Monday, December 11, 2017
Business

Your cost for Internet service just got trickier

You've heard that a major federal court just murdered the Internet. Or something. It's not really clear. People are shouting about "net neutrality," but that sounds more like a newfangled tennis term than anything else. What does it mean? Why should you care? If you're confused about net neutrality, we're here to help.

What is net neutrality?

It's mainly an idea about fairness. It says that no Internet service provider, or ISP, should be allowed to speed up, slow down or block Web traffic from getting to where you, the customer, want it to go.

Let's say you're trying to watch Netflix. In the next room, your spouse is checking email. A believer in net neutrality would say that your ISP should provide both of you with the same quality of service. Just because you're streaming a big video file and your partner is sending tiny packets of text doesn't give your ISP the right to modify your Internet experience.

Why would my ISP want to change that?

Running a network is expensive. Some believe that if you use more data, you should pay for it — in the same way that your utility company charges you for using more water or more electricity.

And companies that operate the networks are always looking for new ways to bring in revenue so that they can make more upgrades.

Okay, but my ISP doesn't do that now.

That's because, until last week, broadband companies were bound by a set of rules that banned them from treating your Netflix video and your partner's email differently. These rules were put in place in 2011 by the Federal Communications Commission.

So what happened this past week?

Those rules got nixed by three federal judges.

Why did that happen?

Verizon brought a lawsuit against the FCC's net neutrality rules, arguing that the agency didn't have the authority to regulate the broadband industry in this way.

No authority? Isn't that what the FCC is all about?

Well, the FCC does a lot of things. But one of the agency's unresolved questions is how much power it has to regulate ISPs, which fall into a different category from the traditional telephone companies the FCC also regulates.

And the FCC tried to do just that?

In a word, yes. The court said that the FCC was trying to apply what are known as "Title II" obligations to companies that are regulated under Title I of the Telecommunications Act, which is the law that created the FCC and gives it its powers. It used the wrong tool for the job. The court actually sided with the FCC on the whole idea of net neutrality, arguing that a ban on traffic discrimination would help keep the Internet an innovative place. But it ruled that the FCC had overstepped its legal authority in trying to do so.

What happens now?

Well, companies like Verizon will be free to experiment with new business models. That's good for Verizon, but potentially bad for consumers.

To return to the Netflix example, Verizon could charge you an additional fee for watching Netflix, on the grounds that you're using more data than you otherwise might if you were simply checking email, like your spouse. Or, more likely, it could demand that Netflix pay a fee to reach Verizon customers. Net­flix could then pass those added costs on to you.

Or Verizon and Netflix could team up, signing a deal that gives the video company preferential treatment over, say, its rival Hulu. If you wanted to watch Hulu instead of Netflix, it might cost you extra. Or perhaps Hulu wouldn't be available on Verizon at all.

These same dynamics could take hold beyond Internet video. Online gaming could become a premium privilege. So could doing academic research.

And ISPs would be free to mix and match these services however they wanted, perhaps creating a bundle of applications you could buy together as a package — much like you buy a cable package today that includes some channels but not others.

There are any number of possible outcomes in a world that's not bound by net neutrality. Consumers might get hurt by a regime that actively discriminates between different types of Internet traffic.

But the FCC isn't just going to roll over, right?

Probably not. Its chairman, Tom Wheeler, says he's looking at an appeal. There are a few choices for the FCC at this point. It can do nothing, which might be an attractive option given that net neutrality was something the last FCC chairman was really into and his successor merely inherited.

Another path would be for the FCC to ask the federal court for a rehearing. This would require a vote by all the judges of the court. If the court votes to rehear the case, it will involve a different set of judges who might be more sympathetic to the FCC's argument. It's like asking for a do-over, with the hope of better luck. There's some reason to think this could work; President Barack Obama has been working to add new judges to the D.C. Circuit Court, and assuming that Democratic nominees would be open to supporting a Democratic agenda at the FCC, net neutrality could sneak by that way.

Anything else the FCC might try?

It might attempt to redefine ISPs into the kind of telecom business that it has more authority to regulate. This process would involve moving ISPs from the Title I bucket to the Title II bucket. But that would be a pretty bold move, and it would attract a lot of criticism from Verizon and the other companies that opposed net neutrality in the first place.

Comments
Tampa: Hundreds protest Trump’s decision on Jerusalem

Tampa: Hundreds protest Trump’s decision on Jerusalem

TAMPA — Hundreds rallied near the University of South Florida on Friday night to protest President Donald Trump’s recent declaration that the United States will recognize the divided city of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel.The protest was organize...
Published: 12/08/17
Updated: 12/09/17

Duke outage leaves 7,700 without power near Pinellas Park

PINELLAS PARK — Up to 7,700 customers across Pinellas Park, Lealman and Kenneth City lost power in a Thursday night outage, according to Duke Energy.The outage impacted a cloverleaf-shaped area of customers, with pedals extending in the cardinal dire...
Published: 12/08/17
Express lanes set to open on Veterans. They’re free -- for now.

Express lanes set to open on Veterans. They’re free -- for now.

TAMPA — Drivers on the Veterans Expressway will gain an extra lane from Gunn Highway to Hillsborough Avenue starting Saturday.But there’s a catch: Once drivers enter the lane, they won’t be able to leave it — not until a designated exit about six mil...
Published: 12/08/17
St. Petersburg chamber of commerce charts ‘Grow Smarter’ economic development strategy

St. Petersburg chamber of commerce charts ‘Grow Smarter’ economic development strategy

Times Staff WriterST. PETERSBURG — What started more than five years ago as an exploratory conversation among a handful of business leaders blossomed Friday into a full-blown community discussion of how to nurture business while working to make sure ...
Published: 12/08/17
Visit St. Pete/Clearwater makes Orlando tourists a top target

Visit St. Pete/Clearwater makes Orlando tourists a top target

In a decision driven by some major data crunching, Visit St. Pete/Clearwater next year will focus its tourism advertising on three target markets: Orlando, New York City and its Tampa Bay home."Research is going to dictate our behaviors and direction...
Published: 12/08/17
Having JW Marriott run Water Street Tampa’s new 519-room hotel expected to help Tampa pursue more upscale conventions

Having JW Marriott run Water Street Tampa’s new 519-room hotel expected to help Tampa pursue more upscale conventions

TAMPA — JW Marriott, a luxury hotel brand new to Tampa, will run the new 519-room hotel that the Water Street Tampa project is building next to the Marriott Waterside Hotel & Marina, developers announced Friday.Construction on the 26-story hotel is ...
Published: 12/08/17

Gravel spill shuts down parts of northbound Howard Frankland Bridge

TAMPA — Authorities are cleaning up a load of gravel spilled onto the northbound Howard Frankland Bridge on Friday afternoon, shutting down at least two lanes of traffic.The incident was reported at 2 p.m. on the stretch of the bridge drivers approac...
Published: 12/08/17
A longer wait: Some now try nearly 3 years to get disability insurance

A longer wait: Some now try nearly 3 years to get disability insurance

By the time Teralyn Fleming could finally plead her case to get federal disability insurance, she had been waiting two years and three months. The wait was not a peaceful one — a blood clotting disorder pushed her out of the workforce in 2015 ...
Published: 12/08/17
Why has bitcoin’s price shot up so fast?

Why has bitcoin’s price shot up so fast?

SAN FRANCISCO — Bitcoin has been in a bull market like few the world has ever seen.At the beginning of the year, the price of a bitcoin was below $1,000. It hit $5,000 in October, then doubled by late November. And on Thursday, less than two weeks la...
Published: 12/08/17
U.S. employers added 228,000 jobs in November, unemployment rate stays at 4.1 percent

U.S. employers added 228,000 jobs in November, unemployment rate stays at 4.1 percent

WASHINGTON — U.S. employers added a robust 228,000 jobs in November, a sign of the job market’s enduring strength in its ninth year of economic recovery. The unemployment rate remained at a 17-year low of 4.1 percent, the Labor Department reported F...
Published: 12/08/17