cheaper options in Georgia and North Carolina which don't come with the property insurance and tax issues dogging Florida.

Then again, Divers said, "I'm looking out my window on Tampa Bay on a beautiful day, and you cannot do this in south Georgia.

"It'll take longer (to come back) but it'll work."

How it's like the 1970s

• Stock markets fluctuate sharply, with rallies followed by a period where markets give up much of their gains amid concerns of a prolonged downturn.

• Market watchers talk about recovery in terms

of a decade or more, instead of a few years.

• Consumer spending trends down; unemployment trends up.

• No irrational exuberance here. Consumer confidence is down.

How it's not

• In the 1970s, the oil embargo created shortages and a sharp spike at the pump. Today, oil prices are trending down from recent highs and expected to push gas prices below the $3 mark.

• Inflation eventually roared into the double-digits in the ’70s. Today, despite the recent spike in energy prices and food prices, across-the-board inflation hasn't weighed as a serious threat.

• Americans routinely saved more than 10 percent of their income in the early 1970s. The savings rate today has dwindled significantly.

How we hope it's not

The 1970s recession, by strict definition, lasted only a year and a half. But it took until 1992 for the market to make a full recovery and move past the prolonged bear market.

Similarities exist between the economic downturns of the 1970s and today 10/18/08 [Last modified: Monday, October 20, 2008 4:11pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Florida turns over voter-roll data to Trump election commission

    State Roundup

    Florida provided voter-roll data to President Donald Trump's election fraud commission Friday despite a lawsuit by the ACLU of Florida attempting to prevent the state from providing the information.

    Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, left, and Vice President Mike Pence, right, lead the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity, which is seeking voter data from every state.
  2. Wells Fargo charged 800,000 for unnecessary auto insurance, internal report says


    Wells Fargo incorrectly charged 800,000 of its auto loan customers for unnecessary auto insurance, according to an internal report obtained by The New York Times. According to the report, about 274,000 of those customers were forced into delinquency on their loans, which resulted in 25,000 repossessions. …

    An internal Wells Fargo report obtained by The New York Times said the bank charged more than 800,000 people for auto insurance they did not need.  | [Los Angeles Times]
  3. Trigaux: Do we all need PhDs to fight scams, frauds and rip-offs?


    There are days when it feels like our school priorities are all wrong. Literature? Math? Computers? Nah. What everyone really needs to survive in the 21st century is a PhD in fighting the rise of increasingly creative consumer scams, frauds and rip-offs.

    As solar panels become cheaper and more popular, consumer agencies are starting to see a rise in consumer complaints about misleading and deceptive solar offerings. Solar scams are noted in a national report on major consumer complaints issued this week by the Consumer Federation of America and the North American Consumer Protection Investigators. [William Levesque, Times]
  4. Starbucks to close all Teavana locations, including five in Tampa Bay


    Local Teavana locations include Tyrone Square in St. Petersburg, International Plaza and Westfield Citrus Park in Tampa, Brandon and Clearwater.

    Starbucks announced Thursday plans to shut down all 379 Teavana stores, citing "underperformance." Starbucks acquired the mall-based tea chain for $620 million in 2012. [ CANDICE CHOI | AP file photo]
  5. Trigaux: Closing Iron Yard coding school hits area tech hard but leaders talk of options


    The coming shutdown this fall of the Iron Yard software coding school in downtown St. Petersburg — announced this month as part of a national closing of all 15 Iron Yard locations — remains a shocking event to a Tampa Bay technology community that dreams big of becoming a major player in the Southeast if not …

    In better days last fall, friends and family of graduates at The Iron Yard, based in the Station House in downtown St. Petersburg, applaud during "Demo Day" when grads of the coding school show off their skills. Despite the local success and strong job placement by the coding school, The Iron Yard is closing all of its 15 locations across the country this summer. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]