Saturday, August 18, 2018
News Roundup

Column: The myth of abortion regret

Many state laws regulating abortion are premised on the notion that having an abortion is a uniquely agonizing decision. Seventeen states require women to receive counseling beforehand, where they receive information on topics including fetal pain and the long-term mental health effects of abortion on women. More than half of all states mandate a waiting period between counseling and the procedure. And 10 require abortion providers to perform an ultrasound on every woman seeking an abortion and then offer her the chance to view the image.

The logic is obvious, if unstated: Women seeking abortions need extra time, extra information and extra guidance before they are allowed to make up their minds on a difficult quandary. As a conservative legal aid group defending Florida's 24-hour waiting period put it recently, "Including such a period of reflection before choosing a decision with serious long-term consequences is critically important." Even abortion rights groups like Planned Parenthood and NARAL Pro-Choice America often refer to abortion as "a difficult decision." Hillary Clinton has called it a "personal, difficult" choice.

A study published Thursday in the journal Conception, however, suggests that most women who seek abortions are really quite sure of themselves, thank you very much. Using an established scale devised to measure uncertainty around health care decisions, researchers from the University of California at San Francisco found that women seeking abortions are at least as confident as women making choices about breast cancer treatments, antidepressant use during pregnancy, and invasive prenatal testing. The new findings "directly challenge the narrative that decision-making on abortion is somehow exceptional," the study's lead author, epidemiologist Lauren Ralph, said. "And it calls into question whether women would universally benefit" from restrictions such as waiting periods and mandatory counseling services.

Ralph and her co-authors surveyed 500 women seeking abortions at four clinics in Utah, a state that mandates a 72-hour waiting period before the procedure. The women filled out a survey before they met with anyone at the clinic, with questions about things such as whether they feel pressured in their decision and whether they understand the benefits and risks of each option. The women were also asked about common myths about abortion, such as the notion that it causes breast cancer (it doesn't) or that childbirth is safer than abortion (it's not, and they're both very safe).

Ralph and her co-authors used a 16-point measure called the Decisional Conflict Scale, which is used widely by researchers and providers to assess attitudes toward decisions related to health care. The scale can be applied to any kind of patient facing just about any kind of medical procedure. It is designed to measure things such as a patient's uncertainty, her clarity about the benefits and risks that are important to her, and whether she has a support system and is well-informed about the procedure in question. Since the Decisional Conflict Scale is used to study a variety of decisions related to health care, the results could be directly compared with patients' certainty about other kinds of medical procedures.

Almost 90 percent of women agreed with the statement, "I feel sure about what to choose."

None of this means the decision to have an abortion is uncomplicated, of course. Slightly more than half of the women in Ralph's survey agreed that the decision was "easy"; less than 30 percent disagreed. (Previous research suggests that more than half of women who get an abortion report afterward that the decision was difficult.) But almost 90 percent of the women in the new study agreed with the statement, "I feel sure about what to choose."

It's not surprising that some women experience hesitation before an abortion or anguish afterward. For one, there's a vocal activist community backed by religious authorities insisting that abortion is murder. But aside from that, the question of whether or not to have a baby is the ultimate road not traveled. Of course women reflect on those choices and wonder what might have been. And many women who experience post-partum depression struggle with feelings of regret, too. What if I didn't have the baby? What if I did? Would things be easier then, or happier? The pain of these questions lies in their unknowability. But there's no reason that women need extra hand-holding from the government in order to work through these "personal, difficult" — or not-so-difficult — choices.

Slate

Comments
Preseason football: Hillsborough 29, East Lake 23

Preseason football: Hillsborough 29, East Lake 23

TAMPA — When moving on to your third football program in four seasons, it helps to have a familiar face on the scene to help make things click faster.For Hillsborough quarterback Charlie Dean, fresh from playing for Tampa Catholic last fall, that per...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Romano: A fresh start for Florida to protect abused children

Romano: A fresh start for Florida to protect abused children

The worst job in Florida is available, once again.Mike Carroll has announced his pending resignation as secretary of the Department of Children and Families, giving someone else the privilege to be an underfunded, second-guessed punching bag. For no ...
Published: 08/18/18
Putting a face to the name: Picture of Marine killed in Vietnam one of the missing

Putting a face to the name: Picture of Marine killed in Vietnam one of the missing

Private Ruben Bell Jr. has a name, a rank, a hometown, five service medals and several living family members. For 50 years, though, he has remained a ghost.Bell enlisted in the Marine Corps in July 1967, when he was 19, and arrived in Vietnam that De...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Jameis Winston vs. Marcus Mariota: The stats that matter

Jameis Winston vs. Marcus Mariota: The stats that matter

Yeah, but …Every Jameis Winston-Marcus Mariota debate is full of them.Winston has completed more passes (939), gained more passing yards (11,636) and thrown more passing touchdowns (69) before his age 24 season than any quarterback in NFL histo...
Updated: 8 hours ago
It’s David Price time, from Rays ‘openers’ to rise of Blake Snell

It’s David Price time, from Rays ‘openers’ to rise of Blake Snell

BOSTON — David Price heard about the recent reunion of the Rays' 2008 American League championship club that he played a big role on as a small part of, and he had a few questions.What players were there? How did it go? Did second baseman Akino...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Rays journal: A 3-0 first-inning lead turns into a loss to powerful Red Sox

BOSTON — Scoring three runs in the top of the first inning is typically a good start toward a victory.But not so much at cozy Fenway Park.And definitely not against these red-hot Red Sox.Facing their AL East rivals for the first time since late...
Updated: 9 hours ago
From Hawaii to the honky-tonk: Nashville’s in love with Marcus Mariota

From Hawaii to the honky-tonk: Nashville’s in love with Marcus Mariota

NASHVILLE — Ten thousand blue leis were distributed to Titans fans for the NFL draft on the day their team picked Marcus Mariota.The 2014 Heisman Trophy winner wasn't even at Nissan Stadium for the party, which drew a crowd of 20,000. But the w...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Preseason football: Clearwater Central Catholic 24, Wiregrass Ranch 14

Preseason football: Clearwater Central Catholic 24, Wiregrass Ranch 14

WESLEY CHAPEL — Clearwater Central Catholic, held to 11 yards rushing in the first half, turned on the power game behind senior Casey Levy, whose 120-yard performance helped carry the visiting Marauders to a 24-14 win at Wiregrass Ranch.Levy’s lone t...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Preseason football: Tampa Bay Tech 54, Brandon 6

TAMPA — Tampa Bay Tech earned all the momentum it needed heading into next week’s sizable test at Armwood.The Titans powered by visiting Brandon 54-6 in a preseason classic on Friday night. The game was cruising along until a 20-minute lightning dela...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Preseason football: Tampa Catholic 36, Robinson 15

TAMPA — First-year Tampa Catholic coach Jeris McIntyre hasn’t named a starting quarterback yet, but Dylan McCain shined in his job interview Friday, running a Crusader offense that scored 22 points in the second half on the way to a 36-15 preseason v...
Updated: 10 hours ago