Make us your home page

Smaller planes are safe, experienced pilots agree

Anyone who flies small commuter planes feels a twinge when scenes from the crash of Continental Express Flight 3407 flash across a TV screen.

Maybe you've become accustomed to the roar of turboprop engines. You're good with ducking to walk down the narrow aisle to your seat. But at some point the question pops into your head.

Are these planes as safe as big airliners?

I asked three aviation veterans — a United Airlines pilot, a retired US Airways pilot and a professor at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University in Daytona Beach. Their unanimous response: absolutely.

Obviously, the question papers over a universe of nuances. Regional airlines like Continental Express carrier Colgan Air operate differently than global giants. Small turboprops have different characteristics than large jets. And pilots who fly them generally have less time in the cockpit.

That last point has been getting a lot of attention since the accident outside Buffalo Thursday.

Capt. Marvin Renslow finished training on the Dash 8 aircraft two months ago. He had 110 hours flying the plane. Renslow flew most of his 3,370 hours in 3 1/2 years at Colgan on a much smaller Saab twin-engine turboprop.

By contrast, Capt. Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, who landed his US Airways jet safely in the Hudson River last month, had flown nearly 20,000 hours in 28 years.

Regional airlines have grown rapidly in recent years as major carriers shifted flying on lightly traveled routes to their partners' turboprops and small jets. That caused a pilot shortage. To fill the jobs, regional airlines reduced minimum flying experience for new hire co-pilots.

Safety experts worried a few years ago that the lower standards might result in more accidents, said Cass Howell, chairman of the aeronautical science department at Embry-Riddle. Statistics subsequently gleaned from accident reports didn't show that air safety suffered.

There's no clear cause-and-effect relationship between pilot experience and accident rates, says John Cox, a former US Airways pilot and former safety investigator for the Air Line Pilots Association.

"Sully Sullenberger is a good example of what experience can do for you," says Cox. "But a lot of experienced aviators make mistakes and a lot of low-time aviators have done good things. You can't draw a quick conclusion."

Steve Huettel can be reached at or (813) 226-3384.

Smaller planes are safe, experienced pilots agree 02/17/09 [Last modified: Tuesday, February 17, 2009 9:31pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pinellas construction licensing board needs to be fixed. But how?

    Local Government

    LARGO –– Everyone agrees that the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board needs to be reformed. But no one agrees on how to do it.

    Rodney Fischer, former executive director of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board Rodney, at a February meeting. His management of the agency was criticized by an inspector general's report. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]

  2. New owners take over downtown St. Petersburg's Hofbräuhaus


    ST. PETERSBURG — The downtown German beer-hall Hofbräuhaus St. Petersburg has been bought by a partnership led by former Checkers Drive-In Restaurants president Keith Sirois.

    The Hofbrauhaus, St. Petersburg, located in the former historic Tramor Cafeteria, St. Petersburg, is under new ownership.

  3. Boho Hunter will target fashions in Hyde Park


    Boho Hunter, a boutique based in Miami's Wynwood District, will expand into Tampa with its very first franchise.

    Palma Canaria bags will be among the featured items at Boho Hunter when it opens in October. Photo courtesy of Boho Hunter.
  4. Gallery now bringing useful art to Hyde Park customers


    HYDE PARK — In 1998, Mike and Sue Shapiro opened a gallery in St. Petersburg along Central Ave., with a majority of the space dedicated to Sue's clay studio.

     As Sue Shapiro continued to work on her pottery in St. Petersburg, her retail space grew and her studio shrunk. Now Shapiro's is bringing wares like these to Hyde Park Village. Photo courtesy of Shapiro's.
  5. Appointments at Raymond James Bank and Saint Leo University highlight this week's Tampa Bay business Movers & Shakers



    Raymond James Bank has hired Grace Jackson to serve as executive vice president and chief operating officer. Jackson will oversee all of Raymond James Bank's operational business elements, risk management and strategic planning functions. Kackson joins Raymond James Bank after senior …

    Raymond James Bank has hired Grace Jackson to serve as executive vice president and chief operating officer. [Company handout]