Thursday, May 24, 2018
News Roundup

He liked something on Facebook. Then he went to jail.

The judge warned Timothy Weiner to stop harassing his ex-wife on Facebook.

"Neither parent," Pasco Circuit judge Lauralee Westine wrote in her order after the September hearing, "shall disparage or threaten the other parent on social media."

But a week later, a photo of his ex-wife surfaced on a father’s rights Facebook page called "Mothers who abuse kids." Weiner hit the "like" button.

That was enough for Westine to send Weiner, of New Port Richey, to the county jail for criminal contempt.

The case illustrates how the ubiquitous use of social media is impacting the courts system in Florida and beyond.

"This is a side of the law that’s starting to get a little bit more clarity," said Ethan Wall, a Miami lawyer who runs the firm Social Media Law and Order. "Social media really intersects all cases, big, small, criminal, civil, you name it. People are tweeting, posting, and poking."

From warning jurors not to check Facebook or Twitter during a trial to an upcoming Florida Supreme Court decision that will define what a Facebook "friend" really is, lawyers and judges are confronted with navigating the complexities of social media.

• • •

When Alexander Graham Bell received his patent on the telephone in 1876, many law firms refused to use the new device.

One well-known lawyer noted that phones were "destroying the simplicity of American life," wrote University of Miami law professor Jan Jacobowitz in a law review article.

Then came fax machines, e-mails, and now: social media.

Society’s latest form of communication has permeated every crevice of the law.

RELATED COVERAGE: Now comes the Florida Supreme Court, live on Facebook.

In divorce cases, for example, St. Petersburg lawyer Charles Hinton has seen such an increase in the number of people who attack their former spouses online that he now makes sure court orders include language that specifies former partners will not insult each other on the web.

"They go on social media and they trash their exes and they say untrue things," said Hinton, who is representing Weiner’s ex-wife, Jesica Wingo. "Most people cannot grasp the permanence of social media. It doesn’t disappear. It’s out there."

Take the Weiner case. According to court records, Weiner and his current wife were harassing Wingo on Facebook.

The judge ordered all social media activity to stop. A few days later, Weiner liked the Facebook photo that got him in trouble.

Hinton also told Westine that his client had received several threatening text messages from an unknown number. Under oath in the courtroom, Weiner admitted to liking the post about his ex-wife. The judge sent him to jail for 60 days.

The next day, his lawyer, W. Matthew Kowtko, asked her to reconsider. His client is a military veteran with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Weiner’s time behind bars, he wrote, has shown him that any other violations "shall result in severe punishment."

The next day, Westine amended her ruling to time served and Weiner was released.

"I absolutely did not expect to go to jail," Weiner said. "My freedom of speech was violated even though I didn’t say anything. All I did was like a Facebook post."

It’s also affecting personal injury cases. A plaintiff might claim they can’t engage in physical activities. But on their Facebook profile, they’re zip lining during a recent vacation.

"People have to recognize how much their web presence is going to become part of the conversation in the event of litigation," said Stetson University law professor Charles Rose.

Social media is also considered in trials. Judges now instruct jurors not to talk about the case outside of the courtroom or online.

It’s rare for judges to declare mistrials because a juror checked or posted on social media, said Pinellas-Pasco circuit spokesman Stephen Thompson.

"Perhaps because jurors are told repeatedly not to do such a thing before they begin deliberating," he said.

In the Pinellas-Pasco circuit, judges tell jurors:

"I want to stress that you must not use electronic devices or computers to talk about this case, including tweeting, texting, blogging, e-mailing, posting information on a website or chat room, or any other means at all."

• • •

Applying the law to social media presents challenges.

It changes and advances much faster than the law can adapt, said Wall.

"By the time the rules catch up and the judges start applying these rules," he said, "Facebook will change its platform."

Courts also had to create rules for admitting social media as evidence, Wall added. Typically, lawyers can put a witness on the stand who is familiar with the posts or have an expert testify about its authenticity.

Another problem: consistency.

"Since we’re in the early stages relatively speaking of the social media invasion of the practice of law, we don’t have consistent rules about it," said Jacobowitz.

For example, some judges will instruct jurors not to check Twitter or Facebook. But others might take their phones away during trials.

Decisions on how to navigate social media have even reached the state’s highest court.

This summer, the Florida Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in a Miami case that could define what a Facebook friendship legally means.

Lawyers from the Miami firm Herssein and Herssein who are suing a former client asked the 3rd District Court of Appeal to disqualify the judge because she’s Facebook friends with a lawyer representing an executive listed as a defendant. But the appeals court denied their request, concluding that "a ‘friend’ on a social networking website is not necessarily a friend in the traditional sense of the word."

The lawyers appealed with the Florida Supreme Court. They argue that another appeals court ruled that Facebook friendships are a conflict of interest.

Jacobowitz, the law professor, suspects that social media-related cases will only become more prevalent.

"But it will also become just more typical and there will be more court decisions," she said. "Every judge is sort of out there figuring it all out."

Times senior news researcher John Martin contributed to this report. Information from the Miami Herald was used in this report. Contact Laura C. Morel [email protected] Follow @lauracmorel.

Comments
Behind the deal: $52 million boutique hotel coming to Ybor City started with cafe con leche at La Tropicana Cafe

Behind the deal: $52 million boutique hotel coming to Ybor City started with cafe con leche at La Tropicana Cafe

TAMPA — Joe Capitano Sr. invested in the 1400 block of E Seventh Avenue in 1985, never doubting the huge potential of the property for Ybor City.But the deal to build a $52 million boutique hotel on the site didn’t start to come together until six ye...
Updated: 12 minutes ago
Bucs union rep Ali Marpet questions legality of the NFL’s new anthem policy

Bucs union rep Ali Marpet questions legality of the NFL’s new anthem policy

Bucs offensive lineman Ali Marpet questioned the legality of the NFL's new  policy that requires players to stand for the national anthem if they are on the field during the performance but gives them the option to remain in the locker room if t...
Updated: 1 hour ago
When will the Lightning run out of wait-til-next-years?

When will the Lightning run out of wait-til-next-years?

TAMPA — Disbelief will eventually give way to acceptance.The Lightning isn't there yet.It isn't there yet in a lot of ways.Will it ever be?Just wondering.Really, what guarantees are there?Late Wednesday night, Washington Capitals captain A...
Updated: 1 hour ago
USF wins doubleheader to stay alive in AAC tourney

USF wins doubleheader to stay alive in AAC tourney

Its American Athletic Conference tournament hopes flat-lining, USF's baseball team has spent the past 30 or so hours reviving itself with plain ol' CPR.Clutch Pitching and Resolve.Needing back-to-back wins on a humid Clearwater day to remain alive, t...
Updated: 1 hour ago
One day after fatal accident, Tampa moves to lower speed limit on Bayshore Blvd

One day after fatal accident, Tampa moves to lower speed limit on Bayshore Blvd

TAMPA — Tampa officials said Thursday they are reducing the speed limit on Bayshore Boulevard, one day after a mother was struck and killed by a speeding car while pushing her 21-month-old daughter across the city’s signature street.Starting Friday, ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
A white supremacist killed her twin. Why did she forgive him?

A white supremacist killed her twin. Why did she forgive him?

As a fifth-grader, Aleesha Mance wrote an essay about her sister’s killer, explaining how peer pressure and drugs led the 17-year-old to make a deadly choice. In high school, she searched for his name online. She read news articles about a tee...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Updated: 1 hour ago
Woman who was raped as a teenager is awarded $1 billion in damages

Woman who was raped as a teenager is awarded $1 billion in damages

Hope Cheston was 14 when, outside a friend’s birthday party in October 2012 in Jonesboro, Georgia, an armed security guard at an apartment complex raped her on a picnic table.For years, she thought she’d be forgotten like countless other sexual assau...
Updated: 2 hours ago
NOAA: Scientists predict 10 to 16 named storms this hurricane season

NOAA: Scientists predict 10 to 16 named storms this hurricane season

Scientists are in consensus: The 2018 hurricane season could be an active one.On Thursday the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration released its 2018 Atlantic hurricane seasonal outlook. It’s calling for between 10 and 16 named storms, five...
Updated: 2 hours ago

Updated: 2 hours ago