Friday, April 20, 2018
News Roundup

Federal judge sides with Scientology on refund issue

TAMPA — A federal judge has ruled in favor of the Church of Scientology, saying two former members must go through the church's internal arbitration process if they want a refund of more than $1.3 million in donations.

U.S. District Judge James D. Whittemore issued a 21-page order Friday stating that plaintiffs Luis and Rocio Garcia are bound by contracts they signed during their 28 years with the church that require them to use the arbitration process to get their money back.

The Garcias' closely watched lawsuit, filed in 2013, alleges the church used fraudulent, deceptive and high-pressure tactics to solicit donations. But now that the order has put their refund demands in church hands, the federal court proceedings are at a standstill.

In addition to donations, the California couple said they also paid deposits on Scientology counseling services, training and accommodations that were never provided.

According to Whittemore, the hearing was limited to two subjects: whether the church had arbitration procedures that were applicable to the Garcias' claims and whether the contracts they signed were unconscionable — that is "whether the complaining party lacked a meaningful choice when entering into the contract" or if it was "so unfair that enforcement should be withheld."

The Garcias contend that, with Scientology conducting the arbitration, they would never get a fair hearing on their refunds because the church now considers them enemies called "suppressive persons" or SPs. But Whittemore said he could not analyze that issue because the First Amendment prohibits him from interpreting religious matters such as Scientology's doctrine on SPs.

The judge did side with the Garcias in acknowledging that the church "failed to provide any convincing evidence" that it had a working process in place to oversee arbitration.

Furthermore, Whittemore wrote, "There has never been an arbitration in the church, further supporting plaintiff's arguments that no rules and procedures for conducting arbitration exist."

But the judge said the absence of particular rules does not make the church's arbitration clause unenforceable.

Because the contract does include information on the number of arbitrators, how they'd be selected, what matters they could arbitrate and if the decision was binding, Whittemore said the contract satisfies the essential requirements under Florida law.

Representatives from the church's media relations office did not respond to requests for comment.

The Garcias' attorney, Theodore Babbitt of West Palm Beach, said Monday he was surprised by the ruling, as the judge seemed to agree with the plaintiffs on many of the issues. He said he is scheduled to meet with the Garcias on Wednesday to discuss their next steps.

"That's up in the air yet," Babbitt said. "They're still considering whether to file a motion for rehearing and also other options that we have."

Babbitt said those options include an appeal and proceeding with the arbitration under the church's rules.

Contact Caitlin Johnston at [email protected] or (813) 661-2443. Follow @cljohnst.

Comments
Flight attendants say ‘appalling’ Southwest flight photo confirms it — you’re not paying attention to the safety demo

Flight attendants say ‘appalling’ Southwest flight photo confirms it — you’re not paying attention to the safety demo

Mario Nunez called it a "huge shaking my head moment" when the photo inside the cabin of Southwest Airlines flight 1380 appeared on his TV.The story was about a terrifying emergency landing after an engine exploded 20 minutes into a trip from New Yor...
Updated: 7 minutes ago
Owners say new house is a disaster; developer accuses them of ‘online terrorism’

Owners say new house is a disaster; developer accuses them of ‘online terrorism’

ST. PETERSBURG --- Stretched across the front of Tim and Hyun Kims’ two-year-old house is a big banner with the name of a developer and the words: "I have to fix my new house."Some of what needs fixing is instantly apparent. The front steps are too ...
Updated: 8 minutes ago
Tampa Bay students voice opinions on gun laws during school walkouts today

Tampa Bay students voice opinions on gun laws during school walkouts today

High school students from around the Tampa Bay area are participating in the National School Walkout today commemorating the shooting at Columbine High School in 1999 and calling for gun law reform.A large group of students from St. Petersburg High g...
Updated: 18 minutes ago

Goodman: In America, truth is missing in action

It’s "Mueller Time," as the nation grows ever closer to a confrontation with the truth.Was collusion with the Russians an illusion? If not, who was involved, what was done, and when? Did it impact the 2016 campaign, the fate of Hillary Clinton and no...
Updated: 26 minutes ago
Suspect in Gilchrist deputies’ slayings has Tampa Bay ties

Suspect in Gilchrist deputies’ slayings has Tampa Bay ties

The man identified as the suspect who fatally shot two Gilchrist County deputies in a restaurant Thursday afternoon before taking his own life has ties to the Tampa Bay area.Deputies say John Hubert Highnote, 59, of Bell — who was found dead outside ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Top 5 at noon: Suspect in Gilchrist deputies’ slayings has Tampa Bay ties; man gets life sentence in Freedom High student’s 2015 shooting death; and more

Top 5 at noon: Suspect in Gilchrist deputies’ slayings has Tampa Bay ties; man gets life sentence in Freedom High student’s 2015 shooting death; and more

Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com:SUSPECT IN GILCHRIST DEPUTIES’ SLAYINGS HAS TAMPA BAY TIESThe man identified as the suspect who fatally shot two Gilchrist County deputies in a restaurant Thursday afternoon before taking his...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Today: Area high school students to join national walkout in memory of Columbine

Today: Area high school students to join national walkout in memory of Columbine

High school students from both sides of Tampa Bay will commemorate the anniversary of the Columbine High School shootings on Friday, although in very different ways. In St. Petersburg, students from several schools will gather at noon at City Hall f...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Man gets life sentence in Freedom High student’s 2015 shooting death

Man gets life sentence in Freedom High student’s 2015 shooting death

TAMPA — After David Brunson murdered an 18-year-old Freedom High School senior, he told a witness the victim was "just some ghetto kid nobody will miss."But people do miss Eion Gustitis.More than two years after Gustitis was shot in the head in a rem...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Shaquem Griffin is about to join a long line of NFL draft picks from Lakewood

Shaquem Griffin is about to join a long line of NFL draft picks from Lakewood

ST. PETERSBURG — Former Lakewood High coach Brian Bruch started each season with the same spiel. He cautioned his players about not becoming obsessed with a professional football career, reciting statistics to emphasize the difficult the odds o...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Former Ohio State, University of Tampa coach Earle Bruce dies

Former Ohio State, University of Tampa coach Earle Bruce dies

Former Ohio State football coach Earle Bruce, whose nine-year tenure in Columbus came after one season as coach of the University of Tampa's now-defunct program, passed away earlier this morning at age 87.Mr. Bruce reportedly had been battling Alzhei...
Updated: 1 hour ago