Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Local car noise case makes it all the way to the state Supreme Court

TALLAHASSEE — The case of a Clearwater driver fighting a $73.50 ticket for playing his car stereo too loud made it all the way to the Florida Supreme Court Thursday.

Richard Catalano's argument: His right to blast his music as loud as he wants is protected by the First Amendment.

Catalano has been fighting a state noise law since 2007 when he was pulled over for playing a Justin Timberlake song too loud. (He won't say what song.)

"I like Justin, so there!" Catalano, a corporate lawyer, said after the 45-minute hearing. "Who would have thought I'd get to the Supreme Court over a 73 dollar ticket?"

At issue is whether the state law violates the U.S. Constitution by restricting some types of expression but not others. The state law bans "plainly audible" noise from a motor vehicle at a distance of 25 feet or more, but does not apply to businesses or political speech, which have a higher First Amendment protection.

In other words, the right to blare Rush Limbaugh is protected. But Led Zeppelin is not.

Catalano argued that the state law is too vague, too restrictive and invites arbitrary enforcement.

To illustrate his point Thursday, he backed 25 feet away from the justices, waived his arms in the air, and asked, "Can you hear me over here? This is a conversational tone. I should be given a ticket? That's what they're doing. That's why I'm here."

Timothy Osterhaus, a lawyer for the state, told judges that the law "has to start somewhere" to protect drivers' safety and ensure that they can hear emergency vehicles and other traffic.

Catalano said he had no problem hearing the siren when the police officer pulled him over to give him the citation.

The Supreme Court hearing follows a circuit court ruling that agreed with Catalano and invalidated the law. The 2nd District Court of Appeal in Lakeland upheld the circuit court ruling in May. The judges could take months to decide the case, which will likely mark the end of a four-year legal battle that has been closely followed by local governments looking for guidance on how to write and enforce noise ordinances.

In January, Pinellas County launched "Operation Lower the Boom" to encourage people to report noise disturbances that are "unreasonably loud and raucous."

Catalano is convinced his court challenges shaped that ordinance.

"They see the writing on the wall, and that this state statute is going to go bye, bye," he said. "They have crafted the local ordinance to be much more constitutional."

Brittany Alana Davis can be reached at

Local car noise case makes it all the way to the state Supreme Court 02/09/12 [Last modified: Thursday, February 9, 2012 3:36pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. President Trump: Nation's culture being 'ripped apart' by Civil War statue removals


    WASHINGTON — Showing his characteristic refusal to back down in the face of criticism, President Donald Trump deepened his defense of Confederate war memorials Thursday, sending out a series of messages on Twitter that adopted the language and arguments of white nationalists who have opposed their removal.

    President Donald Trump points to members of the media as he answers questions in the lobby of Trump Tower in New York on Tuesday. Republican leaders on Wednesday tiptoed around Trump's extraordinary comments on white supremacists.  [Associated Press]
  2. With election heating up, Bill Nelson floods Tampa Bay


    Sen. Bill Nelson seems to have set up a residency in Tampa Bay, a crucial area for his upcoming re-election campaign.

    Nelson campaigns with his wife in Orlando in 2012
  3. Martinez Middle School evacuated after bomb threat


    LUTZ — Bob Martinez Middle School has been evacuated after someone called in a bomb threat, the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office said.

  4. Another local Confederate display sparks division, this one over name of the war


    TAMPA — While the Hillsborough County commission was wrestling over the future of Confederate monument at the county courthouse, a lawsuit has been playing out in court over how best to represent the Civil War across town at Veterans Memorial Park.

    Supporters of a Civil War display at Veterans Memorial Park and Museum had a brochure made to attract donations. They argue in a lawsuit that their efforts were thwarted when the park's executive committee changed their plans.
  5. Myrtle Avenue closed, man hospitalized after Clearwater bike crash


    CLEARWATER — Myrtle Avenue is closed in both directions following a bicycle crash that hospitalized a man with serious injuries.