Make us your home page

Underwater mortgages drowning homeowners and the economy

WASHINGTON — For almost two years, home foreclosures have swept the nation, spreading misery among once-buoyant families, spattering lenders with red ink and undermining efforts to restart the economy.

But a bigger problem may turn out to be the millions of Americans who are still faithfully paying their mortgages, but on houses worth far less than before the bubble burst. It's not that these homeowners will stop making their payments. It's just the opposite — that they will keep doing it.

How could that be a source of future trouble? Because, with home prices stagnant in much of the country, payments on mortgages that are underwater could absorb billions of dollars that might be used for other forms of consumer spending — a drag on family finances, the housing market and the overall economy. And the drag could persist for years.

Of the estimated 15 million homeowners underwater, about 7.8 million owed at least 25 percent more than their properties were worth in the first quarter of this year, according to Moody's Analytics' calculations of Equifax credit records and government data. More than 4 million borrowers, including 672,000 in California, 424,000 in Florida and 121,000 in Illinois — three of the biggest real estate markets — were underwater more than 50 percent. Their average negative equity: a whopping $107,000.

Many of these homeowners are paying much higher interest rates than the latest national average of 4.25 percent. They still have jobs and can afford to make the payments.

But they can't refinance because they owe too much. That home equity line of credit isn't going to happen. Even ordinary loans may be impossible to get. And selling the home at a huge loss is out of the question.

Nor can most underwater borrowers take advantage of the Treasury Department's loan modification program, which generally requires a job loss or another kind of hardship.

In other words, they're stuck.

Heather Hines and her husband reflect this new reality. They owe $415,000 on a Santa Rosa, Calif., townhouse they bought in 2004 for $430,000. When the county appraised the three-bedroom home a few weeks ago, it was worth $246,000 — even less than a year earlier.

The couple had planned to move to a larger home after their two children became teenagers, but now that looks impossible. Their house needs a new roof, but they've put off replacing it for more than a year.

"It's hard to think of making that investment when you're hundreds of thousands underwater," said Hines, 37, a city planner who, like her husband, is employed and has an advanced university degree.

"It just feels hopeless. What are we supposed to do? It feels like we're never going to see any equity in our home."

Theoretically, the Hines family could walk away — stop making the mortgage payments that consume a big part of their income. But defaulting would ruin their credit and have other negative consequences. So, she said, they'll keep paying and hoping for the best. Unhappily for the rest of the country, that's not the end of the problem: The Hineses' financial bind will ripple throughout their community and the larger economy.

The real estate market depends on such homeowners being able to sell and move up; without them the trade-up market can't grow.

Meantime, the Hineses will keep delaying that new roof, depriving a local roofer of business. They're unlikely to redecorate or upgrade the kitchen either, as millions of families were doing before the recession — more potential losses for local businesses, not to mention the car dealers, clothing and consumer electronics stores and manufacturers of the products that the Hineses won't buy.

Weighed down by the huge debt on their house, they also will be a lot more cautious about how they use credit cards. Big family getaways in the summer? Forget it, Hines said. Multiply such sentiments by millions across the country and that translates into lackluster private spending, which accounts for 70 percent of the American economy.

"Families have not yet boosted their spending above the levels preceding the severe cuts they made during the recession," William Dudley, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, said in a speech last month.

"This frugality stands in stark contrast to the first year of recovery from previous deep recessions," Dudley said.

In prior downturns, the housing industry and consumer spending powered the economy back to strength. Home building not only created construction and finance jobs but also fueled manufacturing of glass and lumber, furniture and appliances, and a host of other goods and services.

In normal times, the United States should be putting up about 1.7 million new houses annually, but this year it's running at about 600,000, economist David Crowe of the National Home Builders Association said. He thinks it will be three years before home building returns to its potential.

Rather than going out on their own or starting families, young Americans are doubling up with friends and relatives, saving more and paying down debts. Older Americans are staying in their jobs longer, hoping that the single biggest asset for most of them — their homes — will recover in value.

But nobody expects a return of rapid real estate appreciation any time soon. If home prices were to rise at an annual rate of 3 percent, not an unlikely scenario, it would take the Hineses about 11 years to get to a point where their mortgage balance was even with their property value.

Refinancing the Hineses' 6.5 percent interest loan could be a big help, saving them almost $600 a month. But lenders won't even consider them.

And unless borrowers fall behind on their mortgage payments or face a high risk of defaulting, there's little chance that lenders, even with federal incentives, would reduce their principal or lower their interest rates.

"They feel completely left out," said Fred Arnold, past president of the California Association of Mortgage Professionals, referring to many underwater borrowers.

"If you stop payments, you have a much better chance of getting a modification," Arnold said.

He contends that the federal government should set aside funds to help more borrowers refinance: "It would put immediate money into the economy." But that's not in the cards, especially with budget deficits weighing on Washington and the American public.

Eventually, economists suggested, a lack of options will push more underwater borrowers to walk away from their mortgages. But in the meantime, the stress on families, the housing market and the whole economy will continue.

Tampa Bay underwater

In the Tampa Bay area, the average home value in the summer was $118,700, according to Zillow. More than 45 percent of mortgage-holders were underwater, and sellers took a loss on about 40 percent of homes sold in June, according to Zillow. For the second quarter, about 48 percent of Tampa metro homeowners were considered underwater, more than twice the national average of 23 percent.

How these mortgages hurt the economy

Millions of homeowners are underwater, meaning they owe more on their mortgage than the home is worth. In Tampa Bay this summer, more than 45 percent of mortgage-holders were underwater.

They can't borrow against their equity because they have no equity. They can't refinance because no bank will lend them more money than the house is worth.

With no wiggle room in their income, the homeowners put off renovations or needed repairs. Fewer new homes are built because no one can afford to move.

Contractors and roofers have to lay off workers. They don't buy building supplies. Cash-strapped homeowners don't take trips or go out for fancy dinners. Private spending shrivels.

15 million

Estimated number

of U.S. homeowners

who are underwater

7.8 million

Homeowners who owed at least 25 percent more than their properties were worth in the first quarter of this year

4 million

U.S. homeowners who owed at least 50 percent more than their properties were worth in the first quarter of this year


California homeowners

who owed at least 50 percent more than their properties were worth


Florida homeowners who owed at least 50 percent more than properties were worth


Illinois homeowners who owed at least 50 percent more than properties were worth

Source: Moody's Analytics

Underwater mortgages drowning homeowners and the economy 11/04/10 [Last modified: Thursday, November 4, 2010 11:22pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Carrollwood fitness center employs scientific protocol to help clients


    In 2005, Al Roach and Virginia Phillips, husband and wife, opened 20 Minutes to Fitness in Lakewood Ranch, and last month they opened the doors to their new location in Carrollwood.

    Preston Fisher, a personal fitness coach at 20 Minutes To Fitness, stands with an iPad while general manager/owner Angela Begin conducts an equipment demonstration. The iPad is used to track each client's information and progress. I also included one shot of just the equipment. The center recently opened in Carrollwood. Photo by Danielle Hauser.
  2. Olive Tree branches out to Wesley Chapel


    WESLEY CHAPEL — When it came time to open a second location of The Olive Tree, owners John and Donna Woelfel, decided that Wesley Chapel was the perfect place.

    The Olive Tree expands its offerings of "ultra premium?€ extra virgin olive oils (EVOO) to a second location in Wesley Chapel. Photo by Danielle Hauser.
  3. Massachusetts firm buys Tampa's Element apartment tower

    Real Estate

    TAMPA — Downtown Tampa's Element apartment tower sold this week to a Massachusetts-based real estate investment company that plans to upgrade the skyscraper's amenities and operate it long-term as a rental community.

    The Element apartment high-rise at 808 N Franklin St. in downtown Tampa has been sold to a Northland Investment Corp., a Massachusetts-based real estate investment company. JIM DAMASKE  |  Times
  4. New York town approves Legoland proposal


    GOSHEN, N.Y. — New York is one step closer to a Lego dreamland. Goshen, a small town about fifty miles northwest of the Big Apple, has approved the site plan for a $500 million Legoland amusement park.

    A small New York town, Goshen approved the site plan for a $500 million Legoland amusement park. Legoland Florida is in Winter Haven. [Times file  photo]
  5. Jordan Park to get $20 million makeover and new senior housing

    Real Estate


    Times Staff Writer

    ST. PETERSBURG —The St. Petersburg Housing Authority, which bought back the troubled Jordan Park public housing complex this year, plans to spend about $20 million to improve the 237-unit property and construct a new three-story building for …

    Jordan Park, the historic public housing complex, is back in the hands of the St. Petersburg Housing Authority. The agency is working to improve the 237-unit complex. But the latest plan to build a new three-story building for seniors will mean 31 families have to find new homes. [LARA CERRI   |   Tampa Bay Times]