Friday, November 24, 2017
News Roundup

Pam Bondi wants a say in dismissed Brooksville red-light camera cases

RECOMMENDED READING


BROOKSVILLE — Motorists with pending red-light camera citations rejoiced this month when a Hernando County judge decided to toss out right-on-red cases that came before him.

Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, however, was not pleased.

Bondi's office has filed a motion asking County Judge Donald E. Scaglione to set aside his orders dismissing 31 right-on-red cases from the city of Brooksville. Scaglione threw out the cases during his May 13 red-light camera docket on the grounds that the enforcement process for right-on-red cases is unconstitutional.

According to Bondi's May 23 motion, state law requires the attorney general to be notified and given an opportunity to be heard when a party alleges that a state law is unconstitutional. The motion asks Scaglione to order the 31 defendants to put their constitutional challenges in writing, then set a hearing to consider the challenges.

"(A) deprivation of such is a departure from the essential requirements of the law and due process," the motion says.

A spokeswoman for the Attorney General's Office declined to comment on the motion, but said it's the first time that a right-on-red challenge has been raised in central Florida.

Scaglione also declined to comment. But local attorneys say they expect he will schedule a single hearing to give Bondi's office, the affected defendants and their attorneys the chance to present arguments. If Scaglione doesn't change his mind and lets his order stand, Bondi's office can appeal to the 5th District Court of Appeal.

In the meantime, nothing changes, but the number of affected cases is expected to increase. Scaglione is slated to hear another red-light camera docket on Monday.

"He's got to go through the process, but I don't think he's going to change his mind," said Brooksville attorney Kristie Ruppe, who represented a defendant in one of the May 13 cases. "I think his reasoning is solid."

The city of Brooksville has cameras monitoring 16 approaches at eight intersections. Scaglione is one of two county judges who hear uniform traffic citation cases.

On May 7, Scaglione issued an order stating why he would begin dismissing right-on-red cases. The order only applies to cases heard in his courtroom and does not affect cases he heard previously.

Scaglione called the portion of the state law dealing with right-on-red violations "vague (and) arbitrary and capricious." Because of that, he wrote, enforcing violations is unconstitutional and a violation of due process rights.

As part of the Mark Wandall Traffic Safety Act governing traffic camera programs, the Florida Legislature in 2010 created a defense that says a right turn on red without stopping is permissible if the turn is made "in a careful and prudent manner." But the law's failure to define those terms leads to arbitrary rulings, Scaglione wrote.

Because cities and counties come up with their own definitions, Scaglione wrote, "There is no consistency … between jurisdiction boundaries."

Finally, Scaglione contends, the current law violates the due process rights of citizens because a rolling right turn on red can result in two different outcomes depending on whether an officer stops a driver or the turn is caught on camera.

On May 13, during his first red-light camera docket after issuing the order, Scaglione warned the 31 defendants that his order could be appealed and overturned, in which case they would wind up back in court.

Peyton Hyslop, who represented roughly a third of the defendants on the docket, noted that the uniform traffic citations are brought by the state.

"So it's kind of ludicrous for the attorney general to say she doesn't know what's going on in court when the state of Florida is the one that filed the cases," Hyslop said. "Now they're saying, 'We don't like what happened, so let us have a chance to come,' when they didn't think it was worth their time to be there to begin with."

Reach Tony Marrero at [email protected] or (352) 848-1431. Follow @tmarrerotimes on Twitter.

Comments
Mounted police patrol Seminole Heights after killings

Mounted police patrol Seminole Heights after killings

TAMPA — A Florida police department is using horse patrols in a neighborhood that’s been plagued by homicides in recent weeks. Officials in Tampa have been searching for the person — or people — responsible for shooting and killing four in the Semino...
Updated: 9 minutes ago
Tampa officer revives overdose victim in department’s first use of Narcan drug kit

Tampa officer revives overdose victim in department’s first use of Narcan drug kit

TAMPA — A Tampa Police officer administered the department’s first use of an overdose-reversal drug to revive a 27-year-old man on Friday.About 2 a.m., Tampa Police Officer Scott Seely responded to a call in east Tampa about a possible drug overdose,...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Lawsuit over Jolley Trolley dismissed

Lawsuit over Jolley Trolley dismissed

A federal judge on Tuesday dismissed a lawsuit against Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority that Cincinnati-based First Transit filed in April, alleging it lost the county’s trolley contract because a "who’s who of Clearwater" lobbied the board to cho...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Tampa providing emergency medical service at MacDill, including new ambulance

Tampa providing emergency medical service at MacDill, including new ambulance

TAMPA — Sick and injured people at MacDill Air Force Base now rely on crews from Tampa Fire Rescue for help, and soon, they’ll have their own dedicated ambulance.Last month, the Tampa City Council approved the purchase of a $323,000 Braun Super Chief...
Updated: 1 hour ago

State DOT looking for direction on Alt. U.S. 19 corridor

Residents can give their input on the future of the Alt. U.S. 19 corridor by attending two workshops hosted by the Florida Department of Transportation and Forward Pinellas, the county’s transportation and land-use arm.The agencies are developing a l...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Settlement approved for Treasure Island’s walkway cracks

Settlement approved for Treasure Island’s walkway cracks

TREASURE ISLAND — More than three years after cracks began appearing in its newly constructed mile-long Beach Trail walkway, the city has approved a settlement with the architect and contractors, and hired a new contractor to repair and rebuild the t...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Car-sized hole from broken water pipe closes road in Valrico

Car-sized hole from broken water pipe closes road in Valrico

VALRICO — A large hole that opened in Valrico’s Bloomingdale neighborhood on Thanksgiving day was caused by a broken water pipe, not a sinkhole, county officials said. The hole swallowed a Mini Cooper-sized chunk of Natures Way Boulevard, at the Elm ...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Study to determine number of red snapper in the Gulf

OCEAN SPRINGS, Miss. — A team of 21 scientists will conduct a study to estimate the number of red snapper in the U.S. waters of the Gulf of Mexico. The panel of researchers from universities and state and federal agencies was convened by the Mississi...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Newly engaged couple among three killed in wrong-way crash on I-75

Newly engaged couple among three killed in wrong-way crash on I-75

TAMPA — Last month, LaShay Waiters got down on one knee and proposed to Yvette Alexandre in front of their family and friends. About two weeks ago, the young couple found out Alexandre was pregnant."They had a great future together," said Waiters’ mo...
Updated: 2 hours ago

Police investigate suspicious package at Clearwater Babies"R"Us

CLEARWATER — Authorities evacuated a Babies"R"Us on Friday after reports of a suspicious package in a shopping cart.According to Clearwater police, someone noticed the package about 10:30 a.m. at the store at 21315 U.S. 19 N. The store was evacuated ...
Updated: 2 hours ago