Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Caring for homeless helps Canada hold down health care costs

Dr. Jeffrey Turnbull checks a homeless man at a Salvation Army shelter in Ottawa. Medical care at shelters for alcoholics, drug abusers and street people helps keep them out of hospitals.


Dr. Jeffrey Turnbull checks a homeless man at a Salvation Army shelter in Ottawa. Medical care at shelters for alcoholics, drug abusers and street people helps keep them out of hospitals.

OTTAWA — "Hey, doc!''

Dr. Jeffrey Turnbull pivots around, coming face to face with a man with bloodshot eyes and boozy breath.

"Hey, doc,'' the man repeats. "You now what my medication is? Drink as much as I can!''

Both laugh heartily, and Turnbull gives him a friendly slap on the back. This is not a place for the prudish.

It is a weekday morning in Ottawa, Canada's capital, and Turnbull has just arrived at a Salvation Army shelter for the homeless, one of three he will visit this day. The shelters are part of a program that is saving millions of dollars by keeping homeless drunks and drug addicts out of the hospital.

"Before we started, some of these people would have been in the emergency room daily,'' says Turnbull, chief of staff at Ottawa's largest hospital.

As Congress wrestles with health care reform, much attention has been focused on Canada's system of universal coverage. Even the poorest of the nation's 33 million citizens are entitled to doctor visits and hospital care at government expense.

Canada spends 10 percent of its gross domestic product on health care, compared with 15 percent in the United States. However, Canadian health care costs are soaring as the population ages. Hence the push for money-saving programs like Ottawa's Inner City Health Care, largely funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health.

"Both the Canadian and American systems have trouble getting care for the poor, the disabled and the psychiatric,'' Turnbull says, "but I think the organization and delivery of care is easier when you have a public system.''

• • •

Turnbull, an internist who bears a slight resemblance to comedian Robin Williams, makes the shelter rounds twice a week.

The first stop is a place almost unimaginable in the United States — a hospice for the homeless. He steps into a small but sunny room where Dr. Tara Tucker strokes the shriveled arm of a 56-year-old musician with a long history of drug abuse. Esophageal cancer has spread to his abdomen.

"There's a real shift in him,'' Tucker reports. "He doesn't seem as anxious.''

"I think he's becoming more accepting of what's going on,'' Turnbull says.

"The thing we might not be adequately managing right now is the confusion,'' the other doctor continues. "We're thinking of adding a dose of Haldol,'' which is used to treat delirium.

Turnbull nods in agreement and moves on to an 80-year-old chronic alcoholic. His children, gathered around the bed, say he has become increasingly listless.

"I think it's always a good idea to have him sit up as much as he can,'' Turnbull tells the family.

After helping another dying man open a container of chocolate pudding, Turnbull heads to the Salvation Army shelter. Stuck to the wall are these notices:



"We give them clean crack pipes,'' Turnbull says, "because we know that sharing pipes can cause them to contract hepatitis C.''

Canada's controversial pipe-and-needle exchange programs started in 1989 in Vancouver, where addicts are permitted to inject at a supervised site. The city of Ottawa never sanctioned injections but even the pipe exchange was too much for city councillors, who killed the program in 2007. It has continued with funding from the Ontario government.

Everyone at the Salvation Army is up and about, though several flock to Turnbull with minor ailments. For a severely abscessed toe he prescribes a drug that normally costs $500; there is no charge to the sufferer, who is covered under Ontario's prescription drug program for the disabled, low income and people 65 and older.

Others complain of generalized pain. Some of the shelter's denizens have been hooked on powerful opiates like OxyContin and clearly want more.

"If you're looking for long-term narcotics,'' Turnbull tells one, "I'm not your man.''

For most of those he treats, Turnbull can bill the Ontario Health Insurance Plan. He donates the money to the Inner City program so it can help more clients and buy over-the-counter drugs, which are not covered by the government. Turnbull prescribes one — Sinutab — for a barrel-chested man with a scraggly ponytail.

"I really appreciate the help you give me, doc,'' he says. "Really.''

• • •

The final stop is a shelter that runs Ottawa's Managed Alcohol Program, currently caring for 25 chronically homeless drunks.

From 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. participants get precisely 5 ounces of wine every hour. It sounds like a staggering amount.

"That's about one-ninth of what they would take on the street,'' Turnbull says.

Indeed, no one looks or acts drunk. Several have been detoxed to the point where they go fishing, have pizza parties and work odd jobs around the shelter or at a nearby church. One, a talented Aboriginal artist, even has an agent and write-ups in the local paper.

As he mingles easily with what many would consider the dregs of Canadian society, Turnbull, 58, is at the peak of his own profession.

Next year he takes over as president of the 68,000-member Canadian Medical Association. Unlike some of his predecessors, who advocated a bigger role for private insurance as in the United States, Turnbull is firmly committed to government-funded universal coverage.

"I think his election (as association president) symbolizes in many ways the split within Canadian medicine about our system,'' says Dr. Michael Rachlis of Toronto, an expert on health care policy. "He's more the wave of the future as younger physicians who've grown up with the system are trying to figure out how to make it better rather than how to get rid of it.''

The Inner City program saved an estimated $3.5 million last year by keeping street people out of the hospital. But in Canada's egalitarian system some do end up there, including one Turnbull fondly recalls.

"It was a charming transvestite named Mandy. She was having trouble with her hair, and the nurses just loved doing her hair and her nails. There was a politician in the next bed ringing the bell and saying, 'I can't get any service!' "

Susan Taylor Martin can be reached at

Caring for homeless helps Canada hold down health care costs 07/19/09 [Last modified: Sunday, July 26, 2009 10:46pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. PolitiFact Florida: Claim that 5.7 million noncitizens voted is wrong

    State Roundup

    President Donald Trump's unfounded allegations that millions voted illegally in 2016 is back in the news, with his supporters pointing to a new analysis that claims millions of undocumented immigrants voted in 2008.

    Instances of noncitizens voting have been reported, but evidence points to a small number among millions of votes cast.  
  2. For Fourth of July, an American feast inspired by founding father Alexander Hamilton


    Are there a million things you haven't done? Is one of them throwing a patriotic party inspired by one of the founding fathers?

    Caribbean Pork With Potato Salad makes for the perfect Fourth of July meal.
  3. 'Baby Driver' literally turns heist movie genre on its ear, set to slick soundtrack


    Buckle up for Baby Driver, a movie so full throttle cool that you want to fist bump the screen. Style is the substance of Edgar Wright's inventive heist flick, a fresh, masterful synching of music and getaway mayhem, as if La La Land's traffic jam was moving, armed and dangerous.

    Baby (Ansel Elgort) is a getaway driver for heist arranger Doc (Kevin Spacey). Plagued by tinnitus, Baby tunes out his distracting “hum in the drum” by listening to music while he drives.
Sony Pictures
  4. Former mayor Rick Baker, left, is challenging incumbent Mayor Rick Kriseman, right, to become St. Petersburg mayor
  5. Life after HB7069 to be discussed at Pinellas school district workshop


    The Pinellas County school district is still trying to navigate life after the controversial passage of HB7069.