Wednesday, December 13, 2017
News Roundup

Lawyers rate Pinellas and Pasco judges, but is survey valid?

The judges of Pinellas and Pasco counties make countless decisions on a dizzying variety of cases — wrongful deaths and wrong-way turns, last wills and first appearances, living wills and death penalties.

But this week the judges themselves have come under scrutiny, thanks to a survey of local lawyers that is stirring plenty of comment and controversy.

A newly formed legal group recently polled lawyers to ask about the demeanor, professionalism and fairness of local judges. It posted the results on a blog, floridayoujudge.com.

For lawyers and people involved in the legal system, the survey results are fascinating but also controversial.

Lawyer Haydee Oropesa, who started the survey with help from some of her well-known peers, said the results could provide a good way to let the public know how each judge is viewed by attorneys who are familiar with their work. After all, she said, the judges "get paid with taxpayer money; they serve the people." Also, she said, the survey could provide judges with information they could use to improve their work.

Oropesa said she hears from many people — some in her own family — who don't know how to vote in judicial races, and an outside evaluation like this can help.

"I want the community to understand who they elect as their public servant," Oropesa said.

But Pinellas-Pasco Chief Judge Thomas McGrady doesn't think the survey is valid. He points to the blog, which says that just 115 of 3,200 lawyers who were contacted by email actually returned surveys — less than 4 percent. He said there's no way the 115 lawyers know all 69 judges in the two counties.

"Is it a legitimate evaluation of the judges of the 6th Circuit? I would say no. It may be interesting, but it's not a true evaluation."

Incidentally, McGrady scored relatively high — 4.31 on a scale of 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent).

As in any poll, there are some winners and losers. Judges who received fairly low ratings included Circuit Judges Cynthia Newton (2.6), William Webb (2.63) and Nancy Moate Ley (2.98), along with Pasco County Judge Debra Roberts (2.5) and Pinellas County Judge Cathy McKyton (2.81). A rating of 2 is considered "average."

Highly rated judges included Pasco County judges Paul Firmani (4.55) and Frank Grey (4.72), along with Pinellas County Judge Edwin Jagger (4.66). A 4 is considered "very good."

The new group behind the survey calls itself the Association of Lawyers Promoting Judicial Excellence. Its "polling officers" for the survey included Oropesa, well-known criminal defense attorney Denis de Vlaming and defense attorney Sonny Im, a former Pinellas County judge.

This is not the first time local judges have been evaluated in surveys. The Clearwater and St. Petersburg Bar associations have done so.

Josh Chilson, president of the Clearwater Bar Association, said he intends to appoint a committee to discuss whether to revive its survey.

He said that move was not prompted by the new group's survey. After reviewing it, he said he had some concerns about its validity, particularly because of the small response rate.

Raleigh Greene, president of the St. Petersburg Bar Association, said he had not had a chance to review the new poll. He said his Bar association has no plans to revive its survey.

Curtis Krueger can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8232. Follow on Twitter @ckruegertimes.

Comments
Rick and Tom podcast: Should the Rays go full fire-sale mode?

Rick and Tom podcast: Should the Rays go full fire-sale mode?

As baseball’s hot stove starts heating up, should the Rays go full fire sale to build for the future?In their latest podcast, Rick Stroud and Tom Jones discuss whether the Rays should trade guys like Evan Longoria, Chris Archer, Alex Colome and more,...
Updated: 20 minutes ago
The Daystarter: Roy Moore won’t concede Alabama Senate race; ex-Tampa police sergeant learns fate; older Americans take too many unneeded pills; Rays’ dilemma: Retool or rebuild?

The Daystarter: Roy Moore won’t concede Alabama Senate race; ex-Tampa police sergeant learns fate; older Americans take too many unneeded pills; Rays’ dilemma: Retool or rebuild?

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what you need to know today.10News WTSPThe latest 7-day forecast• It was cold. Then it was warm. And now it will be cold again. Our yo-yo weather continues as another cold front rolls in and drops tempera...
Updated: 24 minutes ago
Tampa Yankees become Tampa Tarpons in a nod to history

Tampa Yankees become Tampa Tarpons in a nod to history

The Tampa Yankees have officially changed the name of the Class A Florida State League team to the Tarpons.The name change is a nod to the original Tampa Tarpons minor-league team that played at Al Lopez Field from 1957-87.For the first four years th...
Updated: 30 minutes ago
Picturing something different: St. Petersburg man finds second career as photographer

Picturing something different: St. Petersburg man finds second career as photographer

A chance meeting during a really tough time in Rossie Newson’s life resulted in him finding a talent he never knew he had. After leaving his job as an illustrator at the Tampa Bay Times in 2009, Newson devoted most of his time and energy to his fathe...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Daniel Ruth: Buckhorn stood with good ol’ boys as firefighter proved city harassed her

Daniel Ruth: Buckhorn stood with good ol’ boys as firefighter proved city harassed her

They tried to shut her up. They tried to make her go away. They made her life miserable. Yet Tanja Vidovic — persisted. Long before most people had ever heard of the knuckle-dragging sexually harassing escapades of oafs like Harvey Weinstein, ...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Woman, 54, killed while crossing U.S. 19 in Hudson

HUDSON — A Hudson woman died Tuesday evening after being struck by a car while crossing U.S. 19 near Babson Avenue, according to Florida Highway Patrol.Patricia Lynn Pla, 54, was crossing U.S. 19 westbound about 6:10 p.m. when troopers said she was s...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Nina Simone, Bon Jovi, The Cars top 2018 Rock Hall of Fame inductees

Nina Simone, Bon Jovi, The Cars top 2018 Rock Hall of Fame inductees

NEW YORK — Iconic singer Nina Simone and New Jersey rockers Bon Jovi lead the 2018 class of Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductees, which includes four first-time nominees. The Cars, as well as first-time contenders Dire Straits, The Moody Blues and Si...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Canseco’s tweets about sexual misconduct could jeopardize job on A’s telecasts

Canseco’s tweets about sexual misconduct could jeopardize job on A’s telecasts

LAKE BUENA VISTA — A series of tweets by former Tampa Bay Devil Rays and Oakland Athletics slugger Jose Canseco about sexual misconduct and politicians could put in jeopardy his job as a studio analyst on A’s telecasts. Canseco posted several times ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Flipping homes for big profits is getting harder in Tampa Bay

Flipping homes for big profits is getting harder in Tampa Bay

Michael Sadeghpour was just 18 when he did his first flip.Using money saved from a job and borrowed from his grandmother, he bought a foreclosed condo in north Pinellas County for $67,000. He did some inexpensive renovations and flipped it for $125,0...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Forecast: Warmer temperatures will follow another sunny, crisp day across Tampa Bay

Forecast: Warmer temperatures will follow another sunny, crisp day across Tampa Bay

Another dose of chilly temperatures is in store for the Tampa Bay region before a warming trend takes temperatures back into the 70s through next week.10News WTSPFeels-like temperatures around the Tampa Bay area Dry air and winds from the north are ...
Updated: 4 hours ago