Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Hillsborough schools sued again over teen's suicide after sexting, bullying

Their daughter had said she wanted to kill herself, and they didn't know.

But a school counselor did.

Nearly three years later and after a failed federal lawsuit, the teen's parents still seek to hold the Hillsborough County School Board accountable.

In a wrongful-death lawsuit filed in Hillsborough Circuit Court last month, the parents of Hope Witsell blame local school officials for neglecting to ensure the safety of their daughter and only child on the day before she committed suicide at home.

At the time of her death, Hope was an eighth-grader at Shields Middle School in Ruskin.

The lawsuit faults the school district for not telling Charles and Donna Witsell about a September 2009 counseling session Hope had with Shields social worker Jody Orlando. During the session, she expressed suicidal thoughts and signed a "no-harm" contract. In the contract, Hope agreed to not attempt suicide and to call the counselor if she felt suicidal.

The next day, a Saturday, Hope hanged herself in the bedroom while her parents watched television downstairs.

Other students had bullied Hope, 13, after a sexting incident. She sent a cellphone photograph of her breasts to a crush — and then the nude photo circulated among other students. A lengthy Times story detailed how the fallout chipped away at the enthusiastic student who was a member of the FFA, formerly known as Future Farmers of America.

The school district has not commented on Hope's suicide or her interaction with school officials, citing student privacy laws.

For this article, school district spokeswoman Linda Cobbe declined to comment on the ongoing lawsuit but said the legal complaint includes inaccurate claims. She declined to elaborate.

Speaking generally about district policies, Cobbe said the School Board approved a bullying and violence prevention policy in December 2008. It followed a state law passed that year mandating that schools establish antibullying policies.

Guidance counselors and staff also receive training from psychological services for handling student suicide threats or attempts, Cobbe said.

The lawsuit accuses the school district of not following its procedures for suicide prevention and not properly assessing Hope's case.

The Witsells' attorney, Richard Alvarez, did not return a call for comment. The couple are seeking unspecified damages for Hope's death.

It's similar to a lawsuit the Witsells filed in federal court last year. U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday dismissed that case on March 5.

The federal lawsuit accused the school district of violating Hope's 14th Amendment rights, saying that the actions of school officials deprived her of her life without due process of the law.

But Merryday determined the school district had no constitutional obligation to protect Hope from self-harm outside the school. Nor did he find that the school'' policies or actions made her more vulnerable to harm.

"With the absence of finding a constitutional duty, and, consequently, with the absence of finding the violation of a constitutional right," Merryday wrote in the order's footnotes, "a discussion of the School Board's alleged deliberate indifference to an absent or hypothetical constitutional right proves awkward, irrelevant, and ultimately unnecessary."

Stephanie Wang can be reached at or (813) 661-2443.

Hillsborough schools sued again over teen's suicide after sexting, bullying 05/03/12 [Last modified: Thursday, May 3, 2012 4:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Fred Clutterbuck poses for a photo in front of the "Dunkirk" movie poster at the Cobb Theatre in Tyrone on Friday. Clutterback is a survivor of the Dunkirk evacuation. [EVE EDELHEIT | Times]
  2. Clearwater driver charged as 10th person dies in sweltering San Antonio truck


    SAN ANTONIO — The Clearwater driver of a sweltering Texas tractor-trailer was charged Monday with transporting immigrants illegally, resulting in the deaths of 10 people.

    James Mathew Bradley Jr., 60, of Clearwater, left, arrives at the federal courthouse for a hearing, Monday, July 24, 2017, in San Antonio. Bradley was arrested in connection with the deaths of multiple people packed into a broiling tractor-trailer. [Associated Press]
  3. Bank of Tampa expanding into Sarasota


    TAMPA — The Bank of Tampa is expanding to Sarasota County. It opened a loan office this month in downtown Sarasota at 1858 Ringling Blvd., which will be converted to a full-service branch within the year, the company said in a release Monday.

    The Bank of Tampa is expanding to Sarasota. Charles Murphy, pictured, will lead the Sarasota branch. | [Courtesy of The Bank of Tampa]
  4. Jeb Bush: Anthony Scaramucci will help Trump


    WASHINGTON - Before he discovered unyielding love for Donald Trump, Anthony Scaramucci, the new White House communications director, was a Jeb Bush man.

    Anthony Scaramucci, the new White House communications director
  5. Tampa Bay home prices still climbing, though more slowly

    Real Estate

    Tampa Bay home prices rose again in June, although the once-torrid pace of increases shows signs of slowing.

    This three story home in Port Richey's gated Harborpointe sold for $1.15 million in June, making it the top sale in Pasco County for the month.
[Penny Perry]