Make us your home page
Working | Still unemployed

Jobless vilified as economy improves

ORLANDO — These are hard times for the unemployed. • There are few jobs, competition is fierce and, now, there is a rising sense that if you don't have job, you must be lazy, incompetent or both. • "I think quite a few are content to sit back and take a handout," said Tom Johnson, a plumbing-parts salesman from Orlando. "I'm sure they could find something if they wanted to." • A similar sentiment is drifting through legislative bodies. Federal lawmakers are increasingly resistant to extending unemployment benefits, and Florida Gov. Rick Scott's economic-transition team recently suggested the jobless aren't looking hard enough.

In January, Florida state Sen. Nancy Detert, a Republican, instructed state unemployment officials to more closely scrutinize those applying for benefits.

"We'd like your department," she said, "to, you know, get rid of slackers and malingerers."

The comments sting many unemployed Floridians, who resent the notion that they are sitting at home collecting checks and watching soap operas. They say their days are filled with phone calls, job searches, resume work and anxiety.

Critics who portray them as indolent and unwilling to work, they say, don't understand how weak the labor market is.

"I go to all the job (web)sites every day; I drop off resumes in person, knowing they probably won't get past the front desk," said Denise Scala, a 50-year-old office manager laid off about nine months ago. "I've looked constantly and just haven't found anything."

Scala was making about $48,000 a year when she was let go from the real estate firm where she worked. Since then, she has told employers she is willing to work for less but is invariably turned away as "overqualified."

The label plagues many workers in the middle of their careers.

"To me, it's irrelevant," Scala said. "I just want to work."

Scala's mother, Joan, has sharper words for those questioning her daughter's work ethic.

"They have some nerve," she said.

Estimates vary, but nationally, unemployed workers now outnumber open jobs by about 4-to-1 or 5-to-1.

Arthur Rosenberg, an attorney and advocate for the unemployed, said he is concerned a "blame the victim" mentality is taking shape as the economy slowly improves. People who weren't laid off who read or hear that the worst is over wonder why anyone needs a year or 18 months to find work.

Certainly there are people abusing the system, but most unemployed, said Rosenberg, are desperate for a job. The layoffs were so deep, he said, that they went well beyond marginal workers, cutting loose solid performers who never had trouble finding work in the past.

"It's not that people aren't doing what they're supposed to do," said Rosenberg, of Florida Legal Services. "The problem is there just aren't many jobs right now."

He and others also point out that unemployment is not welfare; it's insurance. Eligibility is determined by work history, and those who haven't worked aren't entitled to it.

"The disaster has happened," he said, "and now these people need to collect."

But businesses and some officials are asking: "For how long?"

The jobless can collect benefits for a maximum of 99 weeks — not all are entitled to that — and already the state has borrowed $2 billion from the federal government to pay benefits. This year, Florida faces a $64 million interest payment that would be covered by raising the tax rate that employers pay to fund the system.

The minimum rate would jump from about $25 to $72 per employee. Businesses were looking at a similar rate increase last year, but they persuaded the Legislature to delay it. This year, they are lobbying for tighter eligibility requirements, tougher enforcement and a fundamental change in how benefits are viewed.

State law now requires that employees get the benefit of the doubt when a company challenges their right to receive unemployment. Eligibility is to be "liberally construed" in favor of the worker.

But Florida's business lobbies want to change "liberally construed" to "neutrally construed," saying the current system puts them at a disadvantage.

The unemployed and those who work with them claim the proposal is an attempt by businesses and some legislators to save money by making it harder to get benefits. Each new requirement, they argue, is another barrier to clear.

The message behind the push — that lazy workers are gaming the system — frustrates people such as Scala and Phyllis McCallister, an Orange County resident who has watched her husband and grandson struggle to find work in the wake of the Great Recession.

He husband, she said, has been hitting all the local hotels, looking for a job in operations or maintenance.

So far, he has had no luck.

"The idea that people aren't trying just isn't true," McCallister said. Critics, she said, need to "rethink what (they say) and not be so quick to judge."

Jobless vilified as economy improves 02/05/11 [Last modified: Saturday, February 5, 2011 3:31am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Orlando Sentinel.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Trumps travel ban to be replaced by restrictions tailored to certain countries


    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump's ban on travelers from six majority-Muslim countries is set to be replaced as soon as this weekend with more targeted restrictions on visits to the United States that would vary by country, the New York Times reports, citing officials familiar with the plans.

    President Donald Trump's ban on travelers from six majority-Muslim countries is set to be replaced as soon as this weekend with more targeted restrictions on visits to the United States that would vary by country, officials familiar with the plans said Friday. The new restrictions, aimed at preventing security threats from entering the United States, could go into effect Sunday after the conclusion of a 90-day policy review undertaken as part of the administration's original travel ban. Though the restrictions would differ for each country, people living in the targeted nations could be prevented from traveling to the United States or could face increased scrutiny as they seek to obtain a visa. [Associated Press]
  2. In dollars: How valuable are Florida's university football programs?


    The University of Florida football program is valued in a new study at $682 million, making it the most valuable university team in the state but still worth far less than several college programs topping $1 billion. Four years ago, UF's program was valued at just under $600 million.

    The University of Florida football program is valued at  $682 million, making it the most valuable by far in the Sunshine State. Pictured are UF cheerleaders leading the crowd in a Gator cheer on Clearwater Beach last December during the Outback Bowl Beach Day on Clearwater Beach. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]
  3. After 22 years, it's last call for beloved Ybor venue New World Brewery

    Music & Concerts

    YBOR CITY — Steve Bird spreads his tools across a patio table. He has awnings to unbolt and paraphernalia to unpry, from the busted Bop City neon by the stage to the Simpsons "El Duffo o Muerte" mural in the courtyard. He'll uproot a fountain and dismantle a roof and attempt to keep his bar intact. The …

    Various decor and memorabilia fill the walls and shelves at New World Brewery in Ybor City.
Long time music venue and hangout New World Brewery in Ybor City will be closing it's doors and moving locations. Patrons enjoy one of the last events before New World Brewery changes its location to Busch Blvd in Tampa.  [Photo Luis Santana | Times]
  4. Florida bought more Pasta Passes from Olive Garden than almost any other state

    Food & Dining

    Floridians would like their bowls of pasta to never, ever end.

    Florida was the No. 2 state with the largest number of Olive Garden Pasta Pass purchases, an unlimited pasta pass for $100. Photo courtesy Olive Garden.
  5. Trigaux: Tampa Bay household income tops $50,000 but still makes us look poor

    Personal Finance

    The good news is Tampa Bay's median household income finally crawled above $50,000 last year. The bad news is that figure — officially $51,115 by new U.S. Census Bureau data — still puts the Tampa Bay region as the poorest of the nation's 25 largest metro areas.

    Tampa Bay still has the lowest median household income among the 25 most populous metro areas, according to U.S. Census Bureau data.