Make us your home page

Florida still losing ground in wages despite uptick in jobs

The drop in Florida unemployment masks a troubling trend: The new jobs continue to pay far less than the ones that have been lost.

The state added 114,000 jobs last year. But the bulk of them paid on average about 25 percent less than the jobs that disappeared, according to a Tampa Bay Times analysis of jobs and industry wage data.

Count Tampa resident Russ Muncy among the victims.

He enjoyed a successful 30-year career in civil engineering, despite the lack of a college degree, and was earning more than $75,000 a year when he lost his job in 2009.

Since then, Muncy has exhausted his unemployment benefits and finances during a fruitless job search. He has headed back to college, while only able to find a part-time job in the service industry to help cover expenses.

"It's close to minimum wage. It should be a lot higher, naturally," said Muncy, now 64. "There are a lot of people that are just taking advantage of people looking for work, so they bring them in at a low wage."

Wage deflation has been a recurring theme in the wake of the Great Recession.

A year ago, the Times performed a similar exercise comparing wages for jobs created versus wages for jobs lost across major industries in 2010.

Back then, the state was still losing more jobs than it was adding. But the pay differential told a similar tale: Average wages of new jobs were 31 percent lower than jobs that had disappeared.

The economic recovery grew and broadened during 2011. Florida created 10 times more jobs than it lost, and in a bright sign some higher-paying industries like financial services and manufacturing started hiring again.

Nevertheless, many of the new jobs are still clustered in the low-wage spectrum: retail clerks, theme park workers and restaurant help.

And which industries are still losing jobs? The big three are government, construction and information — all industries that pay annual wages north of $40,000 on average.

The situation is a sharp departure from prerecession Florida, when then-Gov. Jeb Bush led the charge to bring high-tech, high-paying jobs to the state. At the time, call center jobs were being vilified. These days, they're celebrated.

Lower-paying industries are dominating job creation, and many of the new jobs are in lower-paid occupations within those industries, according to a report in July by the National Employment Law Project, a worker advocacy group.

Occupations that saw the biggest growth nationally between the first quarter of 2010 and 2011 were in retail sales (median hourly wage of $10.72); office clerks (hourly wage of $13.21); and cashiers (hourly wage of $8.83).

Occupations that saw the biggest losses in the same time span were managers (median hourly wage of $28.30), computer scientists and system analysts (hourly wage of $29.15) and human resources and training (hourly wage of $21.71).

The National Employment Law Project hasn't crunched 2011 numbers yet to see if the wage discrepancy persisted nationwide throughout the year, either by occupation or industry. But Christine Riordan, a policy analyst with the group, believes the difference may not be as great as a year ago simply because more higher-paying industries have begun adding jobs.

The country closed 2011 with a net gain of construction jobs, for example.

Yet, even the re-emergence of dormant, historically higher-paying industries is no guarantee that wages will bounce back, not in an environment of 8.3 percent national unemployment where employers still hold more cards than employees.

Consider new hires within the auto industry. Amid union concessions and financial pressures, "entry-level wages are literally half of what they were prerecession," Riordan said. "Instead of $20 an hour, it's now $14."

The same thing is happening on a local level.

Muncy, the civil engineer, said he has seen the county hire back some long-idled contractors for road projects, but they're receiving less money.

"They've lowered the starting pay. They'll have a pay range, but anyone hired goes in at the lowest amount," he said. "I don't blame them, to tell the truth. That's just the way business works."

Rick Joudrey of Lutz has already learned that lesson.

Joudrey, 57, used to earn about $200,000 a year designing and building communities before being laid off in 2008.

He sold real estate for a while during his three-year job search. After "a couple thousand resumes," he finally landed a promising job four months ago with a site development company, though the pay is roughly half of what he used to make and bonuses are gone.

"I felt the growth of the company and the position itself justified the reduced salary," he said. "You have to think that way these days. A job is a job."

Jeff Harrington can be reached at (727) 893-8242 or

Florida is adding more jobs …


Jobs added

in 2011
Leisure and hospitality$21,44730,400
Private education/health services$43,68627,300
Professional and business services$49,18515,200
Financial activities$57,0428,700
Other services$29,6091,600

Total jobs added: 126,000

Average wage: $38,148

… But they pay about 25 percent less than the jobs lost


Jobs lost

in 2011
Total government$47,3617,900

Total jobs lost: 12,300

Average wage: $50,761

Wage discrepancy: $12,613

Sources: Florida Department of Economic Opportunity, December 2010 to December 2011 data; Times research

Florida still losing ground in wages despite uptick in jobs 02/05/12 [Last modified: Sunday, February 5, 2012 11:33pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. PunditFact: George Will's comparison of tax preparers, firefighters based on outdated data


    The statement

    "America has more people employed as tax preparers (1.2 million) than as police and firefighters."

    George Will, July 12 in a column

    The ruling

    WASHINGTON - JANUARY 08: Conservative newspaper columnist George Will poses on the red carpet upon arrival at a salute to FOX News Channel's Brit Hume on January 8, 2009 in Washington, DC. Hume was honored for his 35 years in journalism. (Photo by Brendan Hoffman/Getty Images)
  2. Appointments at Shutts & Bowen and Tech Data highlight this week's Tampa Bay business Movers & Shakers



    Retired U.S. Navy Commander Scott G. Johnson has joined Shutts & Bowen LLP in its Tampa office as a senior attorney in the firm's Government Contracts and Corporate Law Practice Groups. Johnson brings 15 years of legal experience and 24 years of naval service to his position. At Shutts, Scott will …

    United States Navy Commander (Retired) Scott G. Johnson joins Shutts & Bowen LLP in its Tampa office. [Company handout]
  3. Macy's chairman replaces ex-HSN head Grossman on National Retail Federation board


    Terry Lundgren, chairman of Macy's Inc., will replace Weight Watchers CEO Mindy Grossman as chair of the National Retail Federation, the organization announced Wednesday. Grossman stepped down from her position following her move from leading St. Petersburg-based HSN to Weight Watchers.

    Weight Watchers CEO and former HSN chief Mindy Grossman is being replaced as chair of the National Retail Federation. [HSN Inc.]
  4. Unexpected weak quarter at MarineMax slashes boating retailer shares nearly 25 percent


    CLEARWATER — Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the water, a boating business leader issued a small craft warning.

    Bill McGill Jr., CEO of Clearwater's MarineMax, the country's biggest recreational boat retailer. [Courtesy of MarineMax]
  5. CapTrust moving headquarters to downtown Park Tower


    TAMPA — CAPTRUST Advisors, a Raleigh, N.C.-based investment consulting firm, is moving its Tampa offices into Park Tower. CapTrust's new space will be 10,500 square feet — the entirety of the 18th floor of the downtown building, which is scheduled to undergo a multi-million-dollar renovation by 2018.

    CAPTRUST Advisors' Tampa location is moving into Park Tower. Pictured is the current CapTrust location at 102 W. Whiting St. | [Times file photo]