Make us your home page
Working | Hiring

Job prospects remain grim for 2011

The jobs being created tend to be concentrated in mid- and low-wage industries, such as health care, food service and retail, according to the National Employment Law Project, a policy and advocacy group.

The jobs being created tend to be concentrated in mid- and low-wage industries, such as health care, food service and retail, according to the National Employment Law Project, a policy and advocacy group.

CHICAGO — More than a year after the recession officially ended, millions of unemployed people continue hunting for jobs that don't exist and likely won't be there in 2011.

Though the number of jobs will continue to increase, economists say, companies are not hiring fast enough to bring down the unemployment rate, which is likely to hover above 9 percent.

"We are not going to see the kind of gains we should be seeing, given the losses we already endured," said Diane Swonk, chief economist at Mesirow Financial.

It's a grim outlook for people like William Gardner, who has been unemployed for nearly two years.

Gardner and his wife have gotten by on his biweekly $820 unemployment check — about $50,000 less per year than he used to earn. To make do, the couple have cut back. But some months, keeping current on their $870 mortgage requires going deeper into debt, he said.

"It's a numbers game," said Gardner, a former district sales manager at a beverage distribution company. "I apply to 30 to 40 jobs a week. I just need one job; I just got to keep going."

Recently, Gardner, 53, made it to the final round of interviews at a Detroit-based company. A few days after he returned home, he was told the company had decided to hire from within.

"What do you do? You kill yourself, or you rob a bank? … You pray to God," Gardner said.

In October, there were 3.4 million job openings, roughly one job for every 4.4 unemployed workers, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

To see a rapid decline in the unemployment rate, Swonk said companies would need to hire more than 500,000 people a month — a big jump from the 39,000 jobs added in November.

"But nobody is holding their breath on that," said Swonk, adding that a more realistic estimate puts job creation at 150,000 to 250,000 jobs a month.

The jobs being created tend to be concentrated in mid- and low-wage industries, such as health care, food service and retail, according to the National Employment Law Project, a policy and advocacy group.

"Those are also sectors where there are often real problems with job quality, not enough work benefits, not enough opportunities for promotion," said Annette Bernhardt, the project's policy co-director.

Last year, about 76 percent of the jobs added by the private sector paid less than $15 per hour, Bernhardt wrote in a report. In contrast, nearly half the jobs lost in 2008-09 paid more than $17.43 per hour.

"It's hard to see how we are going to rebuild an economy when disproportionate numbers of workers are stuck in low-wage jobs," Bernhardt said. "What is at stake is whether we are going to rebuild the type of consumption and consumers that the economy needs to recover."

Some skilled workers have already sought refuge in low-wage industries, blocking people with lesser skills from entry-level jobs.

Darryl McClung, an unemployed janitor, is an example. At the Chicago soup kitchen where he is a volunteer, McClung keeps a folded resume in his wallet and a black binder in his backpack with letters and cards from businesses where he has applied for janitorial jobs. He wants to be ready when he gets the call, but he's been out of work for five months, and he's getting desperate.

"I have skills — not on paper — but I do have skills," said McClung, 50.

Nearby, Kurt Jagade scrubbed a plastic tablecloth as other volunteers mopped, picked up trash and tidied up. The aroma of chili lingered in the air.

In July, Jagade, 32, moved back to his native Chicago from North Carolina, where he had been making $10.64 an hour as a government worker fixing roads and driving dump trucks. His uncle said he could get him a factory job for $13 an hour, so Jagade jumped at the opportunity. Two days after he got to the city, the factory closed.

Since then, Jagade said, he hasn't been able to land another job. With a wife and two children to support, Jagade sought help from the state and volunteered at the soup kitchen in exchange for $360 a month in food stamps.

"I left what little I had, but I have nothing now," he said.

For some veterans, the lack of jobs makes it even harder to transition to civilian life after years in the military.

On a recent Friday, a group of about 15 veterans met in downtown Chicago for a daylong job training and networking event.

After 21 years in the Navy, where she specialized in electronics and communications, Mary Madden retired in 2003. She went back to school to finish her bachelor's degree and landed a job as a basic electronics instructor at Naval Station Great Lakes in North Chicago.

She held that job until September, when the company that employed her lost the contract, and she was laid off. Now she finds she doesn't qualify to teach at the college level. Most colleges, she said, require a master's degree.

"I call it the circle," said Madden, 48. To pay for the master's degree, she needs a job, and to get the job she needs the degree.

At the same networking event, Airen Jackson, a construction manager who has been unemployed for about two years, fiddled with his phone as a speaker talked about the importance of mailing thank-you cards after job interviews.

Jackson's job search has proven difficult, he said, in part because he has 15 years of experience but no degree. He is working toward a bachelor's in business and taking prelaw classes.

"I wasn't prepared for this," Jackson said.

Lots of people weren't prepared for the impact the recession has had on entire industries. Andrew Stettner, deputy director of the National Employment Law Project, said the slow recovery makes people wonder if their old jobs and industries will return and, if not, whether they should change careers.

Unfortunately, he said, it's unclear which industries will add employees in the next year.

"I think it's harder than ever to point to where people need to be training, where people need to be going," Stettner said.

What complicates the situation further, Swonk said, is that as companies begin to hire, more than 1 million people who gave up looking for a job will likely start looking again. When they do, they will find more people applying for the same jobs.

"As you start to see (the economy) recover, it feels like one step forward and two steps back, even though we actually are moving forward and generating jobs," she said.

Perplexing to Daniel Mitchell, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, a think tank, is that the economy isn't following patterns he's seen in the past.

"Normally when you have a recession, the economy has a very strong bounce-back and we recover all the lost economic output," Mitchell said. "Well, we are not having a strong bounce-back. We haven't even climbed back up to our average growth rate."

Meanwhile, the impact of the economy is played out at places like the Elijah Food Pantry at St. Luke's Lutheran Church in Chicago's Logan Square neighborhood. Dea Checchin, director of the food pantry, said she gives bags with fresh vegetables, cheese, soup cans and meat to about 600 people a month, double the number before the recession.

Yet, as more people seek help, donations continue to decline, Checchin said. Even the "rich churches," she said, have started food pantries, leaving her scrambling for more donors.

"So far the pantry is in the black, but it's getting scary," she said.

Job prospects remain grim for 2011 01/15/11 [Last modified: Monday, November 7, 2011 1:55pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Chicago Tribune.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Housing starts fall in July

    Real Estate

    WASHINGTON — The Commerce Department said Wednesday that housing starts fell 4.8 percent in July to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.16 million. Groundbreakings for multi-family buildings such as apartments slumped 17.1 percent, while single-family house construction slipped 0.5 percent.

    On Wednesday, the Commerce Department reported on U.S. home construction in July. 
[AP file photo]
  2. Pasco doubles tourist tax to finance sports complex


    DADE CITY — Pasco County is doubling its tourist tax to 4 percent to build an indoor sports complex in Wesley Chapel and improve its outdoor boat ramps in west Pasco.

    Pasco County's plan to double its tourist tax on overnight accommodations to 4 percent is intended to help finance a $25 million sports complex in the Wiregrass Ranch area of Wesley Chapel. It  would include a 98,000-quare-foot multipurpose gymnaisium of eight basketball courts and dedicated space for gymnastics, cheerleading and a fitness center. Shown here is the four-court fieldhouse with 50,000-square-feet of space for competitions at  Disney's Wide World of Sports Complex.  Times photo by James Borchuck (2007)
  3. USAA expansion at Crosstown Center may bring Hillsborough 1,000 more jobs


    BRANDON — USAA will bring as many as 1,000 more jobs to Hillsborough County in early 2019 with the expansion of its existing operations in Brandon.

    Stuart Parker, president and chief executive officer of USAA, speaks at the company's new Crosstown Center location in Brandon during a visit following its 2015 opening. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD   |   Times, 2016]
  4. FHP bids for pay raise a week after disastrous publicity


    TALLAHASSEE — This is real bad timing.

    FHP license plate.
  5. Rhetoric over: Three-nation effort to revise NAFTA begin


    WASHINGTON — Of all the trade deals he lambasted on the campaign trail as threats to American workers, President Donald Trump reserved particular scorn for one: The North American Free Trade Agreement.

    Claudio Montes checks a shipping manifest for U.S. manufactured parts heading to assembly plants in Mexico at Freight Dispatch Service Agency LTD in Pharr, Texas, in June. The freight service ships parts between the U.S. and Mexico that pass through the border freely due to the North American Free Trade Agreement. Of all the trade deals he lambasted on the campaign trail as threats to American workers, President Donald Trump reserved particular scorn for one: NAFTA. [Nathan Lambrecht | The Monitor via AP]