Chris Fargis thought his big job interview was over. But when the partners at Wall Street upstart Toro Trading finished with their questions, they broke out a deck of cards and a green-felt card table. Mind playing a few hands of poker?
It was a final test, and Fargis was relieved. The 30-year-old never went to business school or even took a finance class. But he knew poker. He had made a living playing the game online for six years from his Manhattan apartment, betting on up to eight hands at a time.
Within a few days, Fargis — with no Wall Street experience — was offered a position trading stock options, a job that entails making multimillion-dollar gambles. His poker skills sealed the deal.
"If someone's been successful at poker then there's a good chance they could be successful in this business," said Toro partner Danon Robinson. "If you have no interest, that's almost a red flag. . . . It's almost the equivalent of not reading the Wall Street Journal."
A new breed of traders
There's a part of Wall Street — investment banking in particular — that looks for recruits with sterling family connections and impeccable educations, and that favors sturdy young men and women who played college team sports such as lacrosse and rugby.
Toro Trading is not that Wall Street. Instead, it's one of the new breed of high-speed trading desks that are revolutionizing the financial markets, and making their money on the fractional gains from buying or selling a split-second ahead of their rivals.
They look for job candidates who are quick-thinking, have nerves of steel and a head for numbers — the very skills that lead to success in online poker.
"There's a certain maturity and ability to deal with risk that is hard to get any other way — unless you put the money on the table at some point in your life," said Aaron Brown, a hedge fund executive and author of the 2006 book The Poker Face of Wall Street.
Susquehanna International Group, a 1,500-employee trading firm based in a Philadelphia suburb, has made the card game a central part of its training program. New hires are given copies of The Theory of Poker and Hold 'Em Poker and spend one full day a week studying the game by playing it.
"We are trying to teach people how to be good decisionmakers under uncertainty," said Pat McCauley, who runs the training program. "It's not the stereotypical stuff with bluffing — it's real science."
The rising popularity of online poker has created, in effect, a huge farm team for Wall Street trading desks. Last year, 6.8 million people played at least one hand of online poker for money, up 29 percent from 2008 and nearly triple the number from 2005, according to research firm PokerAnalytics.com.
Wall Street's interest in poker players comes with a certain irony in the aftermath of a global financial crisis, which many blame on reckless risk-taking by big banks. The government's recent fraud lawsuit against Goldman Sachs targets just such behavior. And President Barack Obama has proposed limiting speculative trading by banks with their own money.
"There are many overwhelming, negative consequences associated with the Wall Street philosophical fixation on casino capitalism," said John Kindt, a University of Illinois business professor, citing the subprime mortgage meltdown and the derivatives deals that felled insurance giant American International Group.
Even so, gambling appears to be in Wall Street's DNA. The book Liar's Poker by Michael Lewis captures the heady days of the 1980s when cigar-chomping executives and bond traders at Salomon Bros. would challenge each other to million-dollar wagers during down times on the trading floor.
A new breed of players
Poker was popular among the Wall Street crowd of the '80s. The games of that era were clubby — and played in person. A talent for schmoozing was valued at least as much as ability, said Brown, who was a regular player. Poker then was more likely to lead to a job as a dealmaking investment banker than as a trader.
The fast-paced online poker games of today are a better proving ground for Wall Street's trading floors, which have long been places for unrefined upstarts and members of minority groups. Trading floors historically attracted loud characters with outsized desires, who made up for what they lacked in social skills and education with moxie.
A penchant for betting big is still more important than connections for a would-be trader. But insiders say the typical personality profile has shifted toward that of a math nerd who understands probability and algorithms — the type of person likely to succeed in online poker.
Adam Gilman, at AMR Capital Trading in New York, said young traders like him who honed their skills playing poker alone at home "are more analytical, less in-your-face macho meathead types."
The similarity in personalities reflects the parallels between poker and trading.
Internet poker players and traders both sit in front of multiple screens focusing on what they're holding and consider how to improve their positions.
A trader looks for a security selling for slightly more or less than it should be — then pounces. Similarly, a poker player constantly works through probabilities to determine when another player is betting more or less than makes sense given the cards on the table.
Losing is part of the game
Another important crossover skill: the ability to bounce back from big losses.
When poker players interview at Group One Trading's office in Chicago, the director of recruiting and risk management, Dave Seidman, asks about their worst day, not their best: "I ask, 'How long did it take you to play again?' I want him to say, 'I played the next day; that's just part of the game.' "
For players with these abilities, moving to Wall Street can mean a pay cut, at least in the short term.
A talented online poker player can pull down well into six figures, players say. Gilman, at AMR Capital, said he made as much as $550,000 a year playing poker.
Traders typically start with a base salary of only about $80,000, albeit supplemented by comparatively large bonuses.
But poker winnings pale next to Wall Street's huge profit potential.
"Our traders put up millions of dollars in real money on a daily basis," said Noah Minetz, 22, who played poker while attending the University of Illinois before he joined Group One late last year. "It's unlimited higher stakes and unlimited potential. Poker's cool, but it's not that."
For Fargis, in addition to the money, there are the normal working hours and the camaraderie that he never got playing poker alone at home. He has co-workers at Toro to talk to — and make bets with.
One recent morning, his colleagues smiled when he walked into the office. "It's good you're here because we're about to get a bet on," one said. The wager: whether one of the firm's partners could eat a banana split in less than a minute.
Fargis pondered the odds and decided he liked them. A few minutes later, after the banana split was consumed, the former professional gambler was, once again, right on the money.