Tuesday, April 24, 2018
News Roundup

As Supreme Court takes up individual mandate, conservative justices have hard questions

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court's most conservative justices and its crucial swing voter sharply questioned the government's right to force people to buy health insurance on Tuesday, leaving the centerpiece of President Barack Obama's signature achievement in doubt.

Immediately and throughout the extraordinary two-hour hearing on the second day of oral arguments on the federal health care law, the justices raised scenarios that amounted to a big what if.

If Congress can impose an "individual mandate" for health insurance, could it compel Americans to purchase cellphones, eat broccoli or obtain burial insurance?

"You don't know if you're going to need a heart transplant or if you ever will. So, there's a market there. In some extent, we all participate in it," Chief Justice John Roberts said. "So, can the government require you to buy a cellphone because that would facilitate responding when you need emergency services? You can just dial 911 no matter where you are."

Justice Antonin Scalia picked up the thread. "Everybody has to buy food sooner or later, so you define the market as food, therefore, everybody is in the market; therefore, you can make people buy broccoli," he said, adding, "If the government can do this, what else can it not do?"

Solicitor General Donald Verrilli countered each time, saying that health insurance was a distinct market and that Congress had a right to regulate it under the commerce clause and its taxing authority. Most Americans who do not have insurance after the mandate takes effect in 2014 would have to pay a penalty that would rise to $695 annually in 2016.

The mandate is the key point of the overall challenge before the court, and the arguments on Tuesday carried an air that history was in the making. In the rapt audience were members of Congress and the Obama administration, including Attorney General Eric Holder and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius.

With no decision expected until late June, both sides will have weeks to pound well-worn talking points. Pundits already were gaming the outcome.

Verrilli had a shaky performance, evident in almost the first words he spoke, followed by a gulp of water. "The Affordable Care Act addresses a fundamental and enduring problem in our health care system and our economy," he insisted.

His counterpart, Paul Clement, who is representing Florida and 25 other states challenging the law, was forceful and consistent, and argued that the mandate forces people to buy something they might not want.

"The mandate represents an unprecedented effort by Congress to compel individuals to enter commerce," Clement said.

Oral arguments are only part of a case, and justices may present a viewpoint for the sake of argument. Democrats held out hope the justices will make a deep review of the issues.

Obama and his allies are banking on precedent in which the court has largely backed Congress' ability to regulate commerce.

"I look back into history, and I see it seems pretty clear that if there are substantial effects on interstate commerce, Congress can act," said liberal Justice Stephen Breyer, invoking an old case in which the court found Congress could regulate wheat production and a recent one covering home-grown marijuana.

"Is this commerce? Well, it seems to me more commerce than marijuana," Breyer said.

Still, skepticism from the bench was abundant. Most worrisome for defenders of the law was Justice Anthony Kennedy joining the sharp questioning. Kennedy, appointed by Ronald Reagan, is often a swing vote in big cases.

At one point he said the mandate "changes the relationship of the federal government to the individual in a very fundamental way."

It raised the distinct possibility that the hard-to-read Kennedy will join Roberts, Scalia and the two other conservatives, Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas, in striking down the mandate. The four liberal justices — Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan — signaled their support for the mandate.

Thomas was the only justice who did not speak, but he reliably votes with the conservatives.

A 5-4 decision has always been a possibility, reflecting the ideological divide on the court. But an open question is which side will win over Kennedy.

Despite strong clues early on, he concluded his remarks by saying that the health care issue is unique and that "most questions in life are matters of degree."

Kennedy said the young and uninsured are affecting insurance rates and medical care costs "in a way that is not true in other industries" — effectively taking the Obama administration's view.

"It gave me pause," Nebraska Attorney General Jon Bruning said in an interview afterward. "I think he's very thoughtful. I think all the justices are trying to be very thoughtful about this case and I'm hopeful he'll do the right thing."

Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi said she is confident the court would discard the individual mandate. At a news conference with Republican members of Congress, she deemed the mandate "a government overreach like we have never seen before in our history."

U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., nodded to the congressional fight that would ensue if the mandate is ruled unconstitutional. "I hope that I can be a part of an effort here, to not just vote to repeal Obamacare, but to replace it," he said.

Democrats were far less upbeat, offering what seemed like token optimism that the law would be upheld. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., pointedly challenged CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin's contention that the hearing was a "train wreck" for Obama and the mandate would be found unconstitutional.

If the mandate is on the rocks, today's final day of arguments becomes critical. The arguments will deal with whether parts of the law — some of which have bipartisan support — can survive. The court also will hear arguments about whether the law's expansion of Medicaid is constitutional.

Outside the court, another day of boisterous demonstrations ensued with hundreds of people carrying signs for and against the law. "The mandate is needed because it gives teeth to the legislation," said Cedric Bright, a physician from North Carolina.

But the opposition was much larger and organized. "They make you buy health care, what's next? They going to make you buy broccoli?" said Joe Bodick, 51, echoing almost word for word what was said inside.

Bodick was part of a bus caravan from Pittsburgh that joined hundreds of other demonstrators in a rally organized by the conservative group Americans for Prosperity.

The court's decision this summer could instantly change the dynamics of the presidential race. The mandate was once an idea embraced by conservatives in opposing the last Democratic attempt at health care reform, during the Bill Clinton era, and is part of the plan passed in Massachusetts when Republican presidential front-runner Mitt Romney was governor — a point Verrilli made in his closing remarks.

Alex Leary can be reached at [email protected] Follow him on Twitter @learyreports.

Comments

A Sarasota girl nearly dies after accidentally ingesting pool water

It started off like a regular pool day at her grandparent’s home. Elianna Grace, 4, and other kids were having fun, blowing water out of pool noodles at each other.Then, as Elianna was blowing water out one end of the noodle, someone else accidentall...
Updated: 9 minutes ago
Solid waste director gets job back

Solid waste director gets job back

NEW PORT RICHEY — Pasco County is rehiring its former solid waste director who blew the whistle on a behind-the-scenes effort to buy a privately owned landfill in Sumter County. John Power, who worked previously for the county for 19 years, is schedu...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Sarasota student under fire over his racist ‘promposal’

Sarasota student under fire over his racist ‘promposal’

The Sarasota County School District has begun to address the community after a Riverview High School student’s racist prom proposal over the weekend went viral, including reaching out to the Sarasota chapter of the NAACP.High school senior Noah Crowl...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Top places to hang with your dog in Tampa Bay, from breweries to baseball games

Top places to hang with your dog in Tampa Bay, from breweries to baseball games

Dogs are more welcome in public than ever these days. Bars and restaurants are making themselves more pet-friendly and you can find weekly "yappy hours" happening at spots all over Tampa Bay. Add to that a healthy number of dog-approved events and e...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Court sides with human in copyright fight over monkey selfie

Court sides with human in copyright fight over monkey selfie

SAN FRANCISCO — A U.S. appeals court on Monday favored humans over animals in a novel copyright lawsuit filed over a series of entertaining selfies taken by a monkey with a toothy grin. U.S. copyright law does not allow lawsuits that seek to give ani...
Updated: 2 hours ago
USF extends Mark Harlan’s contract

USF extends Mark Harlan’s contract

As expected, USF athletic director Mark Harlan has signed a contract extension that will keep him at the school through the 2020-21 school year.Harlan recently entered the final year of the original five-year deal he signed in March 2014 that paid hi...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Top 5 at noon: NRA breaks fundraising record after Parkland massacre; attorneys: Seminole Heights murder suspect might be mentally ill; and more

Top 5 at noon: NRA breaks fundraising record after Parkland massacre; attorneys: Seminole Heights murder suspect might be mentally ill; and more

Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com.NRA BREAKS FUNDRAISING RECORD AFTER PARKLAND MASSACREAs the student-led March for Our Lives movement captured the nation’s attention in the weeks after the Parkland shooting, the other side o...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Buckhorn urged to name woman as fire chief in wake of discrimination suit

Buckhorn urged to name woman as fire chief in wake of discrimination suit

TAMPA — In the wake of a female firefighter’s victory against the city in a discrimination lawsuit, Mayor Bob Buckhorn is being urged to name a high-ranking woman to replace retiring fire Chief Tom Forward.Earlier this month, Buckhorn said he will na...
Updated: 2 hours ago
So far, Pasco’s tourism base: Floridians, Canadians

So far, Pasco’s tourism base: Floridians, Canadians

NEW PORT RICHEY – The typical tourist in Pasco County this year most likely is a Floridian.But there are lots of Canadians here as well. Nearly 80 percent drove, rather than flew, to the region. Forty percent stayed in hotels, but more than a quarter...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Girls hockey could replace boys lacrosse on Pasco tourism calendar

Girls hockey could replace boys lacrosse on Pasco tourism calendar

NEW PORT RICHEY – Hockey pucks could replace lacrosse balls as the required sports equipment for the holiday tourism season in Wesley Chapel.The Wickenheiser World Female Hockey Festival, founded by Canadian hockey player Hayley Wickenheiser, is seek...
Updated: 2 hours ago