Tuesday, July 17, 2018
Business

When recruiters disappear

Question 1: Twice I was recruited for positions and had background checks and interviews with the hiring managers. The recruiter in each case — one with the company, one an outside contractor — assured me that the position was mine. I was given a salary and a start date and told to wait for an offer letter.

Then, nothing. When I tried to call or email the recruiters and hiring managers, I was met with deafening silence. I never did find out why these offers, if they were real offers, were pulled at the last minute.

Question 2: I recently answered a job ad and was contacted by the company's recruiting department. The recruiter discussed the job and set an interview for me to meet the hiring manager. Early in the interview, the manager told me there was not a job opening — they just wanted potential candidates for their "pipeline."

When I followed up with the recruiter, he appeared genuinely surprised and said that as far as he knew, there was an open position. After checking with his company, he informed me that the company was continuing its search to fill the position. Since then, he will not answer my emails or phone calls, and neither will the employer's HR department.

Is this legal? The company continues to post this position online.

Answer: It is not clear — or relevant — whether the recruiters in these cases misunderstood or were misled by the employers. When a candidate is left hanging, both employer and recruiter come off looking unprofessional.

In Question 1's case, it's possible that both those offers fell through for any number of legitimate reasons — but the recruiters' and employers' failure to follow up at all was "unethical, troubling and wrong," says Jeremy Tolley, an HR executive with Tennessee-based health-care provider CareHere.

Several scenarios could apply in Question 2's case: Management didn't convey its "pipeline plan" to the recruiter; the recruiter liked the applicant, but the manager didn't; or the recruiter is omitting details to get bodies in the door — unprofessional, but not something you're likely to win a lawsuit over.

Going back to the employers themselves is the right call, if only to let them know that their recruiters may be doing harm to their image.

"Great places to work are concerned about their employment brand and want to do the right thing; they want to know if someone feels they have been subject to unethical treatment by recruiters or hiring managers," says Tolley.

Branding and best intentions aside, it's not unreasonable for employers to rely on recruiters to handle most interactions with job candidates. But for the arrangement to work, both parties must commit to clear communication with each other and with candidates, even when the news is bad.

• • •

Pro tip: In addition to researching recruiters on LinkedIn, you should be checking out the employers they represent on glassdoor.com, looking for complaints about shady hiring practices.

Ask Karla Miller about your work dramas and traumas by emailing [email protected]

Comments
Pinellas County Commission shows support for CrossBay Ferry

Pinellas County Commission shows support for CrossBay Ferry

CLEARWATER –– The ferry that once linked St. Petersburg and Tampa downtowns took one step closer to returning in November.While the Pinellas County Commission didn’t approve spending money to help pay for the CrossBay Ferry during a meeting Tuesday, ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Louisiana shipbuilder hopes to bring 1,000 jobs to Tampa shipyard through Coast Guard icebreaker program

Louisiana shipbuilder hopes to bring 1,000 jobs to Tampa shipyard through Coast Guard icebreaker program

TAMPA — Tampa Ship could welcome more than 1,000 new shipbuilding jobs if Louisiana-based Bollinger Shipyards wins a major contract to build up to six Coast Guard polar icebreakers.Bollinger could start staffing up at Tampa Ship, which has 62 acres a...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Robert Traurig, who helped build one of the world’s largest law firms, dies at 93

Robert Traurig, who helped build one of the world’s largest law firms, dies at 93

Robert Traurig helped build one of the largest law firms in the world and, in so doing, swept Miami-Dade County upward.Brickell Avenue skyscrapers. Open-air malls like Cocowalk in Coconut Grove. Residential communities on the edge of the Everglades. ...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Hard Rock announces new hotel in Ireland in 2020

Hard Rock announces new hotel in Ireland in 2020

Hard Rock International is expanding across the pond. The Seminole Tribe-owned casino and hotel chain announced Tuesday that it will open a Hard Rock Hotel Dublin in 2020, its first hotel in Ireland. It will partner with Irish hotel company Tifco Lim...
Updated: 8 hours ago
New Spring Hill funeral home offers dining, catering services for grieving families

New Spring Hill funeral home offers dining, catering services for grieving families

SPRING HILL — A new funeral home, in response to changing mores, is focused on serving the living, providing homelike conviviality and social amenities that reach beyond attention to death.Yvette and Jim Klausch, licensed funeral directors with 40 ye...
Published: 07/17/18
Want to live on Beeswax Lane? Tampa Bay developers strain to create new street names

Want to live on Beeswax Lane? Tampa Bay developers strain to create new street names

When Newland Communities began developing FishHawk Ranch in Hillsborough County two decades ago, naming streets wasn’t much of a problem."Literally, we would get out our list of Florida native bird names every time a new section came online," said Pa...
Published: 07/17/18
Florida nursing homes have enough staff, numbers show. But the state has shortages in other areas.

Florida nursing homes have enough staff, numbers show. But the state has shortages in other areas.

In most places across America, nursing homes are facing an acute shortage of workers to take care of the country’s growing population of aging and disabled patients. But not in Florida. A Kaiser Family Foundation report published this month found tha...
Published: 07/17/18
Blacks can afford far fewer rentals than Asians and whites, study shows

Blacks can afford far fewer rentals than Asians and whites, study shows

Black and Latino residents of the Tampa Bay area can afford far fewer rentals than Asians and whites can. According to Zillow, blacks can afford just 19 percent of available rentals and Latinos 20.7 percent. That compares to whites being able to affo...
Published: 07/17/18
Tampa Bay business: This is what Prime Day is like as an Amazon seller

Tampa Bay business: This is what Prime Day is like as an Amazon seller

Amazon doesn’t even give its sellers a headsup on which July day the mega online retailer is selecting for its biggest sale of the year, Prime Day. But out of her natural sponges workshop in Tarpon Springs, Theo Prodromitis knew to start getti...
Published: 07/17/18
Another hip hotel in St. Pete? Uptown residents like the idea, but fret about parking.

Another hip hotel in St. Pete? Uptown residents like the idea, but fret about parking.

ST. PETERSBURG — In the past few years, Michael Andoniades has turned two faded hotels — the Hollander and the Avalon — into two of St. Petersburg’s trendiest, most popular lodgings. So it is with mixed feelings that residents of the city’s Historic ...
Published: 07/17/18