Make us your home page

Smaller planes are safe, experienced pilots agree

Anyone who flies small commuter planes feels a twinge when scenes from the crash of Continental Express Flight 3407 flash across a TV screen.

Maybe you've become accustomed to the roar of turboprop engines. You're good with ducking to walk down the narrow aisle to your seat. But at some point the question pops into your head.

Are these planes as safe as big airliners?

I asked three aviation veterans — a United Airlines pilot, a retired US Airways pilot and a professor at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University in Daytona Beach. Their unanimous response: absolutely.

Obviously, the question papers over a universe of nuances. Regional airlines like Continental Express carrier Colgan Air operate differently than global giants. Small turboprops have different characteristics than large jets. And pilots who fly them generally have less time in the cockpit.

That last point has been getting a lot of attention since the accident outside Buffalo Thursday.

Capt. Marvin Renslow finished training on the Dash 8 aircraft two months ago. He had 110 hours flying the plane. Renslow flew most of his 3,370 hours in 3 1/2 years at Colgan on a much smaller Saab twin-engine turboprop.

By contrast, Capt. Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, who landed his US Airways jet safely in the Hudson River last month, had flown nearly 20,000 hours in 28 years.

Regional airlines have grown rapidly in recent years as major carriers shifted flying on lightly traveled routes to their partners' turboprops and small jets. That caused a pilot shortage. To fill the jobs, regional airlines reduced minimum flying experience for new hire co-pilots.

Safety experts worried a few years ago that the lower standards might result in more accidents, said Cass Howell, chairman of the aeronautical science department at Embry-Riddle. Statistics subsequently gleaned from accident reports didn't show that air safety suffered.

There's no clear cause-and-effect relationship between pilot experience and accident rates, says John Cox, a former US Airways pilot and former safety investigator for the Air Line Pilots Association.

"Sully Sullenberger is a good example of what experience can do for you," says Cox. "But a lot of experienced aviators make mistakes and a lot of low-time aviators have done good things. You can't draw a quick conclusion."

Steve Huettel can be reached at or (813) 226-3384.

Smaller planes are safe, experienced pilots agree 02/17/09 [Last modified: Tuesday, February 17, 2009 9:31pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Would you let your company implant a chip in you?

    Working Life

    Would you ask an employee to get a chip implanted in her hand? Sounds invasive and intrusive. But come Aug. 1, one company in Wisconsin will be giving it a try.

    Three Square Market - a developer of software used in vending machines - is offering all of its employees the option to get a microchip implanted between the thumb and forefinger. [Photo from video]
  2. Daniel Lipton resigns as artistic director of Opera Tampa


    TAMPA — Daniel Lipton has resigned as artistic director of Opera Tampa, the David A. Straz Jr. Center for the Performing Arts announced.

    Daniel Lipton became the artistic director and conductor of Opera Tampa in 2012. Lipton replaced the opera's only previous director, Anton Coppola, who retired. [Times file (2012)]
  3. Throwback Tampa Bay station 102.9 goes from R&B jams to WFLA-AM's conservative talk


    Talk radio station WFLA-AM (970) began simulcasting on 102.9 FM in the Tampa area this morning. 

    Tampa's 102.9 is going from Throwback Tampa Bay to WFLA-AM's news radio.
  4. Bank of Tampa expanding into Sarasota


    TAMPA — The Bank of Tampa is expanding to Sarasota County. It opened a loan office this month in downtown Sarasota at 1858 Ringling Blvd., which will be converted to a full-service branch within the year, the company said in a release Monday.

    The Bank of Tampa is expanding to Sarasota. Charles Murphy, pictured, will lead the Sarasota branch. | [Courtesy of The Bank of Tampa]
  5. Tampa Bay home prices still climbing, though more slowly

    Real Estate

    Tampa Bay home prices rose again in June, although the once-torrid pace of increases shows signs of slowing.

    This three story home in Port Richey's gated Harborpointe sold for $1.15 million in June, making it the top sale in Pasco County for the month.
[Penny Perry]