Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Clearwater family sues contractor over man's fall, death

TARPON SPRINGS — As 96-year-old Andrew Brown attempted to leave his home the morning of Nov. 6, 2007, he encountered trouble.

Instead of stepping onto a porch, his feet hit air.

In a flash, Brown had tumbled to the ground and was seriously injured. Paramedics treated him at the scene and took him to a local hospital, but Brown never returned home.

He died four weeks later, leaving behind his wife, Sallie Mae Brown, now 86.

"She gets depressed because she misses him," said Mary Dorsett, Andrew Brown's stepdaughter.

Brown's death certificate listed the cause of death as "complications from blunt head trauma." But one question remained: Who was responsible for the accident?

The Browns' home at 724 Lincoln Ave. was being renovated when Brown fell, and a front porch that once met the doorway Brown exited had been removed, creating a significant dropoff.

A lawsuit filed by Brown's family in February claims the contractor was to blame for his death. The suit says James C. Miller Inc., which is based in Tarpon Springs, "failed to place a barrier at the front door."

Linnes Finney, attorney for the Brown family, refused to say how much the family is seeking. Dorsett said money is needed to cover her mother's living expenses, which include a car payment.

When reached by phone, James C. Miller declined comment and referred all questions about the suit to his attorney, Wade James. Calls to James have not been returned.

According to the Better Business Bureau, there have been no complaints made by consumers against Miller's company.

"I don't know what the defense is going to allege," Finney said.

It all started when Brown and his wife were awarded a $22,700 grant from Pinellas County through a senior assistance program to rehabilitate their home. The house, which Brown had helped his father build in 1920, was looking every bit its age.

Termites were having a field day, the floors were rotted out, the bathrooms were a disaster and the front porch needed to be replaced, Dorsett said.

"It was troubling to see the house falling apart," said Dorsett, 48, of Riverview.

The grant offered hope.

With it, the floors and bathrooms were to be repaired and a new front porch constructed. The Browns picked the contractor.

"They were excited," Dorsett said. "The porch was the big thing for both of them. They've loved to sit out in the summer and feel the breeze at night."

As the project moved forward, Miller's company simultaneously fixed the home's main bathroom and removed the old porch, Dorsett said.

The day Brown fell, he was headed outside after hearing the garbage truck and forgot the porch was gone, Dorsett said.

Finney said the contractor was supposed to secure the doorway.

"They left it open for anybody to fall out," Finney said. "It could have been anybody."

Construction continued, and the contractor never acknowledged the accident, Dorsett said.

Today, the home's floors are up to par, the bathroom is fixed and the new porch is in place.

But Brown's loss has left a void.

"I honestly believe that had he not fallen out that door," Dorsett said, "he would probably still be alive today."

Keith Niebuhr can be reached at or (727) 445-4156.

Clearwater family sues contractor over man's fall, death 05/05/09 [Last modified: Tuesday, May 5, 2009 8:20pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tarpon Springs fire chief to retire in September after 39 years

    Local Government

    TARPON SPRINGS — When Richard Butcher got involved with Tarpon Springs Fire Rescue in 1978, he had just moved down from Ohio.

    Tarpon Springs fire Chief Richard Butcher is retiring after 39 years of service.
  2. Seeking change, Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn goes outside for new fire marshal


    TAMPA — Sarasota County Fire Marshal John Reed has been hired as Tampa's new fire marshal, and Mayor Bob Buckhorn said he wants Reed to shake up Tampa Fire Rescue's building inspection bureau.

    Sarasota County Fire Marshal John Reed, 53, will make $118,310 a year as the new fire marshal for the city of Tampa. [City of Tampa]
  3. Ruth: Trump is no Boy Scout in speech to scouts


    It could have been worse. At least the Boy Scouts of America didn't invite Dennis Rodman to address its 19th jamboree to discuss American foreign policy with North Korea and the art of nose piercings.

    President Donald Trump addressed the Boy Scouts’ national jamboree in Glen Jean, W. Va.
  4. PSTA, wary of future cuts, keeps property tax rate steady

    Local Government

    ST. PETERSBURG — The Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority stands to lose $2 million a year if voters approve an expansion to Florida's homestead property exemption on the 2018 ballot.

    One of The PInellas Suncoast Transit Authority's hybrid busses. The PSTA's governing board voted Wednesday to maintain the current property tax rate. [JAMES BORCHUCK  |   Times]
  5. Rays power way to 5-1 win over Orioles on eve of crucial road trip

    The Heater

    St. PETERSBURG — The Rays didn't get many hits in the early going Wednesday, but they got a couple that went a long way and that was enough to beat the Orioles, 5-1.

    Rays right fielder Steven Souza Jr. (20) hugs catcher Jesus Sucre (45) after Souza's solo home run in the seventh inning. [WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times]