Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge hears arguments in Hillsborough rezoning lawsuit

TAMPA — On a triangular piece of land, developers envisioned a retail and office park with second-floor apartments. No more orange groves, no more cow pastures.

The application to rezone the 19 agricultural acres in Valrico for commercial use went in front of several county agencies and officials: planning commission, land-use officer, zoning hearing master.

Every agency recommended the application for approval. But last year the Hillsborough County Commission denied the rezoning request.

Property owner Greg Henderson of GLH Enterprises sued the county for denying the rezoning application on what his attorneys say were unlawful grounds, arguing the case Monday in Hills­borough Circuit Court.

"GLH met its burden," attorney Vincent Marchetti said. "It met all of its requirements."

As of press time, the judge hadn't ruled on the case.

The land borders Lithia-Pinecrest, Brooker and Valrico roads. In January 2010, commissioners voiced concerns over the proposed 100,000-square-foot development drawing higher traffic to roads and intersections that wouldn't be able to handle the increase.

But GLH Enterprises' attorneys say traffic issues aren't a legitimate basis for denying the rezoning application, distinguishing zoning entitlements from the development stages.

"All we're asking for are the rights," said Chris Torres, who also represented the property owner.

Traffic and road conditions will factor into later phases, such as seeking building permits, that require separate county approval, the attorneys said. A condition of the rezoning application also called for limiting development to 25,000 square feet until the county widens Lithia-Pinecrest Road, the attorneys said.

The attorneys argued the county's comprehensive plan, which sets guidelines for growth management, includes traffic concerns as an element of development.

Torres pointed out that the rezoning denial came during an election year, when the commission may have felt pressured by re-election amid the turnout of many concerned residents opposing the development.

• • •

At the County Commission meeting last year, GLH Enterprises attorney Marchetti refused an opportunity to remand the application because he said the requirements and conditions had already been met.

Defending the commission's decision, senior assistant county attorney Louis Whitehead III said Lithia-Pinecrest has long been tagged as a failing thoroughfare, and the widening project remains unfunded.

Under the county's comprehensive plan, Whitehead argued, the commission has a responsibility to examine transportation. He noted that the agencies that reviewed the application were wrong to have sent it to commissioners with unresolved traffic issues.

Hillsborough Circuit Judge Robert A. Foster Jr. questioned both sides: Did the commissioners need to give specific reasons for denying the approval?

He asked Whitehead this again and again, until the county attorney finally answered, "No."

Can Foster, as the judge, order the application back to the County Commission for review?

Yes, said the attorneys for GLH Enterprises.

Is it important for Foster to drive down Lithia-Pinecrest Road to understand the conflicts?

Yes, someone in the courtroom whispered.

A dozen of the parcel's neighbors sat through the arguments, wearing red. Residents have protested the development throughout the two-year process, fearing standstill traffic on their streets and glaring shopping center lights streaming into their back yards.

Stephanie Wang can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 661-2443.

Judge hears arguments in Hillsborough rezoning lawsuit 04/07/11 [Last modified: Thursday, April 7, 2011 4:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Hudson man, 19, killed by hit-and-run driver while walking in street, FHP says


    A 19-year-old Hudson man walking in the street Friday night was struck and killed by a pickup truck that fled the scene, the Florida Highway Patrol said.

  2. Road Ranger hurt after truck catches fire in crash at I-275, Busch


    TAMPA — A Road Ranger was seriously injured when a drunk driver ran into the back of his truck on Interstate 275 and both vehicles burst into flame, the Florida Highway Patrol said.

    Brian Nelson Barrett, 42, of Wimauma, was headed north on I-275 in his Road Ranger truck Saturday morning 10/21/17 when a car hit him from behind, causing both vehicles to erupt in flames.
  3. Nicked-up Lightning vs. Penguins tonight



  4. Trump to allow the release of JFK assassination records


    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump says he doesn't plan to block the scheduled release of thousands of never publicly seen government documents related to President John F. Kennedy's assassination.

    FILE - In this Nov. 22, 1963 file photo, President John F. Kennedy waves from his car in a motorcade in Dallas. Riding with Kennedy are First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy, right, Nellie Connally, second from left, and her husband, Texas Gov. John Connally, far left.  President Donald Trump, on Saturday, Oct. 21, 2017,  says he plans to release thousands of never-seen government documents related to President John F. Kennedy's assassination.  (AP Photo/Jim Altgens, File) NY107
  5. Romano: C'mon Rick Baker, tell us how you really feel about Trump

    Local Government

    A brief timeline of presidential politics in St. Petersburg:

    Rick Baker, center,  waves to drivers while holding a sign that reads "Thank You" along with his family and supporters.