Make us your home page

Workers' comp ruling may affect lowered rates

The Florida Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that a lawyer representing an injured worker is entitled to "reasonable" fees, setting the stage for another bruising legislative battle over the Florida law that ensures the rights of injured workers.

The decision reinterprets a controversial 2003 reform of the state's workers' compensation law that capped some lawyers fees.

Attorneys that represent injured workers hailed the case as a success, but industry groups warned that it will drive up the cost of doing business in Florida.

"It certainly is a favorable opinion for injured workers and their attorneys," said Greg Lower, a Jacksonville attorney with Fowler White Boggs Banker, who was not involved in the case. "It was not a favorable opinion for industry."

Industry groups lobbied hard for the 2003 reform in an attempt to drive down the cost of workers' compensation insurance. At the time, Florida's businesses paid some of the highest rates in the nation. Since the reform was enacted, rates have fallen nearly 60 percent and were slated to fall still further next year. But the savings came at the expense of injured workers, say labor advocates and attorneys that represent injured workers.

"Having clients not in court results in decreased costs. How can it not?" said Leslie Riviere, a workers' compensation attorney in Tampa who was not involved in the case. "But it also results in injured workers not receiving compensation for medical bills and lost wages that they'd otherwise be entitled to."

The Florida Chamber of Commerce signaled that it will lobby the Legislature to revise the law.

"This is just another example of plaintiffs' trial lawyers attempting to bleed more attorney fees from Florida employers using our state's workers' compensation system," read a statement from David Daniel, vice president of government affairs with the Florida Chamber of Commerce.

The Supreme Court ruled 5-0 in the case, Emma Murray vs. Mariner Health Care, which stemmed from an injury suffered five years ago by Murray. A nurse in her late 50s, she was hurt hoisting a patient at the nursing home where she worked. Her employer's insurance carrier denied her claim, chalking up her injury to a pre-existing condition.

Murray hired Port Charlotte lawyer Brian Sutter and won $3,244 in back wages and medical costs. Since Mariner Health Care lost the suit, it also had to pay Murray's court costs, but the 2003 law had imposed a strict formula on how much a worker's attorney could be paid. Murray's attorney was entitled to $648 for the 80 hours he spent preparing her case — about $8 an hour. Mariner Health Care paid its own lawyers about $16,000.

Sutter argued that the inequity — letting the employer pay its lawyer $150 an hour, while the injured worker's lawyer was limited to $8 an hour — left the worker with an unconstitutional disadvantage. The law gives insurers incentive to deny legitimate claims like Murray's, since few lawyers will take on complex and expensive cases for such meager fees, Sutter said this year.

The Supreme Court sidestepped the constitutional issue, and ruled Thursday that the 2003 law was unclear since it does contain a reference to "reasonable" fees. The court ruled that the ambiguity should be decided in favor of Murray's attorney and ordered Mariner to pay fees of about $16,000, which amounts to close to $200 an hour.

Kevin McCarty, Florida's insurance commissioner, promised a quick review of the decision to determine the impact on the cost of workers' compensation insurance.

Rates were slated for another drop this year, and it's unclear what impact the decision will have. Adam Babington, legislative counsel for the Florida Chamber of Commerce, said he expects more information on insurance rates in the next few weeks.

Asjylyn Loder can be reached at or (813) 225-3117.

Workers' comp ruling may affect lowered rates 10/23/08 [Last modified: Monday, October 27, 2008 4:13pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. U.S. Rep. Charlie Crist and estranged wife Carole put Beach Drive condo on the market

    Real Estate

    ST. PETERSBURG — U.S. Rep. Charlie Crist and his estranged wife, Carole, have put their Beach Drive condo on the market for $1.5 million.

    Former Florida Gov. and current U.S. Rep. Charlie Crist and his estranged wife, Carole, have put their condo in downtown St. Petersburg on the market for $1.5 million. [Courtesy of Rhonda Sanderford]
  2. First WannaCry, now cyberattack Petya spreads from Russia to Britain


    Computer systems from Russia to Britain were victims of an international cyberattack Tuesday in a hack that bore similarities to a recent one that crippled tens of thousands of machines worldwide.

    A computer screen cyberattack warning notice reportedly holding computer files to ransom, as part of a massive international cyberattack, at an office in Kiev, Ukraine, on Tuesday.  A new and highly virulent outbreak of malicious data-scrambling software appears to be causing mass disruption across Europe.
[Oleg Reshetnyak via AP]
  3. Higher Social Security payouts help Florida post a big jump in personal income

    Personal Finance

    Personal income grew 1.3 percent in Florida in the first quarter of this year, a four-way tie among all states for second-fastest growth behind Idaho.

  4. Trigaux: Task now is for Water Street Tampa to build an identity


    Adios, VinikVille! Hello Water Street Tampa.

    An aerial rendering of the $3 billion redevelopment project that Jeff Vinik and Strategic Property Partners plan on 50-plus acres around Amalie Arena.
[Rendering courtesy of Strategic Property Partners]