Make us your home page

Nurse case challenges workers' compensation law change

Nearly five years ago, Emma Murray, a nurse in her late 50s, suffered an injury while hoisting a patient at the nursing home where she worked.

Her employer's workers' compensation insurance company denied her claim, chalking up her injury to a pre-existing condition. She hired Port Charlotte lawyer Brian Sutter and won $3,244 in back wages and medical costs.

Murray's case would have garnered little notice, except that it happened about a month after controversial revisions of Florida's workers' compensation went into effect. Sutter has appealed a provision that capped fees for lawyers hired by injured workers, and will argue Emma Murray vs. Mariner Health Care today before the Florida Supreme Court.

The legislation, completed during a special legislative session in 2003, fulfilled its promise to cut the bill that businesses pay for workers' compensation. But it also sharply limited fees for attorneys who fight for injured workers, leaving many workers with few attorneys willing to help them fight for lost wages and medical bills, Sutter said.

Sutter spent about 80 hours preparing Murray's case. His fee? Just $648, or about $8.10 an hour. Mariner's attorneys earned about $16,000, he said.

Sutter said the legislation gives insurers an unfair advantage, since insurers face no cap on attorneys fees. That gives insurers incentive to deny legitimate claims like Murray's, since few lawyers will take on complex and expensive cases for such meager fees.

"If you have a law that works like that, the insurers can do whatever they want," Sutter said.

Tamela Perdue, general council to Associated Industries of Florida, a pro-business lobbying group, disagreed. "I think the law is fine the way it is."

Premiums for workers' compensation have dropped by more than 50 percent since the law passed, she said. Associated Industries led a coalition of business and industry in support of Senate Bill 50A in 2003, she said. The group has also filed a friend of the court brief arguing against Sutter.

"Before this law was passed, Florida had the highest rates for workers' compensation insurance in the country," Perdue said. "Now, we have some of the lowest rates in the country, so businesses stay in business and workers continue to have jobs."

Asjylyn Loder can be reached at or
(813) 225-3117.

Nurse case challenges workers' compensation law change 04/08/08 [Last modified: Sunday, April 13, 2008 11:57am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Legalized medical marijuana signed into law by Rick Scott

    State Roundup

    TALLAHASSEE — Gov. Rick Scott on Friday signed into law a broader medical marijuana system for the state, following through on a promise he made earlier this month.

    Gov. Rick Scott signed legislation on Friday that legalizes medical marijuana in Florida.
  2. Line of moms welcome Once Upon A Child to Carrollwood


    CARROLLWOOD — Strollers of all shapes and sizes are lined up in front of the store, and inside, there are racks of children's clothing in every color of the rainbow.

    At Once Upon A Child, you often as many baby strollers outside as you find baby furniture and accessories. It recently opened this location in Carrollwood. Photo by Danielle Hauser
  3. Pastries N Chaat brings North India cuisine to North Tampa


    TAMPA — Pastries N Chaat, a new restaurant offering Indian street food, opened this week near the University of South Florida.

    The menu at Pastries N Chaat includes a large variety of Biriyani, an entree owners say is beloved by millions. Photo courtesy of Pastries N Chaat.
  4. 'Garbage juice' seen as threat to drinking water in Florida Panhandle county


    To Waste Management, the nation's largest handler of garbage, the liquid that winds up at the bottom of a landfill is called "leachate," and it can safely be disposed of in a well that's 4,200 feet deep.

    Three samples that were displayed by Jackson County NAACP President Ronstance Pittman at a public meeting on Waste Management's deep well injection proposal. The sample on the left is full of leachate from the Jackson County landfill, the stuff that would be injected into the well. The sample on the right shows leachate after it's been treated at a wastewater treatment plant. The one in the middle is tap water.
  5. Honda denies covering up dangers of Takata air bags


    With just a third of the defective Takata air bag inflators replaced nationwide, the corporate blame game of who will take responsibility — and pay — for the issue has shifted into another gear.

    Honda is denying covering up dangers of Takata air bags. | [Scott McIntyre, New York Times]